Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Tiger5150]

Any truth to the rumour swap Moylan to tigers and Josh reynolds to sharks ?


Is there any benefit in that for the players or clubs? I can’t see a benefit for WT after Moylan has already scrubbed us?

When we were rumoured to be signing him (last year?) I wasn't a huge fan. But if it's a straight swap for someone who never plays anyway, he could be a handy pick up.

Agreed. If a straight swap and for only one year I cant see a downside. Moylan isnt worth that kind of money but is a much better player than Reynolds.

 

[frullens]

Any truth to the rumour swap Moylan to tigers and Josh reynolds to sharks ?


Is there any benefit in that for the players or clubs? I can’t see a benefit for WT after Moylan has already scrubbed us?

When we were rumoured to be signing him (last year?) I wasn't a huge fan. But if it's a straight swap for someone who never plays anyway, he could be a handy pick up.


Agreed. If a straight swap and for only one year I cant see a downside. Moylan isnt worth that kind of money but is a much better player than Reynolds.

Apparently he's not a great trainer.
Not sure he's a great for for what Madge is trying to build.
But madge would no better than anyone what he needs

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

not a fan of moylan but he could fill the fb role with AD at 6 and JAC on a wing.
The article is under a pay wall but also heard it from a mate that has a connection with Morris so don't know how true it is

 

[Tiger5150]

Any truth to the rumour swap Moylan to tigers and Josh reynolds to sharks ?


Is there any benefit in that for the players or clubs? I can’t see a benefit for WT after Moylan has already scrubbed us?

When we were rumoured to be signing him (last year?) I wasn't a huge fan. But if it's a straight swap for someone who never plays anyway, he could be a handy pick up.


Agreed. If a straight swap and for only one year I cant see a downside. Moylan isnt worth that kind of money but is a much better player than Reynolds.

Apparently he's not a great trainer.
Not sure he's a great for for what Madge is trying to build.
But madge would no better than anyone what he needs

He only needs to be better than Reynolds to improve the team

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Harry Grant to the Gold Coast if Smith plays on that is the other rumour circulating around. I would be filthy

 

[The-moP]

So trade / swap an injury prone $800+K bench player for what ... another injury prone $800+K player ... great just great.

 

[TigerWest]

Any truth to the rumour swap Moylan to tigers and Josh reynolds to sharks ?

We'd be going backwards, surely if true.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

A line up of the following would look ok.
1. Moylan
2. Nofo
3. Joey L
4. Momo / Mmbye / Talau
5. JAC
6. AD
7. Brooks

 

[The-moP]

Harry Grant to the Gold Coast if Smith plays on that is the other rumour circulating around. I would be filthy

Harry Grant will demand big dollars pretty soon .. maybe that's what the Titans are trying to offer .. we'll be ok with Liddle and young Simpkins coming through .. !!

I can see Cam Smith retiring at seasons end, and Harry Grant staying at Melbourne .. Storm's problem is with Brandon Smith, they'll have to offer him bigger dollars to stay with them as a bench player, or another club will pick him up .. !!

 

[voice_of_reason]

So trade / swap an injury prone $800+K bench player for what ... another injury prone $800+K player ... great just great.

As much as Josh Reynolds has had a tough time at the Tigers at least he comes across as a decent bloke who is liked by his peers.

Moylan comes across as a gold-star douche who's managed to get most of his playing cohorts offside.

For the sake of team harmony I hope this isn't true.

 

[TillLindemann]

Any truth to the rumour swap Moylan to tigers and Josh reynolds to sharks ?

We'd be going backwards, surely if true.

How though? Reynolds doesn't even play.

 

[Roar_Power]

Moylan's hamstrings are shot. He'd be lucky to play 10 games.

 

[TheDaBoss]

if anybody cares

Cameron King retired

 

[Bones]

Well Campbell graham has been dropped for tomorrow nights game so he can’t be going that good

Injured not dropped.

Wayne’s telling porkies, he knows his stuff

He came off injured last week... but I know it suits your argument to say he was dropped.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Harry G is a must if he comes onto the open market he can bring simpkin through, push Liddle out and use some of his cash to JAC for 2022

 

[tiger05premier]

Any truth to the rumour swap Moylan to tigers and Josh reynolds to sharks ?

I hope so, if it's a straight swap that's not a bad deal.

It's a bad deal if it's for longer than 1 year

 

[Tigerlily]

A line up of the following would look ok.
1. Moylan
2. Nofo
3. Joey L
4. Momo / Mmbye / Talau
5. JAC
6. AD
7. Brooks

Moylan? Surely thats a misprint JD?.😱

That’s a real concern if WTHQ have even contemplated signing that waste of space.

 

[dazza65]

Harry Grant to the Gold Coast if Smith plays on that is the other rumour circulating around. I would be filthy

they must have uncle nicks spare sombrero - Fifita, Tino, Herbert, Ese'ese, plus resigning Proctor, Brimson, Fogarty, Sami.......

 

[dazza65]

I read somewhere we have released Momirovski - anyone aware?

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

jeez didn't know we release Mommo wow