Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

@needaname said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394405) said:
@momo_amp_medo said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394237) said:
“I think our roster this year is far better than it was last year.

This statement really concerns me.
In what area of assessment of our personal is this statement quantified against?
If we are honest we have potentially a better roster or at least we have more growth in our roster this year but performance wise our roster would be blown apart by last years team in its current form.
They are in denial big time.

I would say yes it is better but we are still deficient in a few areas FB CENTRE forwards we have more forwards than you can poke a stick at it just a matter of getting them all fit and the right mix
 
@tigerap said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394137) said:
Hastings could be our dominant halfback next year, he has arrogance, a loud voice and a great kicking game…move Brooks to 6 with one instruction, run, run Forrest run…brooks doesn’t seem to have the IQ a good half needs

This. We have to give this a shot if Brooks is still around. Hopefully this year sees and end to the 10 year experiment of trying to make Brooks be something he isn’t.
 
Not trying to be disrespectful but we have paid big $$ for non specialist players in spine positions that we now have to play elsewhere. We have 2 failed full backs in Douglhie and Mbye. We should have just signed a specialist. Throw Hynes, Reynolds and B Smith into our team and we aren't where we are today.
 
@izotope said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394342) said:
@jc99 said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394339) said:
Idea: let's sign Tommy turbo. 2 million dollars a year

We had the "big three/four" and still sucked donkey then as well

Teddy was pretty damn good
 
Mbye and Nofoaluma need to be moved on ASAP, drop both of them this week, Madden in for Mbye at least he will try his guts out. Jet one last chance on the wing, Tuilagi needs to be promoted in the hope he can soon replace Garner. If Blore is fit he starts, luci to the bench. Simpkin back for Liddle and Tamou to the bench. Seyfarth starts at 13.
 
@needaname said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394405) said:
@momo_amp_medo said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394237) said:
“I think our roster this year is far better than it was last year.

This statement really concerns me.
In what area of assessment of our personal is this statement quantified against?
If we are honest we have potentially a better roster or at least we have more growth in our roster this year but performance wise our roster would be blown apart by last years team in its current form.
They are in denial big time.

If you swap out JTJ and TT with Justin Olam and Joseph Manu, how do you reckon we go?
 
@tony-soprano said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394205) said:
@spud_murphy said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394150) said:
@haberfield_tiger said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394132) said:
Until we move brooks on we won't win anything. Need a dominate 7 the can dig us out of a hole and lead us forward...

To be fair to Brooks I don’t think even Cleary or Cronk at his best would’ve dug us out of the hole we got in last night. That said, he has been the common denominator in a key position during the club’s long stretch of non-success.

We’d be in the finals if Ivan and Nathan come here. Put it that way.

You mean the Ivan that absolutely nuked our salary cap with some of the worst signings in our club's history? That Ivan?
 
@spud_murphy said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394395) said:
@tony-soprano said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394205) said:
@spud_murphy said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394150) said:
@haberfield_tiger said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394132) said:
Until we move brooks on we won't win anything. Need a dominate 7 the can dig us out of a hole and lead us forward...

To be fair to Brooks I don’t think even Cleary or Cronk at his best would’ve dug us out of the hole we got in last night. That said, he has been the common denominator in a key position during the club’s long stretch of non-success.

We’d be in the finals if Ivan and Nathan come here. Put it that way.

Yes sliding door moment that’s come back to bite us on the arse over and over. Same as us getting Madge and Souths getting Bennett when they were both being courted by us two years ago.

And what's to say we wouldn't get the Newcastle or England version of Bennett?

Bennett's a myth, he does well at clubs packed with stars, but there's no evidence to suggest he would get any more out of this squad than our last 4 coaches.
 
@tigger19 said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394435) said:
Mbye and Nofoaluma need to be moved on ASAP, drop both of them this week, Madden in for Mbye at least he will try his guts out. Jet one last chance on the wing, Tuilagi needs to be promoted in the hope he can soon replace Garner. If Blore is fit he starts, luci to the bench. Simpkin back for Liddle and Tamou to the bench. Seyfarth starts at 13.


Don't forget Cooper, an outside back that can tackle.
 
@lauren said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1393948) said:
Know this is totally pointless but one can only dream.
My current wishlist includes Brandon Smith, Dale Finucane and Isaac Liu. Am also a fan of Connor Watson...could probably name a quarter of the NRL at this point in time 😂

Connor Watson is a good player getting shafted by the knights, I would look at him, and look at playing him 13, he is very strong for his size, and if a player goes down during the game, he covers 1, 6, 7 and 9
 
@tigerballs said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394437) said:
@needaname said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394405) said:
@momo_amp_medo said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394237) said:
“I think our roster this year is far better than it was last year.

This statement really concerns me.
In what area of assessment of our personal is this statement quantified against?
If we are honest we have potentially a better roster or at least we have more growth in our roster this year but performance wise our roster would be blown apart by last years team in its current form.
They are in denial big time.

If you swap out JTJ and TT with Justin Olam and Joseph Manu, how do you reckon we go?

Better?
 
@tigger19 said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394468) said:
Yes sorry Talau should be dropped as well, Cini,Hoffman or cooper given a shot

Jeez that talau and or nofo swap for JAC looked good.
 
@tigger19 said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394468) said:
Yes sorry Talau should be dropped as well, Cini,Hoffman or cooper given a shot

Cooper for mine. We need improvements in defence and I reckon he’s got it
 
@cochise said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394240) said:
@momo_amp_medo said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394237) said:
@tony-soprano said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394216) said:
Lee can’t help himself to name drop signings again

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theaustralian.com.au/sport/nrl/wests-tigers-chair-lee-hagipantelis-insists-there-is-light-at-the-end-of-the-tunnel/news-story/2761733d75ebc7b1055eb88e7d3994af

Anyone got access?

Wests Tigers chair Lee Hagipantelis insists there is light at the end of the tunnel
Wests Tigers chair Lee Hagipantelis has described the club’s hefty loss to the Melbourne Storm as inexplicable and indefensible. Still, he insists there is light at the end of the tunnel, coach Michael Maguire is the right man to take the club forward, and revealed the Tigers have held internal discussions over the prospect of signing Tevita Pangai and Dale Finucane.

Hagipantelis, like all Tigers supporters, was gobsmacked by the clubs performance against the Storm on Queensland’s Sunshine Coast on Saturday night. All up, the Tigers conceded 12 tries in a 66-16 shellacking that left the club’s supporters wondering once again whether they were making any progress.

“Last night was bitterly disappointing,” Hagipantelis told The Australian.

But I spent a lot of time with Michael Maguire this morning — he is hurting as we all are — and we all agree there is light at the end of the tunnel.

It is a journey, it really is a journey. There are going to be speed humps and difficulties along the way. We are absolutely committed to what we are doing, we are absolutely convinced we are progressing and the roster is improving.

“We are on a path we are all committed to and we will see it through.”

The Tigers trailed by 40 points at halftime at Sunshine Coast Stadium and Maguire was so disappointed with his side’s efforts, he walked out of the dressing sheds in disgust and left the players to ruminate on their first half display.

They responded to an extent in the second half, although they were also fortunate that Melbourne took their foot off the pedal. Hagipantelis was passionate in his defence of Maguire, who at times appears to be banging his head against a brick wall with some of his players.

“His passion and commitment and dedication — he is hurting as much as anyone,” Hagipantelis said.

“The absolute belief he has in this organisation and roster is infectious, absolutely infectious. That is what you want to see.

“That is what you want to see in your NRL head coach and he has that in spades. He is the right fella. We have to make sure we give him he roster and resources he needs.

“That is what we are building towards. As an organisation we are in this together. We had a lessen taught to us last night by whom I think is the benchmark in the competition.



They are an incredibly formidable organisation. We had our butts kicked last night and there is no point in sugarcoating that.

“I think our roster this year is far better than it was last year. Our recruitment and retention has significantly improved. We want to make sure we continue down that path but as I say last night was, I would hope to thin, an unfortunate anomaly.

Then again, this is a team that put 50 on Souths two weeks ago. You had the best 17 that Queensland had to offer have 50 put on them by NSW.

“There might be more to this than just the performance of a team. The new rules for example would have to have some role to play — 40 has become the new black in this game.”

“That doesn’t excuse 60 but the fact of the matter is that some of these top teams are capable of doing this.”

Asked about the prospect of signing Finucane or Pangai — the latter has been linked with the Tigers for weeks — Hagipantelis said: “These are names that have come up in conversation. I can’t deny that.

“We are looking to add anyone of quality. There is a process to go through. There are matters that are discussed internally but we are interested din any player that will add value to the organisation.”

Well that's it, TPJ and Finucane are no chance now.

I hope that also means Maguire is gone as well
 
@tigerballs said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394023) said:
Finucane, TPJ, Brandon Smith…they won’t make tackles for JTJ, TT, Nofo etc

Tamou is a little past it. Our younger forwards are better than him. The point is though that Tamou and our forwards in general aren't the issue. We just have too many players who are poor defensive players.

Nofo has been one of our best players for a couple of years but his defense is terrible. JTJ's defense is worse. I don't think I've seen a player make as many mistakes in first grade as TT. I think he has some talent and he could turn it around but he makes a lot of mistakes.

We need to fix our edges. It's our weakest area.
 
@earl said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394486) said:
@tigerballs said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394023) said:
Finucane, TPJ, Brandon Smith…they won’t make tackles for JTJ, TT, Nofo etc

Tamou is a little past it. Our younger forwards are better than him. The point is though that Tamou and our forwards in general aren't the issue. We just have too many players who are poor defensive players.

Nofo has been one of our best players for a couple of years but his defense is terrible. JTJ's defense is worse. I don't think I've seen a player make as many mistakes in first grade as TT. I think he has some talent and he could turn it around but he makes a lot of mistakes.

We need to fix our edges. It's our weakest area.

Perhaps we should play weakest link with the team. Who'd be the last man standing?
 
@mike said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394487) said:
@earl said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394486) said:
@tigerballs said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394023) said:
Finucane, TPJ, Brandon Smith…they won’t make tackles for JTJ, TT, Nofo etc

Tamou is a little past it. Our younger forwards are better than him. The point is though that Tamou and our forwards in general aren't the issue. We just have too many players who are poor defensive players.

Nofo has been one of our best players for a couple of years but his defense is terrible. JTJ's defense is worse. I don't think I've seen a player make as many mistakes in first grade as TT. I think he has some talent and he could turn it around but he makes a lot of mistakes.

We need to fix our edges. It's our weakest area.

Perhaps we should play weakest link with the team. Who'd be the last man standing?

Seyfarth
 
@earl said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394486) said:
@tigerballs said in [Signing Suggestions & Rumours](/post/1394023) said:
Finucane, TPJ, Brandon Smith…they won’t make tackles for JTJ, TT, Nofo etc

Tamou is a little past it. Our younger forwards are better than him. The point is though that Tamou and our forwards in general aren't the issue. We just have too many players who are poor defensive players.

Nofo has been one of our best players for a couple of years but his defense is terrible. JTJ's defense is worse. I don't think I've seen a player make as many mistakes in first grade as TT. I think he has some talent and he could turn it around but he makes a lot of mistakes.

We need to fix our edges. It's our weakest area.

I have been surprised the past two weeks to how slow JTJ looks now. Opposition seem to pull away from him when a break is made.
 
Why would anyone want to sign here ? Genuine question. Even if our juniors are good, why on earth would they want to stick around ? The current crop and the team of the last decade are hardly a team any young blokes look at and go yeah I want to play for them one day. Hilarious to hear that Lee thinks this roster is better than last year. Wish I could live in the same la la land him, that moron Pascoe and anyone else that looks after our club are in. Instead I’m in a world where broncos and bulldogs fans are messaging me saying “far out I feel sorry for you”
 
Back
Top