Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[pawsandclaws1]

As long as Brooks is our 7 we'll do diddly squat.

Mark my words, nothing will change with this team until Brooks is gone, pitty it's going to take so long to realise it.

Braydon Trindall is available. Just needs a coach to give him a decent chance.

Good player.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Curtis is a good player and we need a right edge second rower but the bloke can’t stay on the field

18 games last year, 22 the year before. That’s pretty decent.

 

[JC99]

Curtis is a good player and we need a right edge second rower but the bloke can’t stay on the field

18 games last year, 22 the year before. That’s pretty decent.

That’s surprising. I feel like he’s had heaps of injuries the last few years. Not a bad player at all

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

I'd happily take Siro to release Aloiai, Siro's game has progressed since he left we have also had a shift in coach with Madge. Someone we dont need for a position we do need is a decent outcome if true, only concern is he is injury prone.

 

[Snake]

I’d be all over Siro. Ironic considering I was his biggest critic when he played with us the first time round, but he’s grown as a player so much since leaving. He needed to go somewhere else, to establish his own name, which he did. Now he’s ready to come home.

This is exactly the reasoning why the club never plays finals footy ... 😂😂 living in the past is a badge of honour for some .. Siro is not a top footballers boot lace no thanks honestly!

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Curtis is a good player and we need a right edge second rower but the bloke can’t stay on the field

18 games last year, 22 the year before. That’s pretty decent.

And will strengthen our right side defence.

 

[avocadoontoast]

Curtis is a good player and we need a right edge second rower but the bloke can’t stay on the field

18 games last year, 22 the year before. That’s pretty decent.

And will strengthen our right side defence.

Massively, he’s always been a good defender.

 

[tig_prmz]

Siro reminds me of Eisenhuth with a bit more ability.

Someone said that he gives 100% but I disagree wholeheartedly. Has nowhere close to the work ethic or impact as most second rowers. He is naturally gifted but if he was to come here, I'd expect some cash to go with a player swap.

 

[jadtiger]

If that rumour has any legs Josh/Sirro i would happily take it because i feel Sirro has higher potential and Madge is just the coach to develop it

 

[coivtny]

I’d be all over Siro. Ironic considering I was his biggest critic when he played with us the first time round, but he’s grown as a player so much since leaving. He needed to go somewhere else, to establish his own name, which he did. Now he’s ready to come home.

Me too. Didn't rate him at all when he was here. Thought he was a lazy bludger but he's played really well at Manly. Would be a good swap for JA in my opinion.

 

[JD Tiger]

I don't know, I'm not sold on this swap should it be a real potential possibility.

To let Aloiai go, I'd want better. He has damaged this club, and though a player swap may be part of the deal, I'd demand from him to make up his behaviour before we let him go. Sit him down and tell him he will remain here, that there will be no swap, he remains here with his former mates (because they all look down on him now), until his attitude changes and he makes up for his rubbish. Then, and only then, we may consider a swap.

 

[happy_tiger]

I don't know, I'm not sold on this swap should it be a real potential possibility.

To let Aloiai go, I'd want better. He has damaged this club, and though a player swap may be part of the deal, I'd demand from him to make up his behaviour before we let him go. Sit him down and tell him he will remain here, that there will be no swap, he remains here with his former mates (because they all look down on him now), until his attitude changes and he makes up for his rubbish. Then, and only then, we may consider a swap.

Probably take the year off and fight Gallen ...he'd get more than 500 k doing that

 

[TheDaBoss]

I don't know, I'm not sold on this swap should it be a real potential possibility.

To let Aloiai go, I'd want better. He has damaged this club, and though a player swap may be part of the deal, I'd demand from him to make up his behaviour before we let him go. Sit him down and tell him he will remain here, that there will be no swap, he remains here with his former mates (because they all look down on him now), until his attitude changes and he makes up for his rubbish. Then, and only then, we may consider a swap.

Probably take the year off and fight Gallen ...he'd get more than 500 k doing that

I hope he pummels gallen

 

[Deleted member 3518]

I’d be all over Siro. Ironic considering I was his biggest critic when he played with us the first time round, but he’s grown as a player so much since leaving. He needed to go somewhere else, to establish his own name, which he did. Now he’s ready to come home.

If that’s the swap it sounds fair to me.

Agree. Actually balances out our team better.

However, I doubt there is anything to this given they are chasing Garner as a replacement for Joel Thompson so I wouldn't expect them to let go of another back rower.

Yep it’s exactly what we need . And it rights a wrong , both parties made a few years ago. Wow I thought that was impossible .

 

[JC99]

SMH in one article says Laurie is a done deal and has been denied a release, then they say his manager is about to ask for a release, now the latest article says he’s ‘close’ to agreeing terms for 2022

Which one is it 😂

 

[kiwitiger]

I don't know, I'm not sold on this swap should it be a real potential possibility.

To let Aloiai go, I'd want better. He has damaged this club, and though a player swap may be part of the deal, I'd demand from him to make up his behaviour before we let him go. Sit him down and tell him he will remain here, that there will be no swap, he remains here with his former mates (because they all look down on him now), until his attitude changes and he makes up for his rubbish. Then, and only then, we may consider a swap.

Probably take the year off and fight Gallen ...he'd get more than 500 k doing that

I hope he pummels gallen

Sorry, if you made that statement a week ago i would agree. But now i hope JA goes home in an ambulance. First round knock out to Gallen, he hits him so hard he ends up in the lap of Tyron Smith ringside.

 

[BAGNF05]

Where’s the Sirro stuff coming from, I’d be doing cartwheels he’s been awesome at Manly

 

[BAGNF05]

I’d be all over Siro. Ironic considering I was his biggest critic when he played with us the first time round, but he’s grown as a player so much since leaving. He needed to go somewhere else, to establish his own name, which he did. Now he’s ready to come home.

Grown up and in his prime

NSW could have used him last night, Nathan Brown couldn’t keep up.

 

[Harvey]

In big news Jesse Sue has signed for Newcastle.

Damn, thought we had him.

 

[Harvey]


No thanks, he is a downhill skier.

Doesn't run good lines or run hard, avoids any dirty work and injury prone. His father has also had a bit to say about our club.

Would prefer Keppie, Titmuss or Olakau'atu