Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[851]

But but he's fast.

A fast dumb half, what can go wrong

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

I hope these murmurs about Fifita and woods dont mean we've missed Klemmer. I can see the merit in one older head but not two. Unless Fifita is a Dias replacement meaning in reggies but plays a few games here and there.

 

[The Fresh Oil]

So why are you Brooke's mum on here?

It's just the internet. Google anything / anyone and you will find a nutbag fanatic asking it/them for feet pics. Hopefully once the trade is done and ding dong brooks is gone, these freaks will migrate to the Newcastle forum with the imp.

 

[851]

Madden was played at 7 ahead of Hastings when Brooks was out.

Yes he was tried and didn't really impress, and was let go, a smart decision considering he was off contract and Hastings wasn't

 

[jadtiger]

I think the current management dont understand the level of Hurt and Anger that Arron Woods gave us fans.

Our then captain left us for the dogs.

I will be very very disappointed if Woods is back at our club in any capacity.

Management at our club has probably been divorced from reality for decades and there is little likelyhood of change for at least another 5 years imho

 

[TigersFan101]

 

[pawsandclaws1]

View attachment 2937

Excellent pick up for WTs. I gather this is confirmation?

 

[batboy]

Madden was played at 7 ahead of Hastings when Brooks was out.

Numbers aside...
Brooks pretty much played 2nd receiver all year.

 

[tigerap]

View attachment 2937

We only have him for 2023, so he can sign for another club after November 1st....

 

[gregjm87]

Everyone is talking retiree's, when we have the money to afford above average.
Rather than sub standard.

There is no above average on the market for ’23.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

Brooks can't even get punted right. What's taking so long.

Good point, If Brooks is so Great where are the Clubs that require the services of such a great half back. ???????

 

[tigerap]

Not entirely sure why people can’t get player names right. Like Fifita.
We also have access to the internet

I swear I thought his name was Andrew Fatfita....

 

[balmain boy]

How silly would it be though.

If we get Klemmer and Joffa we have 60min+ props.
Stefano is a 40min+ prop
Add Twal who can play 80mins
Joffa and Twal could play other forward roles at a pinch (not fulltime but in a game situation)

Fafa in 15-20mins spurts would offer more than Woods from the bench impact wise.

I think often people just look at a name rather than the dynamics of how they would fit into the team rotations.

Joffa is not a 60 min prop. He's a 40-50 min prop, more than that and he gets tired and misses tackles.
You Realistically can't have Joffa and Twal on the field at the same time as they're too similar. Slow, one dimensional, not powerful runners, workhorses. You need punch to go with the workers.
Klemmer is a more punchy worker too. Having Klemmer, Joffa and Twal on at the same time would be suicide for our attack.

Woods is the same as the above. Slow and lacking impact. Fifita can at least offload, find his front and get a quick play the ball and still make his tackles.

 

[stryker 69]

Madden was played at 7 ahead of Hastings when Brooks was out.

They were testing him to see if he was worth keeping.
Evidently, he was not.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Everyone is talking retiree's, when we have the money to afford above average.
Rather than sub standard.

If I'm recruiting I'm not taking Andrew Fifita either. I'm saying that if I'm choosing between him and Woods, I'm taking Fifita every day of the week.

 

[Cobarcats]

View attachment 2937

It's great news that the Peach is going and Charlie will add competition and depth to the squad. Thanks for posting TF101

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

View attachment 2937

No value in Leniu being released now unless they are getting something for him as he'd be on peanuts for his final year.

 

[Tito Santana]

I swear I thought his name was Andrew Fatfita....

They probably said David Fafita but meant Andrew’s brother that plays in the UK, not the one on the GC

 

[TigersFan101]

We only have him for 2023, so he can sign for another club after November 1st....

You’d think he’d hold off on any decisions for 2024 onwards until he sees how he feels after abit at the tigers, unless tigers sign him with an extension

 

[earl]

Sheens views Hastings as a 13.

He appears to have viewed Hastings as a 13 up until this point. He might change his mind or the roster might change his mind.

Let's see how it plays out. If we get Staines maybe Laurie goes to 7 and Hastings is at 13.

I think whatever the case Hastings is going to be organizing us in the middle. His role won't change that much.

In some ways it's the wrong question. The question is do we play with an extra forward or an extra running 6 ?