Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[SwervinMervin]

Brooks' whole career was summed up in that interview when he said he "Hasn't seen much of the Dolphins because they played at the same time as us".

Just take a minute to digest that.

A professional on $1 mil a year hasn't done homework on the opposition.

It's beyond belief.

You hear about how much video that Nathan Cleary does in preparation for games and in pre season and when he is rehabing from injury. So did Cooper Cronk (still does even though he is not playing). Brooks clearly not that type of halfback and perhaps relies on the coaching staff to do that homework for him and give instruction. Maybe he just doesn't see the game like the best halves who are thinking 3 plays ahead and can break down an opposition. Adds to the belief he is best used as a running 5/8 who can pop up, play what he sees, follow a ball carrier in support. Unfortunately we wanted him to be something he just aint, and this statement in the interview shows why. He will probably go alright at Manly with Cherry Evans pulling the strings. I hope he does. It must suck being the whipping boy each week for 200+ games, whether it's deserved or not.

 

[Tucker]

https://x.com/nrl/status/1158920887044907008?s=46&t=rbvfolGQjKFKhk22og350A

cant wait

Are they Harold Mathew’s highlights?

 

[crazycat]

You hear about how much video that Nathan Cleary does in preparation for games and in pre season and when he is rehabing from injury. So did Cooper Cronk (still does even though he is not playing). Brooks clearly not that type of halfback and perhaps relies on the coaching staff to do that homework for him and give instruction. Maybe he just doesn't see the game like the best halves who are thinking 3 plays ahead and can break down an opposition. Adds to the belief he is best used as a running 5/8 who can pop up, play what he sees, follow a ball carrier in support. Unfortunately we wanted him to be something he just aint, and this statement in the interview shows why. He will probably go alright at Manly with Cherry Evans pulling the strings. I hope he does. It must suck being the whipping boy each week for 200+ games, whether it's deserved or not.

I just never saw it in him.

I reckon he trained harder then most players, but no where near as hard as Cronk or Cleary. I will add Chad Townsend to that list, as a Cronulla fan told me "he just wants it" and would train the house down... Doing everything possible.

Luke Brooks just seemed very happy go lucky. It's an attitude you can have at 5/8, not halfback.

 

[crazycat]

Wests Tigers Defence Assistant Coach is like the Defence Against the Dark Arts Teacher at Hogwarts in Harry Potter. new one every year with the last succumbing to an unpleasant fate.

Thinking about it... I reckon if we got Shane Flanagan in instead of Gardiner we may have had a very different 2022.

Shane Flanagan had the NRL experience and I reckon he would either conflict with Madge OR actually get the little things right. Too much was on Madge's shoulders. ...

 

[tony soprano]

Justin Pascoe to resign by end of 2023. Remember where you heard it first...

Who comes in?

 

[lathami]

Justin Pascoe to resign by end of 2023. Remember where you heard it first...

I won’t just heard on the podcast about an hour before your post!

 

[Tucker]

Who comes in?

Fitzy

 

[gregjm87]

If we win next season drinks on me. You can bookmark this post.

like just a game, or do we need to win the whole comp Earl?

 

[gregjm87]

I think you know the only positive in the club is the return of investment in talent identification and focus on elite pathways instigated by Sheens after Pascoe allowed Taylor and Cleary to dismantle it...

The way Pascoe flips and flops with the wind - this legacy is not set in stone and could all be gone again in 2 years time...

Seriously - Pascoe is unemployable at CEO level anywhere else!!

i dont know who was responsible for pathways but i feel like a lot of work was likely done long before Sheens. The club won Mat's before he was at the club.

 

[hammertime]

Fitzy

The ultimate 18th man fills the hole yet again.

 

[watersider]

on the money again !

I personally feel the forum has upgraded in the development of @kade7 and @teddy23. The Pom was getting old and complacent with his news, started getting a little loose and couldn't hit it like he used to. These new young upstarts have been pretty lethal.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

I personally feel the forum has upgraded in the development of @kade7 and @teddy23. The Pom was getting old and complacent with his news, started getting a little loose and couldn't hit it like he used to. These new young upstarts have been pretty lethal.

They are great to have on the forum but you've forgotten a forum identity. Wasn't it Mistymuzzle that hit us up with the Fainu signing and now has posted news about Pascoe?

 

[BalmainJnr]

Justin Pascoe to resign by end of 2023. Remember where you heard it first...

Won’t mean much with the same board in place.

 

[weststigerman]

Im less concerned about Pascoe these days as it appears his wings are clipped.

Lee has all the power and his ego won’t allow him to step aside.

He was asked if Benji was ready to coach and he said “Tim thinks he is and who am I to argue”.

He’s taking advice from the old guy who just wants to retire and the key part is if Benji fails, he can again blame the football department.

 

[kade7]

Are they Harold Mathew’s highlights?

nope flegg and then cup

 

[tigerballs]

Are they Harold Mathew’s highlights?

I wonder why Saints don't want him.

 

[tigerballs]

They are great to have on the forum but you've forgotten a forum identity. Wasn't it Mistymuzzle that hit us up with the Fainu signing and now has posted news about Pascoe?

No, it was Tigerballs with the Fainus. And multiple others.

 

[Mistymuzzle]

No, it was Tigerballs with the Fainus. And multiple others.

Back it up with posts and dates

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Back it up with posts and dates

And maybe some facts - and if no facts - plausibility and coherence.

 

[Mistymuzzle]

Back it up with posts and dates

Actually I take it back. I did a search, Tigerballs did post about the Fainus before I did....I was unaware of Tigerballs post. Credit where credits due etc....