Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

king_sirro said:
Just like those saying they can't understand how anyone sees something in Kapeoa, I can't understand how you can't at least see something. Tom Shines questioned if we even watch, well I dare say he must not watch if he can't see anything. He even said AJ can't pass, when in actual fact he has proved to be one of the better players in the team at skipping to the outside and slipping a ball the an unmarked man.

No doubt AJ frustrated us last year, he fell short in parts of his game that are crucial to centre and wing play. But the athleticism and aggression he showed playing backrow for the first time was impressive IMO and at least showed "something" to work with. Especially when we are very short on for backrowers and it's very handy to have one that can fill in out wide if injury hits during a game.

If we play him at centre or wing in 24 then I share the concerns, but if he concentrates on backrow, I think he will be a decent first grader that comes in handy.
Click to expand...

I watched every minute of last season…

he is one of the worst players I have seen play first grade and continue to be selected…

You can just tell from his body language that he has ZERO confidence …

He just doesn’t have it ..,
 
Tom Shines said:
I watched every minute of last season…

he is one of the worst players I have seen play first grade and continue to be selected…

You can just tell from his body language that he has ZERO confidence …

He just doesn’t have it ..,
Click to expand...

You haven't seen much of the Tigers and Magpies over the years if you think he is one of the worst. He would have walked into the starting lineup of many Balmain, Magpies and Wests Tigers teams over the years.
 
king_sirro said:
You haven't seen much of the Tigers and Magpies over the years if you think he is one of the worst. He would have walked into the starting lineup of many Balmain, Magpies and Wests Tigers teams over the years.
Click to expand...

I have been a fan of Balmain and the Tigers for 40 years …

he would make an all time worst line up ..

he might not be the worst … but he is definitely in the 17..
 
Every club has got to have depth players and they are the players that fans will never all agree on. We have too many of them - and most that move on have proven to be useful to other clubs because of their FG experience. Can think of many that have been bagged consistently on this forum who have contributed to much better squads than ours.
 
Telltails said:
Every club has got to have depth players and they are the players that fans will never all agree on. We have too many of them - and most that move on have proven to be useful to other clubs because of their FG experience. Can think of many that have been bagged consistently on this forum who have contributed to much better squads than ours.
Click to expand...

“Depth player “ that played 19 games last year ..

he is on the market now for 2025 … interesting to see who will sign him
 
Telltails said:
Every club has got to have depth players and they are the players that fans will never all agree on. We have too many of them - and most that move on have proven to be useful to other clubs because of their FG experience. Can think of many that have been bagged consistently on this forum who have contributed to much better squads than ours.
Click to expand...
It’s hard to blame him. Blame the club for putting themselves in a position where players of his calibre are in the top 17. He’s a fringe first grader anywhere else. Here, he’s a regular starter. And given all the resources the club have, that’s on them.
 
Tom Shines said:
“Depth player “ that played 19 games last year ..

he is on the market now for 2025 … interesting to see who will sign him
Click to expand...
That's the point- we have plenty of players that retain FG positions because there are no better players to compete for them. Eisenhuth Cheekham both come to mind as players who got smashed on here and both went to stronger clubs and played plenty of FG off the bench and or in run on side when players were injured.
 
Telltails said:
That's the point- we have plenty of players that retain FG positions because there are no better players to compete for them. Eisenhuth Cheekham both come to mind as players who got smashed on here and both went to stronger clubs and played plenty of FG off the bench and or in run on side when players were injured.
Click to expand...

Eisunhith and Cheekhan were much better players …
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 481 (members: 27, guests: 454)
Back
Top