Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Camel2281]

Yeah we didn’t progressively get worse since sacking him. Last, last, and last. Consistent.

The first spoon was on Madge

 

[Droppy05]

The first spoon was on Madge

In 2023 we were worse than 2022. 16th to 17th. Lets hope there no new teams next year.

 

[weststigers]

Bennett does what he wants. He is all over the place. He doesn’t go to Fiji because he doesn’t have young kids. What difference? The fact that we suck and the media worked out Benji had 6 nights instead of 4 in a place suited to young kids? Don’t get it. Whether he was in Brisbane or Hamilton Island, doesn’t matter. Media beat up. And we love it here.

Gotta laugh.

4 hour plane ride to Fiji and probably 4 hour drive to Bennetts farm.

 

[weststigers]

😩😩😩😩
the batemen situation is not a good one
a week ago he was staying in the uk

not sure the change of heart, or maybe we didnt want to contribute to his salary

Salaries in England are pretty low. I remember clubs baulking at Sullivan's salary saying they simply couldn't fit 325k pounds into their cap for 1 player.

Bateman is on 670k or something. I thought he'd spat the dummy and was going to leave despite the cash, but it's a lot of money to forego at the back end of your career.

He's not going great over there either. I think he'll be a passenger for the next 2 years sadly.

 

[weststigers]

Yes, it’s still playing out and it is what it is.

He’s worked hard for what he has, I don’t begrudge him.

I’d have made a play for Luai before MM, for many reasons.

Ex Rooster kid at work, rates Hunt and Skelton pretty highly. Thinks we need Kobe as well.

He also rates Hook as a coach from the ex league player grapevine. He may not have gelled at SGI.

Maybe Hook as an assistant for us?

Hook has form being totally disliked by players and the administrators wherever he goes and has been punted as a result (although he was a little.unlucky at Penrith).

Whoever our coach is going to be, they need to be there long term if Benji is going to be given the boot.

Looking at all the coaches in the NRL, the only ones that might match our needs are Andrew Webster or Todd Payten. Possibly with a big asterisk Demetriou.

The rest are no chance of coming here.

Failing that, you have the next breed of coaches coming through like Dean Young.

I'd prefer to watch how the first half of the season goes before discussing replacements though.

I don't see much talent in Arthur, Griffin, Barrett, McGregor to fill me with confidence that they can do the job. We are a special case.

 

[1itiger]

Ive only once had a decade of success like that.
Ive been a supporter since 1984 with Balmain and now Wests Tigers.
So between 84 and 93 they made the finals 6 times (85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90).
That run of good years hooked me and has not even hinted at happening since....bastards

Mate...exactly the same haha

 

[bptiger 0]

TherIf Bateman is legit keen to play we probably don’t get Kobe.

Even if Bateman comes back we need another backrower

 

[Tom Shines]

Bateman coming back is a disaster

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Bateman coming back is a disaster

Imo Bateman's manager s maneuvering to get the best payout for his client.

 

[king_sirro]

You are basing that off your opinion and an assumption that you are right and he is wrong. You don’t know what went on at the club before Benji went away, what went on while he was away, or after he got back.
That is self opinionated arrogant stance right there.

Agree.

 

[Tom Shines]

Imo Bateman's manager s maneuvering to get the best payout for his client.

I’m not so sure he is wanted elsewhere

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

How many middles do we need? We simply can't sign RCG unless it's replacing Klemmer.

of we lose Pole for 2026 (which would seem likely) then RCG replaces him for 2026

 

[hank37w]

We could only dream of making finals 5 years out of the last 10 like Brad Arthur managed with the Eels.

Instead we are <checks notes> 0 out of 10.

Yep.

Check again. 0 out of 13. 🤢

 

[jadtiger]

Imo Bateman's manager s maneuvering to get the best payout for his client.

I sincerely hope you are right as he is terrible value for money.A massive con job that Sheens left behind

 

[Tom Shines]

I sincerely hope you are right as he is terrible value for money.A massive con job that Sheens left behind

Sheens final revenge on the club

 

[Telltails]

I can't believe you are comparing Benji with Bennett.

A bit like comparing Melbourne with Wests Tigers

 

[hank37w]

Looks like Addo-Carr will be looking for a new club

Well hopefully it won't be here because that laughing JAC ASS has has screwed us over a couple of times already, so we should just let him Trot off somewhere else.

Over to you Gus.

 

[bigsiro]

Not sure how you would claim a 'common' understanding for modern era and would be interested in seeing what others think.For mine there is no way 50 years ago could be considered modern. 30 years ago or just short of, maybe, given that was approximately the dawn of professionalism and the start of 'NRL' post superleague. But I still wouldn't consider that 'modern' particularly how much the game has changed in 25-30 years.
Post 'wrestle' era of about 20 years ago I would start considering a 'modern era'. Even then we have moved past that into the 6 again era the last few years.
Not an attack on your opinion in any way just curios what others would consider 'the modern era'.

All of that makes complete sense.
I guess it’s who you ask. Players like Coote, Fulton, Beetson were always considered greats of modern era, as opposed to your Churchills or Dave Browns.
Then you look at guys like Raudinikis, Eadie, Ray Price, who were around 40+ years ago - and would be considered “modern” greats by most.

Then Clyde, Langer, Lewis era, which is circa 30+ years ago (this is making me feel old!).

Yep, I suppose it’s who you ask.

 

[liltiger]

That Pom had better be back for the start of preseason then. No BS family or international excuses, get here and start living up to your contract.

Best part of the whole article was Richo spraying the players for carrying on like numpties on the sideline. Can't see Richo letting Bateman miss any of the preseason, if Bateman wants the money he I'd going to actually have to earn it now.

 

[Telltails]

I like a lot about Bateman, his mongrel and his defense mainly. I’ll forgive his many brain snaps this year because I don’t think he’s a good loser, I’d back him, like Luai to drive standards in a better squad.

The obsession about Bateman is over the top. He is not anywhere near as undisciplined as some make out but people choose to believe it anyway. Never liked the deal from the get go but he is not the reason we got the threepeat and seems to be one of the favoured scapegoats.