Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Radley's Concussion history
Interesting !!


2019513/04/2019HIA NO RETURN19/04/20190
20191124/05/2019HIA24/05/20190
20191124/05/2019HIA CLEARED24/05/20190
2019GF06/10/2019HIA06/10/20190
2019GF06/10/2019HIA CLEARED06/10/20190
2020620/06/2020HIA20/06/20200
2020620/06/2020HIA CLEARED20/06/20200
2021907/05/2021HIA NO RETURN15/05/20210
2022112/03/2022HIA NO RETURN18/03/20220
2022725/04/2022HIA25/04/20220
2022725/04/2022HIA CLEARED25/04/20220
20221601/07/2022HIA LAST 15 MINS16/07/20221
20222104/08/2022HIA04/08/20220
20222104/08/2022HIA CLEARED04/08/20220
20222426/08/2022HIA LAST 15 MINS11/09/20221
2023105/03/2023HIA17/03/20231
2023317/03/2023HIA17/03/20230
2023317/03/2023HIA CLEARED17/03/20230
20232626/08/2023HIA LAST 15 MINS01/09/20230
20241807/07/2024HIA NO RETURN20/07/20241
20242202/08/2024HIA02/08/20240
20242202/08/2024HIA CLEARED02/08/20240
2025106/03/2025HIA NO RETURN21/03/20251
2025321/03/2025HIA21/03/20250
2025321/03/2025HIA CLEARED21/03/20250
2025428/03/2025HIA28/03/20250
2025428/03/2025HIA CLEARED28/03/20250
20251301/06/2025HIA01/06/20250
20251301/06/2025HIA CLEARED01/06/20250
20251514/06/2025HIA NO RETURN12/07/20253

Judiciary record
grade. length
20214RoostersDangerous contact - Other10$1800
20216RoostersHigh tackle - Careless20$1900
202111RoostersHigh tackle - Careless25460
202111RoostersDangerous contact - head/neck11120
202122RoostersDangerous contact - other23315 + 35 = 350
202223RoostersDangerous Contact10$1000
202224RoostersDangerous Contact10$1800
20236RoostersDangerous Contact03000
20238RoostersCareless High Tackle03000
202312RoostersStriking3
202320RoostersDangerous Contact203000
202412RoostersCareless High Tackle101000
202424RoostersDangerous Contact201800
202425RoostersCareless High Tackle203000
2024PFRoostersDangerous Contact203000
[/COLOR]
Brother, where'd you get the stats? Just wondering if it was AI, because that paints a really bad picture! So I'm wondering how accurate it is?
Appreciate you pulling it together either way
 
Radley at lock for 2 years as a stop gap, to just buy us time to find someone more long term, I'd do it in a heartbeat. We just need 35 - 40 games out of him in 2 seasons, he should be able to do that easily. If he goes well give him another 2 years. If not we have 2 years to work something out. Plus he's cheap uncle Nick is chipping in to move him on.
🙃👎
 
If we have a proper lock we don't need another prop realistically coz Twal and Sione come into the prop rotation with Terrell, Pole, Hunt and Seyfarth

KPP won’t be our only notable signing

Our main issue this year was depth which we have addressed and will further improve

South’s have so so much going on to the point it doesn’t really make a difference who is playing

Titans I can see improvement out of

I highly doubt with how disjointed Newy are that they hit the ground running
Gee the Tigers will again struggle in 2026 if KPP is considered a notable signing. He comes to us from the team who finished with the Wooden Spoon. I have no wrap on him.
 
I honestly think the Luai/Fainu/Doueihi problem would be fixed easily if Luai just dug his heels in and had a proper crack at 7. He is still a good player but he was in very bad form both at 7 and 6. He had a disrupted season with galvin overtaking him, then heath mason for a few weeks, then latu, doueihi, and then latu again. He looked his best next to AD understandably playing as a running 6 acting instinctively. AD is the best stable option for the next year to get the boys home in games we should win, luai is probably the one who should be stepping up but is simply not doing enough, and latu's selection at 7 will be good for the future of the club long-term but hurt us short-term in closing out games rather than how sides like the Storm
 
Roosters have a kamikaze style of defensive and attacking technique. It gets them results however it also delivers a large number of concussions...think Cordner, Friend, Radley and Teddy has had his fair share. walker has also had more than he should with his number of games. Perhaps in a different system with different structure Radley may be able to temper his technique and prolong his career.
Agreed
It's definately an effective defense, but one that seems to be breaking people.

Craig Fitzgibbon was huge into the wressle. I wonder if this is contributing.
We may start to see the same at the sharks.
 
Roosters have a kamikaze style of defensive and attacking technique. It gets them results however it also delivers a large number of concussions...think Cordner, Friend, Radley and Teddy has had his fair share. walker has also had more than he should with his number of games. Perhaps in a different system with different structure Radley may be able to temper his technique and prolong his career.
The margin of error of going a bit too high with that kamikaze style defence has worked against Radley (and others) he gives away a lot of penalties. This year the footy has been great viewing with its momentum shifts (or a “game of two half’s”) where you think one team has the game won (like the Raiders V Broncos). We have seen the Cowboys and Titian games get away from us with momentum swings.
It’s buyer beware with players like Radley. They can do something good to change the game or get penalised or sent off.
 
Radley's Concussion history
Interesting !!


2019513/04/2019HIA NO RETURN19/04/20190
20191124/05/2019HIA24/05/20190
20191124/05/2019HIA CLEARED24/05/20190
2019GF06/10/2019HIA06/10/20190
2019GF06/10/2019HIA CLEARED06/10/20190
2020620/06/2020HIA20/06/20200
2020620/06/2020HIA CLEARED20/06/20200
2021907/05/2021HIA NO RETURN15/05/20210
2022112/03/2022HIA NO RETURN18/03/20220
2022725/04/2022HIA25/04/20220
2022725/04/2022HIA CLEARED25/04/20220
20221601/07/2022HIA LAST 15 MINS16/07/20221
20222104/08/2022HIA04/08/20220
20222104/08/2022HIA CLEARED04/08/20220
20222426/08/2022HIA LAST 15 MINS11/09/20221
2023105/03/2023HIA17/03/20231
2023317/03/2023HIA17/03/20230
2023317/03/2023HIA CLEARED17/03/20230
20232626/08/2023HIA LAST 15 MINS01/09/20230
20241807/07/2024HIA NO RETURN20/07/20241
20242202/08/2024HIA02/08/20240
20242202/08/2024HIA CLEARED02/08/20240
2025106/03/2025HIA NO RETURN21/03/20251
2025321/03/2025HIA21/03/20250
2025321/03/2025HIA CLEARED21/03/20250
2025428/03/2025HIA28/03/20250
2025428/03/2025HIA CLEARED28/03/20250
20251301/06/2025HIA01/06/20250
20251301/06/2025HIA CLEARED01/06/20250
20251514/06/2025HIA NO RETURN12/07/20253

Judiciary record
grade. length
20214RoostersDangerous contact - Other10$1800
20216RoostersHigh tackle - Careless20$1900
202111RoostersHigh tackle - Careless25460
202111RoostersDangerous contact - head/neck11120
202122RoostersDangerous contact - other23315 + 35 = 350
202223RoostersDangerous Contact10$1000
202224RoostersDangerous Contact10$1800
20236RoostersDangerous Contact03000
20238RoostersCareless High Tackle03000
202312RoostersStriking3
202320RoostersDangerous Contact203000
202412RoostersCareless High Tackle101000
202424RoostersDangerous Contact201800
202425RoostersCareless High Tackle203000
2024PFRoostersDangerous Contact203000
[/COLOR]
I wonder how many of those hia were tactical substitutions
 
Would not touch Radley. He is a unit with a lot of hard miles on the clock, had plenty of defect notices from the authorities and might struggle to get a pink slip when his rego is up. Also spent a fair bit of the time on blocks in the garage.

Seriously we don’t need another penalty magnet, with a rap sheet longer than a goal post and more head knocks than a no arms boxer
 
If you could sign victor for bench player coin x 1-2 years would be okay imo
But I can’t see that happening
Assuming he has a family to support reckon he will go to the highest bidder
Wonder if there’s a spot for him at the Titans 😂
 
Would not touch Radley. He is a unit with a lot of hard miles on the clock, had plenty of defect notices from the authorities and might struggle to get a pink slip when his rego is up. Also spent a fair bit of the time on blocks in the garage.

Seriously we don’t need another penalty magnet, with a rap sheet longer than a goal post and more head knocks than a no arms boxer
Yeah he’s another like Nelson. He’s one of the most penalised in a team that’s gets the rub of the green from the refs, imagine how often they’d penalise him at the Tigers?
He could be a good stepping stone player for us for 2 years, and him. I’d bet quids a team like Perth would pay good money for him no matter how beat up he is.
 
Its not often a high calibre player comes along falling out of the tree, and its reported @700 G?
Good investment IMO, the guy would add plenty at 13 where we have lacked any strike.
Instantly improves the pack in a huge way.... yes the headknocks, but worth the risk.
What were they going to pay that muppet dossier kid to stay?
Surely they kick the tyres.... it would be a travesty if the red V beat us to the punch.
 
Its not often a high calibre player comes along falling out of the tree, and its reported @700 G?
Good investment IMO, the guy would add plenty at 13 where we have lacked any strike.
Instantly improves the pack in a huge way.... yes the headknocks, but worth the risk.
What were they going to pay that muppet dossier kid to stay?
Surely they kick the tyres.... it would be a travesty if the red V beat us to the punch.
Mixed feelings re the possibility. At his best very good enforcer and hard runner of the ball but he is close to the end. Don't want to end up wth another Bwaith type pension collector, which is a real possibility.
 
I’m still not 100% on Radley , I see our problem was once we got into our opposition 10/ 15 mtr area we just could not put points on we looked lost , no organisation , no set plays , we missed AD in last few rounds and I feel he could have made a difference in those games but AD at 13 and a good 7 is where we need to go , KPP. Will help but Latu I’m still not sure if he is the wiz kid , we also need attack coach like Cronk , that’s where I think we need to spend money
Cheap forwards will be available shortly ,
 
Mixed feelings re the possibility. At his best very good enforcer and hard runner of the ball but he is close to the end. Don't want to end up wth another Bwaith type pension collector, which is a real possibility.
Yes agreed. I was in favour of the Blore Olam swap and we got burned by that badly. NAS, Radley are in the same bucket. Wouldnt touch Brandon Smith. A very troubled soul.
 
Yep. He's out of his prime and is about 1 head knock away from forced medical retirement. No thanks
Its not that bad really, 6 HIA No Returns in 7 seasons. I wouldnt sign him, much rather we transition Doueihi to 13. Besides we have a few promising rangy 2nd rowers joining us in the offseason.
 
I’d take Victor in a heart beat . Every sports person in Australia has dibbed and dabbled with the marching powder . Your system burns through it , and it’s easy to mask / chuck up inconclusive test results with Berocca and other things.
If you sink half a carton of piss every weekend ,smoke bongs/ even smash durries all day!( not sure how you afford it anymore) , then you’re in no position to claim moral high ground on a dude snorting lines in a controlled environment with his mates. In fact it’s hypocrisy at its finest .the only difference between you and him is government have developed clear systems to tax. Litterally that’s it . Sorry to break it to you , they’re all just harmful in the community as each other .
If it doesn’t affect who and what he is in the dressing sheds and his performance on and off the field both in pre-season and the general season, this is exactly the type of player we need . A middle who can tackle all day , provide spark , and ball play through the middle corridor of the field .
There’s really only 2 types of people who are beyond repair , blokes who love to bash thier families (not dudes who are screwed up and know they’re a mess and need help- there’s a difference there. The second bloke seeks therapy , might have spent time in gaol , had a long hard mirror shown to him and his past and is genuinely doing the work, the first bloke loves the power and domain he holds and gets off on the pain he inflicts. That guy should be thrown off a cliff) and obviously your Brett Finch types .Castration comes to mind there …
Sorry and on a team harmony level , your Ryan Matterson types … hard to include just being a shit bloke with the evil of the 1st two though.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top