Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[happy_tiger]

That's not the point, the lack of depth with a squad of 25 will leave a lot of teams struggling when injuries hit.

Isn't that what you were trying to get across, it will happen with less injuries than double digit, especially teams under the top 8.

I think the NRL involvement in the future of the ESL is to poach as many top players from that comp as possible , thus trying to fix the very apparent shortfall of 20 sides

 

[Dr_Ice]

Yeah you can't obviously use weights like they did in the 60s .....not that I'm old enough to remember that .....but I reckon playing 2 years up is the maximum that kids can deal with mentally
I would occasionally play baseball as a 12 year old in my Dads team if they were short
And even in a non contact sport it was overwhelming

Didn’t jockey Malcolm Johnston tell the story that he once scored 5 tries in a Junior rugby league game. Then mentioned he was about four years older than everyone else as he was so small.

 

[tiger_one]

Didn’t jockey Malcolm Johnston tell the story that he once scored 5 tries in a Junior rugby league game. Then mentioned he was about four years older than everyone else as he was so small.

@Dr_Ice - sound like he was playing for the comps back then that were by weight.

 

[innsaneink]

I think the NRL involvement in the future of the ESL is to poach as many top players from that comp as possible , thus trying to fix the very apparent shortfall of 20 sides

Not a real wize investment if they plan to rape and pillage

 

[happy_tiger]

Didn’t jockey Malcolm Johnston tell the story that he once scored 5 tries in a Junior rugby league game. Then mentioned he was about four years older than everyone else as he was so small.

Could be right .....I haven't heard that story before

 

[happy_tiger]

Not a real wize investment if they plan to rape and pillage

I can't see any other reason to invest to be honest ......rugby league is a very distant 3rd in footy popularity and FTA TV is threatening to pull the pin on any coverage
The only other thought is they switch the game to a winter sport in England so players can play like they did in the 80s on short term deals to help teams during end of season / finals footy
The crowds are poor bar derby games ( ie Hull v Hull KR ) and I don't think it can be saved at a competitive level compared to soccer or rugby

 

[TigerBurnsy]

Don't think the club really needs a psychopath swearing at the players ever time they play poorly. Though it would be a complete contrast to Benji being everyone's mate

Our players need a kick up the ass, Benji is way too soft and everyone’s best bud

 

[balmain boy]

Commercial success at the expense of the game itself. Anyone who has watched the game for longer than 5 years doesn't like the way it is going.

And this is the problem with pvl. He's only focused on cash, not on the footy or the fans. Without us the money goes

 

[balmain boy]

If people are worried there isn't enough talent, make it a top 25 instead of top 30, that's an additional 100 players that can be utilised...

Most clubs use 27-37 players a season. How would it help to have fewer players training professionally? The game has never had more injuries.

If the NRL want more clubs they need to invest an extra 100 million in juniors development across the country

 

[WswWt]

Our players need a kick up the ass, Benji is way too soft and everyone’s best bud

That islanders of the playing group won’t react well to that style lol

 

[NT_Tiger]

And this is the problem with pvl. He's only focused on cash, not on the footy or the fans. Without us the money goes

I dont think he needs fans, he only needs gamblers

 

[Buttface]

I dont think he needs fans, he only needs gamblers

He loves a little tv air time.

 

[Vicious]

Obviously the talent pool is reduced with the inclusion of extra teams, but there could be 24 teams and there would still be 1 maybe 2 genuine top class tj elite players available for each team.
The problem is teams such as ours have a lot of trouble identifying players who are elite and end up paying elite salaries to players who are not in that category.
One player from each club should be salary cap exempt to allow a genuine elite marquee player at each club.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

Obviously the talent pool is reduced with the inclusion of extra teams, but there could be 24 teams and there would still be 1 maybe 2 genuine top class tj elite players available for each team.
The problem is teams such as ours have a lot of trouble identifying players who are elite and end up paying elite salaries to players who are not in that category.
One player from each club should be salary cap exempt to allow a genuine elite marquee player at each club.

Like it.

Plus clubs (& players) should be incentivised & rewarded for developing their own juniors from at least having two years in U19s up.

A decent salary cap discount for clubs + a bonus (not included in cap) for players.

Clubs would invest more heavily in pathways then I’m sure & would help in some small way to counteract the tax-free lure of PNG.