The Awards are a JOKE!

@Strongee said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241806) said:
@chiranth said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241798) said:
I’ll start of first by saying it’s awesome to see Nofoaluma finally take out the players player and the best player for 2020 award! Absolutely well deserved! ? ? One of the best winger seasons in WT history! Been UNDERRATED for the last 8 years! Harry Grant could have easily won the award and there would have been no complaints!

BUT I can’t understand for the life of me how Luciano Leilua is NOT recognised, NOT even in the Top 5 is dropdead ridiculous! People will say it’s only awards, but I say great seasons deserve to be recognised and celebrated! You don’t see the Melbourne Storm making this mistake!

How on earth is Twal even 3rd in the voting! The bloke missed half a season with an injury and was pretty average the whole season if I was being generous! Then they’ve got Brooks in the Top 5 when he’s only had 3 try assists for a out and out halfback! Nofa plays on the wing and has 7 try assists this season! If that’s not saying something I don’t know what is! It just mindboggling to see players that should be getting recognised never do, especially Luciano Leilua and Sam McIntyre for their incredible performances all year! No wonder players start leaving this club, when the playing group/staff don’t even know who’s had a great season and who hasn’t! It’s not rocket science

Mate ,try assists are a stat that means your the last person to touch the ball prior to someone scoring a try . If you don’t grow a sweet cutout ball to your centre , and he draws and passes to your winger to walk over , that’s the centre’s try assist. But who really assisted the try ? Ice hockey has this sorted , if you’re the bloke who set it up you get an assist doesn’t matter if it needed a link man to get the score . No one gave a crap about try assists until like 5 years ago . It’s hardly an advanced metric stat.

I have to correct you on that one. Try assists in the NRL are actually given to the person who most contributed to the try being scored. This change occurred at least 5 years ago. In your example above the halfback would receive the “try assist” today, but separately the centre is awarded a “last pass assist”...The “last pass assist” isn’t mentioned or listed in tv coverage stats, but it’s provided to NRL coaches and I think it may even be a seperate stat that contributes to super coach scores (worth less than a try assist).
 
@balmain-boy said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241871) said:
Both Aloiai and Leilua not even bring in the top 5 is a disgrace. It shows that whatever the system is for voting it's been Trumped and needs instant change.

Who does vote for this? Coaching staff?

IMHO, only players worth mentioning are Grant, Aloiai, Nofoaluma, AD, and L Leilua, they are, unfortunately, miles ahead of everyone else, especially Twal and Brooks.
 
@happy_tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241923) said:
They missed one award ...Worst Fan .................Geo wins and gets a Life Time Manly membership as his reward

Says the bloke who wants us to get the spoon
 
the players voted for Nofo i see....
No wonder we don't have the mentality to make the semis if they vote for Nofo... makes sense now
 
@Geo said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241924) said:
@happy_tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241923) said:
They missed one award ...Worst Fan .................Geo wins and gets a Life Time Manly membership as his reward

Says the bloke who wants us to get the spoon

Says the bloke who spoons with Hobbo

The quicker we reach rock bottom ..the quicker we can improve


Look at the Titans .....16th -9th and probably have recruited best of any club in 2021 so far
 
@Geo said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241924) said:
@happy_tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241923) said:
They missed one award ...Worst Fan .................Geo wins and gets a Life Time Manly membership as his reward

Says the bloke who wants us to get the spoon

![alt text](https://media4.giphy.com/media/ncbdoCpKerEbK/giphy.gif?cid=4d1e4f296016db55034e37acf3008b5027a0444848d46e82&rid=giphy.gif)
 
Grant was awesome for us but he didn't play for over a quarter of the games - Noffa was voted best by his peers, how can you argue with that?
 
@balmain-boy said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241967) said:
So the players vote for players player and also for the main award? What's the point in having two awards then?


According to WT Instagram, the players vote for one and the coaching staff vote for the other.

"nrl_weststigers Voted by the coaches AND players as your 2020 Player of the Year! 👏🏆"
 
oh well Benji never won a Player of the year either I guess. I am sure Harry can wave as he plays his 10th origin game for QLD and makes debut for Australia.
 
@Jedi_Tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241882) said:
Harry Grant does ... clearly said that in my post.
Harry should have won the award clearly our best player followed by Nofo !
if he can back it up next year then Nofo might make origin but one year doesn't make up for a poor last few years

Nofo played every game and Grant played what 14?
 
@Jedi_Tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241925) said:
the players voted for Nofo i see....
No wonder we don't have the mentality to make the semis if they vote for Nofo... makes sense now

Far out, I think you're actually serious 🤣
 
@nrlsurvivor said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241886) said:
@Strongee said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241806) said:
@chiranth said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241798) said:
I’ll start of first by saying it’s awesome to see Nofoaluma finally take out the players player and the best player for 2020 award! Absolutely well deserved! ? ? One of the best winger seasons in WT history! Been UNDERRATED for the last 8 years! Harry Grant could have easily won the award and there would have been no complaints!

BUT I can’t understand for the life of me how Luciano Leilua is NOT recognised, NOT even in the Top 5 is dropdead ridiculous! People will say it’s only awards, but I say great seasons deserve to be recognised and celebrated! You don’t see the Melbourne Storm making this mistake!

How on earth is Twal even 3rd in the voting! The bloke missed half a season with an injury and was pretty average the whole season if I was being generous! Then they’ve got Brooks in the Top 5 when he’s only had 3 try assists for a out and out halfback! Nofa plays on the wing and has 7 try assists this season! If that’s not saying something I don’t know what is! It just mindboggling to see players that should be getting recognised never do, especially Luciano Leilua and Sam McIntyre for their incredible performances all year! No wonder players start leaving this club, when the playing group/staff don’t even know who’s had a great season and who hasn’t! It’s not rocket science

Mate ,try assists are a stat that means your the last person to touch the ball prior to someone scoring a try . If you don’t grow a sweet cutout ball to your centre , and he draws and passes to your winger to walk over , that’s the centre’s try assist. But who really assisted the try ? Ice hockey has this sorted , if you’re the bloke who set it up you get an assist doesn’t matter if it needed a link man to get the score . No one gave a crap about try assists until like 5 years ago . It’s hardly an advanced metric stat.

I have to correct you on that one. Try assists in the NRL are actually given to the person who most contributed to the try being scored. This change occurred at least 5 years ago. In your example above the halfback would receive the “try assist” today, but separately the centre is awarded a “last pass assist”...The “last pass assist” isn’t mentioned or listed in tv coverage stats, but it’s provided to NRL coaches and I think it may even be a seperate stat that contributes to super coach scores (worth less than a try assist).



It doesn’t though . The try where brooks cutout 3 blokes and hit Mbye on the chest to put whoever over , the try assist was given to Mbye . Brooks didn’t get one . I looked at the time . Because everyone was bringing up try assists and I was noticing that had happened a few times. It’s still perception . In ice hockey they’d just given them each one .
 
@Jedi_Tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241837) said:
Nofo had an exceptional year but we are West Tigers lets not give the award to a player who will go on to play Origin and tests for Australia and likely win premierships for years to come
...
Welll done Nofo well done
God help this club honestly

Jennings received the “just for fun “ award !
 
was not mentioning Jennings Hobo he is gone now and good luck to him alas the love affair for Nofo with some fans continues. See Fitler and the Blues didn't have the same love affair as many tigers fans....
I would have Harry Grant well before Nofo in a team anyday, but typical tigers hope we do not pay stupid money to Nofo when his contract is up hope we lowball him too
Harry will be a rep player and star and should have won that award
 
@Jedi_Tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1242025) said:
was not mentioning Jennings Hobo he is gone now and good luck to him alas the love affair for Nofo with some fans continues. See Fitler and the Blues didn't have the same love affair as many tigers fans....
I would have Harry Grant well before Nofo in a team anyday, but typical tigers hope we do not pay stupid money to Nofo when his contract is up hope we lowball him too
***Harry will be a rep player and star and should have won that award***

Yeah, but he didn’t so time to move on
 
true history now I guess...
Due to Turbo's injury who knows Nofo may yet get picked for nsw or train on squad at least likely Cotric and Fergo or Tupou ahead of him though but never know
The downside would be a bigger cost for his next contract if he plays rep footy
 
@Jedi_Tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1242025) said:
was not mentioning Jennings Hobo he is gone now and good luck to him alas the love affair for Nofo with some fans continues. See Fitler and the Blues didn't have the same love affair as many tigers fans....
I would have Harry Grant well before Nofo in a team anyday, but typical tigers hope we do not pay stupid money to Nofo when his contract is up hope we lowball him too
Harry will be a rep player and star and should have won that award

Nofo is one of our own mate .
Harry was just a loaner ..
If you’d look at the numbers Nofo produced through the season it’s a no brainer he won ..

Jennings works at the 7 Eleven on George st
Say G’day from all of us 😂
 
@innsaneink said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241999) said:
@Jedi_Tiger said in [The Awards are a JOKE\!](/post/1241925) said:
the players voted for Nofo i see....
No wonder we don't have the mentality to make the semis if they vote for Nofo... makes sense now

Far out, I think you're actually serious ?

He is. Once he latches on to something neither heaven nor earth will shift it.
 
Back
Top