Tukimihia Simpkins #248

Wasn’t too bad, but he isn’t upto standard yet - tackling up high, while the other ball player opposition is driving his legs making big meters is a prime example.

Give it sometime.
 
He is very young and inexperienced coming into a side that is also young.With experience i am sure he will improve. It is very difficult when you dont have much experience in your FG side around you.
I am confident he will be fine in FG in time
 
@jadtiger said in [Tuki Simpkins](/post/1432350) said:
He is very young and inexperienced coming into a side that is also young.With experience i am sure he will improve. It is very difficult when you dont have much experience in your FG side around you.
I am confident he will be fine in FG in time

I get the experience thing, but experience does not have much to do with "mobility".

I fully get he might miss a tackle or knock the ball on, but to me he does not look like he has the general level of athleticism of the 'average/good' NRL players. Every player may drop a ball or throw a forward pass, but I dunno if natural abilities can be developed as much.
 
You've got to remember these kids aren't match fit. Hasn't been a NSW cup match for months. They have to try go from nothing to NRL.

For starters he's a lock. Not a second rower. He's got decent ball skills and offloading. He needs to improve on his defence, fitness etc but give him an offseason and more time to learn
 
Answers a lot of questions.....we have a very young INEXPERIENCED SQUAD......but many seem to expect the coach to produce match winners every game.....unfortunately the NRL doesnt seem to work that way,only on very rare occasions do teams like Storm or Roosters have someone in the ranks NRL ready at any one time....
 
Perspective is a wonderful thing - the kid is 19, eligible for Jersey Flegg but has played KOE all season - anyone expecting him to come in and turn our fortunes around in the middle of the field needs to re-adjust their expectations. He has a stack of improvement left in him and will come good with time and experience.
 
@willow said in [Tuki Simpkins](/post/1432414) said:
Perspective is a wonderful thing - the kid is 19, eligible for Jersey Flegg but has played KOE all season - anyone expecting him to come in and turn our fortunes around in the middle of the field needs to re-adjust their expectations. He has a stack of improvement left in him and will come good with time and experience.


Correct, and the only way to improve is to play more NRL games, the same applies to Tuilagi, Simpkin, Dias, Cooper, Hoffman, …
We given Packer, Talau, Nofoaluma, Tamau, Roberts, BJ, LL, Mbye too many chances!
 
@inbenjiwetrust said in [Tuki Simpkins](/post/1432422) said:
@willow said in [Tuki Simpkins](/post/1432414) said:
Perspective is a wonderful thing - the kid is 19, eligible for Jersey Flegg but has played KOE all season - anyone expecting him to come in and turn our fortunes around in the middle of the field needs to re-adjust their expectations. He has a stack of improvement left in him and will come good with time and experience.


Correct, and the only way to improve is to play more NRL games, the same applies to Tuilagi, Simpkin, Dias, Cooper, Hoffman, …
We given Packer, Talau, Nofoaluma, Tamau, Roberts, BJ, LL, Mbye too many chances!



Difference is all the guys you mentioned have had heaps of chances,they also are very NRL experienced as well as rep players....you cant seriously compare the kids to them....they will take time and patience to even get to NRL standard and we dont want to ruin their confidence or get them a long term injury just to satisfy an opinion...

ps exception is Talau...
 
Somebody stop this bloke from offloading 😅

Its every damn tackle and idk how he does it 😂

Keep em comming
 
Tuki Simpkins has 8 offloads from 23 career runs so far. Lot of physical development left for him but looks like his main skill in NSW Cup will and has carried into the NRL
 
I think Madge is doing the right thing with these young guys. He gives them a taste then drops them back to still train with the team and work on stuff they need to. When he thinks they are ready to get another run he brings them back in. The program is hampered by no KOE but he is bringing a few younger players through.
As for Tuki I think he is a future frontrower with an offload. Needs to keep working on his mobility and ball skills and will be great.
 
@jirskyr said in [Tuki Simpkins](/post/1445759) said:
Good kid Tuki, very much of the Gibbs / Galloway tall build, but with a wicked offload. Good pickup.

I really don't see a lot of similarities between Gibbs/ Galloway and Tuki. Tuki is a lot more agile with better footwork and a stronger passing game, he is that mobile lock we have been looking for. He needs to work on his motor and fitness to allow him to get through more work, especially in defence.
 
Back
Top