OK, so it seems the 5 coaches in the running are Cleary, Payten, Toovey, Webster and Daley. I'm really not sold on any of them:
Cleary- 49% win record doesn't really have me all that excited. He had a lot of quality players in the sides from 2006-2011 and wasn't able to get them a grand final win. 4 years with the panthers and they only had 1 season over 50%. Supposed to be a nice bloke and good manager of his players but isn't that what Poetter was.
Payten- Unknown quantity, well liked by some of the players which could be a positive or a negative. I know people are saying they don't want a rookie coach which is fair enough but the Cowboys are doing pretty well with their rookie coach who they took a chance on a few years ago. Manly and St George have coaches they took on as rookies. Now neither of those teams are going fantastically but we wouldn't be the first team to take a punt.
Toovey- For me he is a myth. Good tough player but as a coach he was gifted a championship side and had a few good years. Was dumped after 1 bad season and spat the dummy continually when his team get the call he wanted. I believe he baby sat that side and if not for the good work of Des Hasler in setting the side up he wouldn't have been as successful. For me he is a goose.
Webster- Same as Payten.
Daley- Tough to come up against the QLD side for 3 games a year on limited preperation. Not sure how he would go over a whole season and without having quality players in every position. I think he would be found wanting.
I don't know if Webster is a long term coach but i would like to see how he goes with the side before we make a decision.