Wests Tigers Team v Canterbury Rd 7

[Tiger5150]

I'd be tempted to play Walters instead of Reynolds.


Woah careful with those crazy suggestions in here magic. Reynolds tries hard and requires continual encouragement in here. Credit where its due.

I just cant understand why the Coach of this team isn't tempted to play Walters at 5/8 or put him on the bench....maybe he knows something more than we do...
I like Walters and he seems to have a go everytime he goes out there,,,but Im not the coach...JR must be doing what Madge needs him to do,maybe that's why he is selected to play 5/8...


I agree with you TT. For mine Walters matches Reynolds in his only asset which is effort and energy. IMO there is nothing else in JR's game that Walters couldnt match, plus much more upside. Maybe its an experience thing Madge sees but again in my IMO, Reynolds is not going to be calling plays so I dont see why that would be a factor.

We were both posting at the same time by the look of it ...I stated that Madge might be going with experience more than anything,particularly with some of our quality players out...

Experience plays a part sure, but I think Madge has made it pretty clear that he's looking for defence. While JRey misses his fair share of tackles, he is typically a relatively good defender for a half, brings plenty of aggression and energy. Plus he should have some added incentive this week.

I dont disagree with any of this, but my memory of Walters early in the year is his defence was pretty robust. In Madge we trust I guess.

 

[ElleryHanley]

Danger game for us but one we simply must win.
But we are WT so ...... lol!

To be fair...it is a legit 50/50 game now.

Dogs pack looks better, our 7-9 are much better.

Dogs will consider this a must win also.

 

[Snake]

Danger game for us but one we simply must win.
But we are WT so ...... lol!

To be fair...it is a legit 50/50 game now.

Dogs pack looks better, our 7-9 are much better.

Dogs will consider this a must win also.

Dogs are specials ! There pack will roll over the Tigers ..

 

[boonboon]

The most wests tigers supporter thing ever - thinking a 26yr old with 4 nrl games as a bench hooker shoukd replace an ex Origin winner with 150 plus nrl games coming off a match where we convincingly beat the opposition and he set up multiple tries.

 

[Tiger5150]

The most wests tigers supporter thing ever - thinking a 26yr old with 4 nrl games as a bench hooker shoukd replace an ex Origin winner with 150 plus nrl games coming off a match where we convincingly beat the opposition ***and he set up multiple tries***.

**head explodes**

 

[TheDaBoss]

https://www.weststigers.com.au/news/2020/06/23/press-conference-luke-garner/

https://www.weststigers.com.au/news/2020/06/23/press-conference-harry-grant/

 

[TheDaBoss]

WE play our 500th game against the Dogs btw

 

[Sart0ri]

The most wests tigers supporter thing ever - thinking a 26yr old with 4 nrl games as a bench hooker shoukd replace an ex Origin winner with 150 plus nrl games coming off a match where we convincingly beat the opposition and he set up multiple tries.

He also kept rushing out of the line creating huge holes and gave momentum to the Cowboys several times with some poor early kicks when Tigers were not aware to chase and an intercept.

The Cowboys should have kicked behind Reynolds a few times.

 

[jadtiger]

WE play our 500th game against the Dogs btw

Even combined i cant see how Balmain/Magpies/WT would have played the dogs 500 times.I am happy to be corrected but i just cant see it,the dogs in any entity have only been around just over 80 years

 

[coivtny]

WE play our 500th game against the Dogs btw

Even combined i cant see how Balmain/Magpies/WT would have played the dogs 500 times.I am happy to be corrected but i just cant see it,the dogs in any entity have only been around just over 80 years

Hahaha. Don't think that's what he meant. I think he meant WT 500th game against anyone.

 

[WT2K]

Perenara the ref

 

[TieDye]

Perenara the ref

The flog**

 

[BalmainJnr]

Perenara the ref

Well atleast we know which way the 50/50s are going in this one. You would swear at times he was the one tackled at Campbelltown but ultimately he just isn’t very good at his job.

 

[Guest]

Perenara the ref

Well atleast we know which way the 50/50s are going in this one. You would swear at times he was the one tackled at Campbelltown but ultimately he just isn’t very good at his job.

He sucks his job. I mean I've seen refs suck, but this guy is the suckiest suck who ever sucked.

 

[TrueTiger]

Perenara the ref

Well atleast we know which way the 50/50s are going in this one. You would swear at times he was the one tackled at Campbelltown but ultimately he just isn’t very good at his job.

He sucks his job. I mean I've seen refs suck, but this guy is the suckiest suck who ever sucked.

So you don't rate him mate...:-1:

 

[Geo]

Perenara the ref

Well atleast we know which way the 50/50s are going in this one. You would swear at times he was the one tackled at Campbelltown but ultimately he just isn’t very good at his job.

He sucks his job. I mean I've seen refs suck, but this guy is the suckiest suck who ever sucked.

Funnily enough I reckon Henri has been one of the better refs with the new rules...seems to ref both teams the same..we won with him last week..

The guy who sucks the most is Gee..have not won a game with him past 6 outings..he's a Klein protege..look at me look at me...

 

[Spartan117]

Gee, Marshall must be well and truly on the outer with Maguire. I really expected him to be picked, with Reynolds coming off the bench to replace Harry Grant (he's a star in the making but 60 min at this stage will have bigger impact that 80 min, IMO).

I dare say if were stuck with JRey then we will see more of him at Benjis expense.

Lets face it we need to stip relying on him as our crutch.

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Perenara the ref

Well atleast we know which way the 50/50s are going in this one. You would swear at times he was the one tackled at Campbelltown but ultimately he just isn’t very good at his job.

He sucks his job. I mean I've seen refs suck, but this guy is the suckiest suck who ever sucked.

Funnily enough I reckon Henri has been one of the better refs with the new rules...seems to ref both teams the same..we won with him last week..

The guy who sucks the most is Gee..have not won a game with him past 6 outings..he's a Klein protege..look at me look at me...

Sutton is the worst I reckon.

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Gee, Marshall must be well and truly on the outer with Maguire. I really expected him to be picked, with Reynolds coming off the bench to replace Harry Grant (he's a star in the making but 60 min at this stage will have bigger impact that 80 min, IMO).

I dare say if were stuck with JRey then we will see more of him at Benjis expense.

Lets face it we need to stip relying on him as our crutch.

Need to get our money’s worth out of Reynolds, he’s being paid the big bucks