Wests Tigers Team v Cronulla

[hobbo]

Buchanan should be nowhere near the team, Taylor and his favourites are crueling us already, Get MCK, JAC, Griffin and the like in there and replace the ones who should be in NSW cup before it is too late.

JAC / MCK / Griffin won't hang around , they'll get snapped up by other teams .

It's top 8 or bye bye JT !!!!

The only one that would be a chance of being snapped up is JAC. The other 2 would have been long snapped up if they were that good. Particularly Griffin.

Well going by your judgment ( not having a go ) it just proves how I inept the club is in its player signings …

Look at Adam Blair ( sheens era) we couldn't get a fart out of him , now he's killing it at the Broncos .
Look at Taupau ( potter /Talylor era) we were lucky to get 80 mins from Taupau in 3 games , but all of a sudden he can play 80 mins for manly.
This club Friggin SUCKS when it comes to player signings , player retention & team selections.
JT's slowly digging his grave picking hacks like Lovett/ Halatau / Buchanan / Rankin .

It's top 8 or JT needs to log onto seek.com

 

[stevetiger]

Finally that plodder is gone

I don't want to hack the guy but what do you say.

 

[Nelson]

Hopefully JT starts feeling some pressure this week after his stupid bench selections backfired & we see at least a couple of changes…Edwards & Griffin should be getting a run at prop ahead of Buchanan. MCK over Lovett and probably Halatau as well.

 

[Nelson]

hobbo, bit rough on Rankin. He may be serviceable at best, but the money he is likely on makes him worthwhile.

Where does Buchanan rate amongst Matthew Lodge and Matt Groat?

Lodge > Cashmere (for the high pants) > Buchanan > Bambi > Groat

 

[white]

in all seriousness how are edwards and co going in state league. does mark oneill have any input in team selections as well

 

[barra]

Fingers crossed that Grant is cleared to play… if not, it shows how inept some of these selections are.

:brick: Buchanan
:brick: Halatau/Cherrington
:brick: Lovett
:brick: Rankin

Actually even with Grant we'll be lucky to be in it with the above.

 

[hobbo]

hobbo, bit rough on Rankin. He may be serviceable at best, but the money he is likely on makes him worthwhile.

Where does Buchanan rate amongst Matthew Lodge and Matt Groat?

Lodge could've been a weapon if he wasn't such a Tool .
So we never found out .

Groat was garbage , although sheens killed him too early ..

Buchanan plays like he's on Rohypnol's .
Galloway was a plodder , but compared to Buchannan , he's an immortal !
Ryan O'hara was better than Buchannan and that's saying something .

 

[The-moP]

NO, NO, NO, this is beyond a joke, has anyone got Taylor's mobile number. Better still what's the Boards number .. not happy at all .. !!!

It's not rocket science JT, it's called selecting the best suited players for the position for the given day. Picking the same plodders who bring nothing, and give nothing to the side is ridiculous.

Have we ever won a game with both plodders A and B in the side .. ?? If we keep picking the same side that that we tested with last game, we're gonna get beat again. It didn't work last time so why should it work this time. Stop selecting dead wood and start pick players who have something they can offer to the side (speed, mobility and size)

If the players don't play on instinct and click together, it's obvious that our coach hasn't got the skills to coach them out of a wet paper bag, if we don't get over the line this weekend, I'm sorry but it's time to go JT .. !! :rant :brick: :rant

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Buchanan should be nowhere near the team, Taylor and his favourites are crueling us already, Get MCK, JAC, Griffin and the like in there and replace the ones who should be in NSW cup before it is too late.

JAC / MCK / Griffin won't hang around , they'll get snapped up by other teams .

It's top 8 or bye bye JT !!!!

The only one that would be a chance of being snapped up is JAC. The other 2 would have been long snapped up if they were that good. Particularly Griffin.

Well going by your judgment ( not having a go ) it just proves how I inept the club is in its player signings …

Look at Adam Blair ( sheens era) we couldn't get a fart out of him , now he's killing it at the Broncos .
Look at Taupau ( potter /Talylor era) we were lucky to get 80 mins from Taupau in 3 games , but all of a sudden he can play 80 mins for manly.
This club Friggin SUCKS when it comes to player signings and player retention ...
JT's slowly digging his grave picking hacks like Lovett/ Halatau / Buchanan / Rankin .

It's top 8 or JT needs to log onto seek.com

That's what happens when you're inept in operating your cap. TigerTorch even said last week that the reason why guys like JAC and MCK haven't played so far was due to the cap.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Why are people getting upset with the team that's named? Teams that play Monday, always name the same team Tuesday. There will be changes.

 

[851]

Why are people getting upset with the team that's named? Teams that play Monday, always name the same team Tuesday. There will be changes.

Because we know how our coach operates :crazy

 

[diedpretty]

Wests Tigers
1 James Tedesco
2 David Nofoaluma
3 Tim Simona
4 Kevin Naiqama
5 Jordan Rankin
6 Mitchell Moses
7 Luke Brooks
8 Aaron Woods ©
9 Robbie Farah
10 Tim Grant
11 Chris Lawrence
12 Dene Halatau
13 Sauaso Sue

Interchange
14 Ava Seumanufagai
15 Kyle Lovett
16 Joshua Aloiai
17 Manaia Cherrington
18 Jack Buchanan

Coach: Jason Taylor

http://www.nrl.com/round-5-nrl-team-lists/tabid/10874/newsid/94284/default.aspx

Would play Sue in the prop rotation from the bench replacing Lovett. Halatau to lock, Aloiai to starting side and CheeKam/Edwards to bench.

 

[Curaeus]

I assume Edwards is injured at the moment. He or Griffin would have to be a better bet than Buchanan or Lovett.

 

[Mac_tiger]

I'm OK with it - Jack won't play, Rob to start and interchange with Cherry. Best we have until Curtis is back. I hope Edwards and MCK aren't too far off being chosen though.

 

[Geo]

Grant still has to pass his cog test..

I expect changes… :wink:

 

[hobbo]

Grant still has to pass his cog test..

I expect changes… :wink:

I hope happy passes this weeks cog test ?
He's been awfully quiet the last few days !

 

[Bob]

Meaningless until Lovett's gone through the judiciary and Grant's seen the neurologist. Buchannan will probably replace one of them unfortunately.

Lovett quite sensibly escaped any charges.

 

[Masterton]

Have we ever won a game with both plodders A and B in the side .. ?? If we keep picking the same side that that we tested with last game, we're gonna get beat again. It didn't work last time so why should it work this time. Stop selecting dead wood and start pick players who have something they can offer to the side (speed, mobility and size)

We beat Parra, Melbourne and Raiders with them last year.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Isnt Lovett going to be suspended ?
Buch should just sit this out for his poor efforts

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Hopefully JT starts feeling some pressure this week after his stupid bench selections backfired & we see at least a couple of changes…Edwards & Griffin should be getting a run at prop ahead of Buchanan. MCK over Lovett and probably Halatau as well.

I don't think JT handles pressure too well
He might make even more bizarre selections under pressure