Where does Jason Taylor go with our great hooker policy now?!

[goldcoast_tiger]

Continuous harassment of any kind can be evidence of bullying By a superior.

((And I use the word superior, for want of a more suitable word)these laws are meant for all people. As this is being played out in public, by Taylor.
He needs to be carefull in what he does
He's clearly the best hooker in the club. Also Taylor has threatened him with demotion before a ball was kicked.
I'm no lawyer, but you know what courts are like these days
It's just interesting.

I don't think he could go to court and get a decision but there is a lot of truth here. It's harassment in a lot of situations.

You have to be rational in your criticism and factual. That isn't happening.

Hypothetical. Although I do think there is a long way to go with this.

 

[stevetiger]

I am sure Robbie will be fine after footy. He has always looked out for himself.

I wonder if Robbie is as bad a guy as he is made out to be. Do you have facts to back your comment up ?

 

[rialto]

Well the roosters costed themselves a grand final by letting Minichello play in the semis, and had a shocker against souths when they were up 12-0 he dropped everything that came to him, sometimes loyalty can cost you.

If Farah was any other player and not on the amount of money he is and not a former captain or origin player he should have been dropped months ago because of form.

but it's clear taylor waited till after origin to do this, he knew Farah was gonna play origin and had to keep him in the team to save all that contravsary out, now that origin is over it is no co-incidence he is sent to reserve grade, and he no doubt has played his last origin too

So Taylor did the right thing waiting till after soo?

 

[tig_prmz]

been away for a few days so missed the great farah dropping.

this doesn't make sense at all.. why drop a player of farah's stature when he hasn't even been playing bad, esp after naming him in the line up a day earlier?

more personal now. pathetic call. we saw how we went without a specialised hooker against the roosters when jake friend absolutely carved up.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

I am sure Robbie will be fine after footy. He has always looked out for himself.

someone's finally starting to make some sense of this fiasco in this thread that starts rhetorically. Thank you Rialto.

And FYI Rialto - I worked at Rialto - great people.

Robbie - we'll talk soon. Love ya bro.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

been away for a few days so missed the great farah dropping.

this doesn't make sense at all.. why drop a player of farah's stature when he hasn't even been playing bad, esp after naming him in the line up a day earlier?

more personal now. pathetic call. we saw how we went without a specialised hooker against the roosters when jake friend absolutely carved up.

Of course he did, because Pearce wasn't there, so he had to stand up. With us we have the halves and Tedesco. Taylor doesn't want 4 playmakers and at this stage in their careers, Farah is the most expendable.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

GNR your comments echo many people's voices.

 

[tig_prmz]

every other team is ok with 4 playmakers lol.

a dummy half is irreplacable.. you can possibly go into a game with 1 half instead of 2 but you need a spealist hooker in your team if you have one available. he can replace farah with cherrington if cherry was in form and farah wasn't. but farah has been playing to the game plan and actually been playing good off the bench.

this is nothing but personal.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

yes - but it's his neck on the line - can you see any honor or reason there?

 

[stevetiger]

every other team is ok with 4 playmakers lol.

a dummy half is irreplacable.. you can possibly go into a game with 1 half instead of 2 but you need a spealist hooker in your team if you have one available. he can replace farah with cherrington if cherry was in form and farah wasn't. but farah has been playing to the game plan and actually been playing good off the bench.

this is nothing but personal.

It's hard for some dudes on here to grasp that Robbie plays dummy half and Tedesco, Brooks, Moses, ET, Woods, every other play on the team actually play different roles than Robbie.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

i think its hard for all of us to grasp what's happening out there on the field in game time. Who's talking - who's not. If you are a trainer then please accept my apologies. For the rest of us - we don't know what's going on Steve. Please enlighten us.

 

[Cosimo_Zaretti]

every other team is ok with 4 playmakers lol.

Yeah Jake Granville seems to play what's in front of him, despite having the one of the besf best creative halves pairings in the game outside him. If he sees the hole, he runs it and there's no one demanding Granville be dropped to get more ball to Morgan and Thurston.

 

[Nelson]

every other team is ok with 4 playmakers lol.

Yeah Jake Granville seems to play what's in front of him, despite having the one of the besf best creative halves pairings in the game outside him. If he sees the hole, he runs it and there's no one demanding Granville be dropped to get more ball to Morgan and Thurston.

I think the argument is that there are 4 playmakers plus Farah - Brooks, Moses, Teddy and ET. The cowboys don't have a ball playing lock, they have a human battering ram.

 

[magpiecol]

Am I the only person who thinks Jason Taylor is doing a good job?

Robbie Farah is cancerous. He needs to go.

Why is Robbie cancerous ? Where is the proof ?

JT came in and said numerous dumb comments and he has continued that up until today.

Why not let one of our best every players who is still playing quality footy play out this season and next season at the club ? Why make that decision ?

Because he is the coach.

 

[happy_tiger]

every other team is ok with 4 playmakers lol.

Yeah Jake Granville seems to play what's in front of him, despite having the one of the besf best creative halves pairings in the game outside him. If he sees the hole, he runs it and there's no one demanding Granville be dropped to get more ball to Morgan and Thurston.

Granville would put two yards in Robbie over 15 metres and doesn't stuff around looking for a penalty

Massive difference

 

[sheer64]

every other team is ok with 4 playmakers lol.

Yeah Jake Granville seems to play what's in front of him, despite having the one of the besf best creative halves pairings in the game outside him. If he sees the hole, he runs it and there's no one demanding Granville be dropped to get more ball to Morgan and Thurston.

Granville would put two yards in Robbie over 15 metres and doesn't stuff around looking for a penalty

Massive difference

Granville cant even play 80 minutes yes massive difference.

 

[stevetiger]

Am I the only person who thinks Jason Taylor is doing a good job?

Robbie Farah is cancerous. He needs to go.

Why is Robbie cancerous ? Where is the proof ?

JT came in and said numerous dumb comments and he has continued that up until today.

Why not let one of our best every players who is still playing quality footy play out this season and next season at the club ? Why make that decision ?

Because he is the coach.

Thanks Col. I love hearing well thought out arguments.

 

[Nelson]

Granville cant even play 80 minutes yes massive difference.

He can play 80 minutes, Green just chooses not to use him that way.

 

[Tigermama]

Dripping with irony.

Yeah its dripping with irony of course.

Im suggesting a coach is responsible for selections of the his team.

It a big stretch to make I know!!

Especially considering Farahs recent benching anf JAC being dropped for Rankin.

Anyway, lets blame ONeill. Im sure he came in the office on Thursday's and says "lets rest Farah and play ET at hooker"

GNR simple question do you not think Taylor is getting the team he wants? Do you really believe that? If you do just tell us mate instead of dancing around it talking about committee?

:laughing:

So why did you credit him and the selectors when we were wining?

GNR, Gallagher

Do you want me to find the posts praising Taylor when we won against Souths? Praising him when we won 2 in a row? Bagging Farah when he opend his mouth? Bagging Farah that he was playing average football?

IM capable of doing both. I dont just sit on one side of the argument. I can praise Taylor and call him out. You guys cant bring yourselves to do that.

I talk about the coach when we win and when he lose as he is accountable for winning and losing.

You blokes when every poor selection is made try and talk about Oneill.

Oh Buckets bought in the Pizzas thats why we lost!!!

Oh Buckets is in the coaching box he must be in his ear!!

Oh Buckets is picking the team now so its not Taylors fault!!

If thats not deflecting im not sure what it.

Keep digging though

Keep it going though its entertaining.

Is it ever JTs fault at all guys??

The briliant and masterful JT can do no wrong…Ever :master:

 

[Harvey]

every other team is ok with 4 playmakers lol.

Yeah Jake Granville seems to play what's in front of him, despite having the one of the besf best creative halves pairings in the game outside him. If he sees the hole, he runs it and there's no one demanding Granville be dropped to get more ball to Morgan and Thurston.

Lately Farah has not been looking for a hole, he has been looking for a defender that he thinks is offside (usually because a quick play the ball has opposition backpedalling) and runs straight into them, stops and looks at referee.