Your side to play Panthers

[Magpie1969]

As long as Marshall, Lawrence, Garner and Packer are not in the 17 next week I really don't care who is picked. It will just be a training run for Penrith who will rack up a big score.

 

[izotope]

1 Moses Mbye
2 David Nofoaluma
3 BJ Leilua
4 Tommy Talau
5 Asu Kepaoa
6 Adam Doueihi
7 Luke Brooks
8 Josh Aloiai
9 Harry Grant
10 Alex Twal
11 Luciano Leilua
12 Shaun Blore
13 Matthew Eisenhuth

14 Jacob Liddle
15 Thomas Mikaele (middle forward)
16 Sam McIntyre (middle forward)
17 Luke Garner (backup centre/2nd row/lock)

Brooks and Doueihi as halves could work if Grant plays a controlling role in the middle like Cam Smith does.
Musgove is due back round 16-18 so may be available

like this, try brooks last chance saloon. Otherwise give madden a taste following week.
Musgrove back, twal to 13 and musgrove takes prop slot. eiso drops.

Think thats the best we can do

 

[Chainlink]

Please put Garner back in the left to run lines of Brooks.

Doueihi
Nofo
Talau
BJ
AJ
Mbye
Brooks
Aloiai
Liddle
Twal
Lucy
Garner
Eisenhuth

Grant
Mikaele
Blore
Musgrove / McIntyre

 

[avocadoontoast]

As long as Packer, Marshall and Brooks aren’t there I’ll be happy.

 

[walter]

Who cares our season is over you don’t deserve to make the finals if you lose more games then you win

 

[Goanna57]

As long as Marshall, Lawrence, Garner and Packer are not in the 17 next week I really don't care who is picked. It will just be a training run for Penrith who will rack up a big score.

So what does it matter if the players you mentioned are in the side or not ,we are just moving deck chairs we do not have quality

 

[Krammy]

1.Kepaoa - apparently can play any postion in the backline why not
2.Nofo - makes sense been one of our consistent players
3.J.Leilua - give him the year see if he can hit form
4.Hoffman - lets see what hes got
5.Talau - still has defensive issues but ive been impressed by hes attack last few weeks
6.Doueihi - his passing game is really good, i think this will be his best postion
7.Brooks - last chance ,Madden next week if it doesnt work out
8.Aloiai - most consistent forward
9.Grant - i dont want to put him here cause hes leaving and it makes no sense
10.Clark - love his defense
11.Garner - his defense needs works but he hits hard and can break the line, i think garner is a great back up player to have around
12.L.Leilua - 2nd best forward
13.Twai -

14.Liddle - been great i dont wanna leave him out of the side,honestly think he should be starting
15.Mikaele - Impact
16.Blore - Impact
17.McIntyre

Would love to see more of Seyfarth
Cini and Simpkin hopefully should get a run too

I agree with the choice of team here. Clarke is SO much better than Packer in defence and he wouldn't have to do much to add more to the attack than Packer as well.

 

[Magpie1969]

As long as Marshall, Lawrence, Garner and Packer are not in the 17 next week I really don't care who is picked. It will just be a training run for Penrith who will rack up a big score.

So what does it matter if the players you mentioned are in the side or not ,we are just moving deck chairs we do not have quality

Goanna57 agree with your comments on quality depth. Marshall and Lawrence
won't be playing in 2021, Garner is worth persisting with but feel he needs a break and
made to work on his game. Packer is just taking the piss. lack of runs, lazy defence.
Marshall replaced by Madden, Lawrence replaced with Blore, Garner replaced by McIntyre
And Packer by Clarke until Musgrove comes back.

 

[Goanna57]

As long as Marshall, Lawrence, Garner and Packer are not in the 17 next week I really don't care who is picked. It will just be a training run for Penrith who will rack up a big score.

So what does it matter if the players you mentioned are in the side or not ,we are just moving deck chairs we do not have quality

Goanna57 agree with your comments on quality depth. Marshall and Lawrence
won't be playing in 2021, Garner is worth persisting with but feel he needs a break and
made to work on his game. Packer is just taking the piss. lack of runs, lazy defence.
Marshall replaced by Madden, Lawrence replaced with Blore, Garner replaced by McIntyre
And Packer by Clarke until Musgrove comes back.

Magpie agree I have no problem with change and I don’t care who the player is.The one criteria I have is player coming in is going to make us stronger,not change for change sake

 

[turkeytiger03]

I’d go with
1 Doueihi
2 Nofoaluma
3 BJ
4 Mbye
5 Talau
6 Brooks
7 Madden/Grant
8 Alioia
9 Liddell
10 Twal
11 Garner
12 McIntyre
13 LL
14 Grant / Madden
15 Blore
16 Seyfarth
17 Eisenhuth

 

[PabloX]

1 Moses Mbye
2 David Nofoaluma
3 BJ Leilua
4 Tommy Talau
5 Asu Kepaoa
6 Adam Doueihi
7 Luke Brooks
8 Josh Aloiai
9 Harry Grant
10 Alex Twal
11 Luciano Leilua
12 Shaun Blore
13 Matthew Eisenhuth

14 Jacob Liddle
15 Thomas Mikaele (middle forward)
16 Sam McIntyre (middle forward)
17 Luke Garner (backup centre/2nd row/lock)

Brooks and Doueihi as halves could work if Grant plays a controlling role in the middle like Cam Smith does.
Musgove is due back round 16-18 so may be available

Getting close to what I was thinking. I'd keep AD at the back and give Madden a run instead. That's the pack I'd love to see though

 

[Wagga_Tiger]

1 Mbye
2 Nofa
3 BJ
4 Talau
5 Asu
6 Doueihi
7 Brooks
8 Aloiai
9 Liddle
10 Clark
11 Luciano (RHS)
12 Garner (LHS)
13 Twal
14 Huth
15 Mikaele
16 Grant
17 Blore

 

[Russell]

1-JAC
2-Nofo
3-BJ
4-Talau
5-AJ
6-Doueihi
7-Brooks
8-Aloiai
9-Liddle
10-Twal
11-Garner
12-Lucy
13-Eiso
14-Grant
15-Mikaele
16-Blore
17-Mbye

How are you playing JAC against Pamfers THIS week?

 

[Geo]

1 Kepaoa
2 Hoffman
3 Leilua
4 Mbye
5 Jennings

6 Reynolds
7 Marshall

8 Packer
9 Taylor
10 Seyfarth
11. McQueen
12 Garner
13 Clark

14 Mikaele
15 Madden
16 Blore
17 McIntyre

 

[balmain boy]

Doueihi
Nof
Talau
Leilua
Kapaoa
Madden
Brooks
Aloiai
Grant
Mikaele
Leilua
Blore
Twal

Liddle
Eiso
Clark
Garner/MCK

Talau is a right centre, let's put him there. need to break up the right side defence.

Madden needs a run but needs someone experienced alongside him. Brooks/Reynolds doesn't make much difference

 

[mike]

1-JAC
2-Nofo
3-BJ
4-Talau
5-AJ
6-Doueihi
7-Brooks
8-Aloiai
9-Liddle
10-Twal
11-Garner
12-Lucy
13-Eiso
14-Grant
15-Mikaele
16-Blore
17-Mbye

How are you playing JAC against Pamfers THIS week?

Fantasied about how just one player would make a huge difference. You got to admit that backline looks pretty good with just the addition of one marquee player.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

are we able to give simpkin a run ? if so i would leave out Grant if he is heading back to melbourne

 

[avocadoontoast]

If Madden and Blore don't get a run this week Madge is kidding himself.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

1. Mmbye
2. Nofo
3. Joey L
4. Talau
5. Hoffman or Jennings if they are keeping him
6. Douhie
7. Brooks
8. Aloia
9. Liddle
10. Packer
11. Luciano L
12. Garner
13. Twal
14. Simpkin
15. Mikaele
16. Blore
17. Clark

 

[The-moP]

1 Moses Mbye
2 David Nofoaluma
3 BJ Leilua
4 Adam Doueihi
5 Tommy Talau
6 Josh Reynolds
7 Luke Brooks
8 Josh Aloiai
9 Harry Grant
10 Russell Packer
11 Luciano Leilua
12 Matthew Eisenhuth
13 Alex Twal

14 Jacob Liddle
15 Thomas Mikaele (middle forward)
16 Sam McIntyre (middle forward)
17 Shaun Blore (prop/2nd row/lock)