Your team v Silvertail Scum..

@mike said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218171) said:
1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kepaoa
3 Joey Leilua
4 Tommy Talau
5 David Nofoaluma
6 Adam Doueihi
7 Jock Madden
8 Josh Aloai
9 Jacob Liddle
10 Thomas Mikaele
11 Luciano Leilua
12 Luke Garner
13 Alex Twal
14 Shawn Blore
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Sam McIntyre
17 Moses Mbye
18 Harry Grant
19 Matt Eisenhuth
20 Josh Reynolds
21 Russell Packer

It was our forwards who were smashed against. the Panthers. What changes have you made to the forwards to. ensure this. doesn't happen again?
 
@kiwitiger said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218046) said:
So Jock Madden has gone from promising player for the future to fg halfback by playing no games all year. All good promoting youngsters on the back of good form but this is just hoping to win the lottery. Throw him in and hope.
Reminds me of Blake Lazarus. Great talent according to some on here...until he played first grade. I think madge is pragmatic enough that if these young players were the answer he would have picked them by now. Its not as if he hasn't already given some youngsters a go this year.

I agree it is undesirable to select any young player, let alone a half to play behind our pack.
 
Not really fussed about what team runs out this weekend. But would like to see Madden or Simpkins get a little game time and experience over the remaining few rounds.
 
My only concern is that Madden gets man of the match, gets hailed a future Origin half and is likened to the next Joey Johns......then history repeats itself for the next 7 years.......
 
1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kepaoa
3 Joey Leilua
4 Tommy Talau
5 David Nofoaluma
6 Adam Doueihi
7 Jock Madden
8 Josh Aloai
9 Jacob Liddle
10 Thomas Mikaele
11 Luciano Leilua
12 Luke Garner
13 Alex Twal
14 Shawn Blore
15. Packer
16.McKntyre
17. Seyfarth
 
@Andyvee said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218358) said:
My only concern is that Madden gets man of the match, gets hailed a future Origin half and is likened to the next Joey Johns......then history repeats itself for the next 7 years.......

but you got to understand

we on the forum have very low expectations and wil never over or under rate any player :smirk:
 
@Telltails said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1217831) said:
I wish they would retire the white jersey can't remember ever playing well in them let alone winning.


Superstitious I know, but if I see them run out in the white jersey I switch the Tele off.
 
1. Doueihi (I think he will be a better 5/8 but right now probably our safest option.)
2. Nof
3. BJ
4. Talau
5. Kepeoa

6. Mbye (Worth a shot)
7. Madden

8. Musgrove
9. Liddle
10. Aloiai
11. Garner (Very much rocks and diamonds, but made the panthers work hard to tackle him quite a few times on Saturday night)
12. Luciano
13. Twal

14. Marshall (I think he may need to come into the game if the halves are struggling. Also think he is a better option than Reynolds or Brooks for that role.)
15. Grant (Simpkins will get his shot, but Grant will keep the roll on, and can go into the Lock role Brandon Smith style which I think would be beneficial)
16. Mikaele
17. McIntyre

18. Blore (He is solid in attack but still getting a bit gassed in defence, a full madge pre-season will have him flying next year)
19. Eiso
20. Reynolds
21. Brooks
 
@happy_tiger said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218310) said:
@Geo said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1217797) said:
Time for the future..

1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kapaoa
3 Reece Hoffman
4 Tommy Talau
5 Robert Jennings

6 Moses Mbye
7 Jock Madden

8 Alex Seyfarth
9 Josh Reynolds
10 Oliver Clark
11 Sam McIntyre
12 Chris McQueen
13 Shawn Blore

14 Russell Packer
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Jake Simpkin
17 Moses Mbye or A Stick only gets a few minutes anyway

All off contract players given a run to see if they get a go..Young blokes exposed to NRL may as well to see if they are any good..if not punt them too

The big 3 in Mbye Packer and Reynolds on show to lead the side to Glory and sweeten the pot for perspective suitors..

Heard A Stick has put us over the cap again ...another 2 year fine coming up

2ndly ...no skulls with that squad ....none of us would survive


Hospitals couldn't handle the that many stomachs being pumped pout at once out

I've decided to replace A Stick with Micheal Chee-Kam in 17..
 
1. Mbye
2. Nofo
3. Leilua
4. Talau
5. AJ
6. AD
7. Madden
8. Aloiai
9. Liddle
10. Mikaele
11. Luc
12. Blore
13. Twal
14. Simpkin
15. Eiso
16. McIntyre
17. Musgrove (if fit)
 
@pawsandclaws1 said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218341) said:
@mike said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218171) said:
1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kepaoa
3 Joey Leilua
4 Tommy Talau
5 David Nofoaluma
6 Adam Doueihi
7 Jock Madden
8 Josh Aloai
9 Jacob Liddle
10 Thomas Mikaele
11 Luciano Leilua
12 Luke Garner
13 Alex Twal
14 Shawn Blore
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Sam McIntyre
17 Moses Mbye
18 Harry Grant
19 Matt Eisenhuth
20 Josh Reynolds
21 Russell Packer

It was our forwards who were smashed against. the Panthers. What changes have you made to the forwards to. ensure this. doesn't happen again?

I’d put Musgrove in their but I don’t think he is fit. Other than that there is really not a lot to choose from.
 
Sounds like Madden and Simpkin might get a run but if they do it’ll probably be off the bench. It sounds like Madge will stick with Benji in the team for whatever reason.

Besides those two there’s no one else who hasn’t had a run yet. Dylan Smith, Kane Bradley, Zac Cini all haven’t played either but Id be surprised if they got a shot.
 
Might have to calculate Marshall into remaining games if the rumors are true been tapped on the shoulder and last season at the Tigers although wants to play on.
Let it be known now if he plays for another club that it will be one year too long, sounds like he still thinks he has something to offer however as supporters its time to move on and support Madge.
 
@mike said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218431) said:
@pawsandclaws1 said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218341) said:
@mike said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218171) said:
1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kepaoa
3 Joey Leilua
4 Tommy Talau
5 David Nofoaluma
6 Adam Doueihi
7 Jock Madden
8 Josh Aloai
9 Jacob Liddle
10 Thomas Mikaele
11 Luciano Leilua
12 Luke Garner
13 Alex Twal
14 Shawn Blore
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Sam McIntyre
17 Moses Mbye
18 Harry Grant
19 Matt Eisenhuth
20 Josh Reynolds
21 Russell Packer

It was our forwards who were smashed against. the Panthers. What changes have you made to the forwards to. ensure this. doesn't happen again?

I’d put Musgrove in their but I don’t think he is fit. Other than that there is really not a lot to choose from.

That's the issue, Maguire has very few options available to him.
 
@Magpie1969 said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1217794) said:
McIntyre should be groomed as 2021 lock. Twal prop rotation only.

Please give AJ, Bradley and Madden 4 weeks to prove what they have

Bring Lawrence and Marshall back for last game of season only. Lap of honour.

He generates a lightning quick play the ball . Blore should be on the edge next year whichever that will be , luci on the other .
I’ve been a brooks defender , like GEO , but I’m starting to waver . I hope he refunds his form . He looks like the Taylor ball brooks out there . Which offers nothing .
 
@Geo said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1217797) said:
Time for the future..

1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kapaoa
3 Reece Hoffman
4 Tommy Talau
5 Robert Jennings

6 Moses Mbye
7 Jock Madden

8 Alex Seyfarth
9 Josh Reynolds
10 Oliver Clark
11 Sam McIntyre
12 Chris McQueen
13 Shawn Blore

14 Russell Packer
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Jake Simpkin
17 Moses Mbye or A Stick only gets a few minutes anyway

All off contract players given a run to see if they get a go..Young blokes exposed to NRL may as well to see if they are any good..if not punt them too

The big 3 in Mbye Packer and Reynolds on show to lead the side to Glory and sweeten the pot for perspective suitors..

Your a funny guy Geo. Hopefully Madge would not be that silly.
 
@Russell said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1218448) said:
@Geo said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1217797) said:
Time for the future..

1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kapaoa
3 Reece Hoffman
4 Tommy Talau
5 Robert Jennings

6 Moses Mbye
7 Jock Madden

8 Alex Seyfarth
9 Josh Reynolds
10 Oliver Clark
11 Sam McIntyre
12 Chris McQueen
13 Shawn Blore

14 Russell Packer
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Jake Simpkin
17 Moses Mbye or A Stick only gets a few minutes anyway

All off contract players given a run to see if they get a go..Young blokes exposed to NRL may as well to see if they are any good..if not punt them too

The big 3 in Mbye Packer and Reynolds on show to lead the side to Glory and sweeten the pot for perspective suitors..

Your a funny guy Geo. Hopefully Madge would not be that silly.

To quote Madge..I have a strong group training under these guys (in ref to the team trotted out v Pamfers)

So now is the time to see if they can transfer that to the paddock..

What's to lose Russ..those guys off contract will slay it..Kids will slay it if not punt them..

Only one way to find out..
 
@hobbo1 said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1217834) said:
@Telltails said in [Your team v Silvertail Scum\.\.](/post/1217831) said:
I wish they would retire the white jersey can't remember ever playing well in them let alone winning.

Agree
It’s a ? jersey as well

Not half as bad as the black one.
 
Back
Top