Your team v Silvertail Scum..

[avocadoontoast]

Time for the future..

1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kapaoa
3 Reece Hoffman
4 Tommy Talau
5 Robert Jennings

6 Moses Mbye
7 Jock Madden

8 Alex Seyfarth
9 Josh Reynolds
10 Oliver Clark
11 Sam McIntyre
12 Chris McQueen
13 Shawn Blore

14 Russell Packer
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Jake Simpkin
17 Moses Mbye or A Stick only gets a few minutes anyway

All off contract players given a run to see if they get a go..Young blokes exposed to NRL may as well to see if they are any good..if not punt them too

The big 3 in Mbye Packer and Reynolds on show to lead the side to Glory and sweeten the pot for perspective suitors..

Your a funny guy Geo. Hopefully Madge would not be that silly.

To quote Madge..I have a strong group training under these guys (in ref to the team trotted out v Pamfers)

So now is the time to see if they can transfer that to the paddock..

What's to lose Russ..those guys off contract will slay it..Kids will slay it if not punt them..

Only one way to find out..

I agree, nothing to lose. Would rather see some other players given the opportunity.

 

[Tigerbuck63]

Well like to think its a game we can WIN whoever we select, Manly going as good as us this season - Neither Top 8.
This game will most likely decide where we finish this year, rather finish closer to the 8 than the bottom 4 teams.

 

[Dyloh]

Doueihi, Madden, Brooks, Benji, Reynolds, Mbye, Walters, how many halves pairings are we gonna try and ruin before we realise that their not getting any help? Do we really think Madden is gonna be able to manage a game better than Brooks and Benji when he's still stuck in his half the majority of his games?

 

[JC99]

I don’t think the team will look that much different tbh

 

[Hangonaminute]

1. Whoever is faster than AD and can catch a ball.
2. Nofo
3. AD
4. JLO
5. Talau
6. JREY
7. Benji
8. Twal
9. Liddle (not sold on him at all)
10. ?
11. Garner (don't know what's happened to him, gone backwards)
12. Lucy
13. ?

14. Grant
15. ? Not the usual suspects, but I have no idea who
16. ?
17. ?

 

[Cairnstigers]

Time for the future..

1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kapaoa
3 Reece Hoffman
4 Tommy Talau
5 Robert Jennings

6 Moses Mbye
7 Jock Madden

8 Alex Seyfarth
9 Josh Reynolds
10 Oliver Clark
11 Sam McIntyre
12 Chris McQueen
13 Shawn Blore

14 Russell Packer
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Jake Simpkin
17 Moses Mbye or A Stick only gets a few minutes anyway

All off contract players given a run to see if they get a go..Young blokes exposed to NRL may as well to see if they are any good..if not punt them too

The big 3 in Mbye Packer and Reynolds on show to lead the side to Glory and sweeten the pot for perspective suitors..

Now we can all see how much you love Mbye
Naming him twice
Or is it because you want two chances of getting rid of him

 

[Russell]

Time for the future..

1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kapaoa
3 Reece Hoffman
4 Tommy Talau
5 Robert Jennings

6 Moses Mbye
7 Jock Madden

8 Alex Seyfarth
9 Josh Reynolds
10 Oliver Clark
11 Sam McIntyre
12 Chris McQueen
13 Shawn Blore

14 Russell Packer
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Jake Simpkin
17 Moses Mbye or A Stick only gets a few minutes anyway

All off contract players given a run to see if they get a go..Young blokes exposed to NRL may as well to see if they are any good..if not punt them too

The big 3 in Mbye Packer and Reynolds on show to lead the side to Glory and sweeten the pot for perspective suitors..

Your a funny guy Geo. Hopefully Madge would not be that silly.

To quote Madge..I have a strong group training under these guys (in ref to the team trotted out v Pamfers)

So now is the time to see if they can transfer that to the paddock..

What's to lose Russ..those guys off contract will slay it..Kids will slay it if not punt them..

Only one way to find out..

You could lose a lot Geo. That is not counting the game which would be a guaranteed.

I can imagine the uproar on here if we lose, we were lucky not to get the spoon, sack Madge, he's hopeless.

PLUS it is not fair to put some MAYBE promising youngsters into a dud team like that and expect them to
show something good. They would have no chance and so everyone would be wanting them cut.

It is absolutely ridiculous to play Simpkin at his age and with no game time all year. Cini would fail
miserably - at this stage could not tackle a decent size hamburger.

The players that are off contract, we already know what they offer - nothing. i.e. Jennings, McQueen, MCK etc.
Players that are on contract that we don't want e.g. Packer, Mbye, Reynolds etc. we already know what they offer.

TO THE FUTURE, WITH REALITY.

 

[JC99]

Time for the future..

1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kapaoa
3 Reece Hoffman
4 Tommy Talau
5 Robert Jennings

6 Moses Mbye
7 Jock Madden

8 Alex Seyfarth
9 Josh Reynolds
10 Oliver Clark
11 Sam McIntyre
12 Chris McQueen
13 Shawn Blore

14 Russell Packer
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Jake Simpkin
17 Moses Mbye or A Stick only gets a few minutes anyway

All off contract players given a run to see if they get a go..Young blokes exposed to NRL may as well to see if they are any good..if not punt them too

The big 3 in Mbye Packer and Reynolds on show to lead the side to Glory and sweeten the pot for perspective suitors..

Your a funny guy Geo. Hopefully Madge would not be that silly.

To quote Madge..I have a strong group training under these guys (in ref to the team trotted out v Pamfers)

So now is the time to see if they can transfer that to the paddock..

What's to lose Russ..those guys off contract will slay it..Kids will slay it if not punt them..

Only one way to find out..

You could lose a lot Geo. That is not counting the game which would be a guaranteed l.

I can imagine the uproar on here if we lose, we were lucky not t o get the spoon, sack Madge, he's hopeless.

PLUS it is not fair to put some MAYBE promising youngsters into a dud team like that and expect them to
show something good. They would have no chance and so everyone would be wanting them cut.

It is absolutely ridiculous to play Simpkin at his age and with no game time all year. Cini would fail
miserably - at this stage could not tackle a decent size hamburger.

The players that are off contract, we already know what they offer - nothing. i.e. Jennings, McQueen, MCK etc.
Players that are on contract that we don't want e.g. Packer, Mbye, Reynolds etc. we already know what they offer.

TO THE FUTURE, WITH REALITY.

I agree we can’t expect a team full of kids. Their might be some minor changes with some younger guys getting limited minutes but I don’t see Madge throwing a heap of guys all into the deep end at once. Guess we will have to wait and see though

 

[bythebeardofzeus]

1. AD
2. Nofo
3. BJ
4. Talau
5. AJ
6. Mbye
7. Brooks
8. Aloiai
9. Grant
10. Twal
11. LL
12. Garner
13. McIntyre

14. Mikaele
15. Musgrove (if unfit then the Huth)
16. Blore
17. Liddle

 

[Russell]

1. AD
2. Nofo
3. BJ
4. Talau
5. AJ
6. Mbye
7. Brooks
8. Aloiai
9. Grant
10. Twal
11. LL
12. Garner
13. McIntyre

14. Mikaele
15. Musgrove (if unfit then the Huth)
16. Blore
17. Liddle

That would be pretty close to my team as well Chief.

 

[JC99]

I would start Liddle and give him a good 60 mins. Grant is a fabulous player but we need to keep improving Liddle as he’s our 9 for next season

 

[hobbo1]

I wish they would retire the white jersey can't remember ever playing well in them let alone winning.

Agree
It’s a ? jersey as well

Not half as bad as the black one.

I like the black
Need an orange strip as well

 

[TheDaBoss]

im predicting not to much change

maybe 1 debut

 

[HowDugWT]

Dylan Smith is off-contract at the end of this season. How do we know what to think. I've seen him in intrust he looks exciting and almost looks like marshall in his prime. When he gets the ball anything can happen. idk we gotta give him a go. HAVE TO

 

[hobbo1]

im predicting not to much change

maybe 1 debut

I look forward to 4pm Tuesday more than game day ...
It’s always a crack up to see which nuffie/ plodder combos have been selected

 

[Guest]

Dylan Smith is off-contract at the end of this season. How do we know what to think. I've seen him in intrust he looks exciting and almost looks like marshall in his prime. When he gets the ball anything can happen. idk we gotta give him a go. HAVE TO

I must be watching a different player because every time I''ve seen Smith play he hasn't looked FG standard at all.

 

[Geo]

Time for the future..

1 Dylan Smith
2 Asu Kapaoa
3 Reece Hoffman
4 Tommy Talau
5 Robert Jennings

6 Moses Mbye
7 Jock Madden

8 Alex Seyfarth
9 Josh Reynolds
10 Oliver Clark
11 Sam McIntyre
12 Chris McQueen
13 Shawn Blore

14 Russell Packer
15 Matt Eisenhuth
16 Jake Simpkin
17 Moses Mbye or A Stick only gets a few minutes anyway

All off contract players given a run to see if they get a go..Young blokes exposed to NRL may as well to see if they are any good..if not punt them too

The big 3 in Mbye Packer and Reynolds on show to lead the side to Glory and sweeten the pot for perspective suitors..

Now we can all see how much you love Mbye
Naming him twice
Or is it because you want two chances of getting rid of him

Read the whole thread..acknowledged I had 2 Mbye's so replaced the bench Mbye with A Stick..then A Stick with Chee-Kam..

 

[mike]

I would start Liddle and give him a good 60 mins. Grant is a fabulous player but we need to keep improving Liddle as he’s our 9 for next season

Unless there is a chance of keeping Grant, which I don’t believe there is, Grant should not play again this season. Great player but not in our future and the fact we are no chance to make the finals now he is no longer of use.

 

[Geo]

Why are we also playing players that are carrying injury by reports needed surgery..why put that off till season end..which would then leave players in rehab when pre season for 2021 commences..

 

[avocadoontoast]

I wish they would retire the white jersey can't remember ever playing well in them let alone winning.

Agree
It’s a ? jersey as well

Not half as bad as the black one.

I like the black
Need an orange strip as well

One mainly black strip and one mainly orange strip would be ideal i reckon. The white one is a shocker.

Who knows, we have a new jersey supplier apparently next year, might have things shaken up a bit.