Your top 17, Season 2016

@GNR4LIFE said:
@cktiger said:
@GNR4LIFE said:
@swag tiger said:
If he was going to play reserve grade i do not think he would have signed with us and it is also a waste of experience.

Exactly

He would have been told Farah would be gone - he might not have signed to play reserves but that's where he'll likely end up.

No he won't

One of the selectors GNR or just hoping?
He would have been in reserves at Manly - can't see him getting too much game time if they really want to bring Cherrington forward.
Farah should be first choice hooker and we've got a ton of backrowers - including the need to fit in Halatau somewhere.
 
@cktiger said:
One of the selectors GNR or just hoping?
He would have been in reserves at Manly - can't see him getting too much game time if they really want to bring Cherrington forward.
Farah should be first choice hooker and we've got a ton of backrowers - including the need to fit in Halatau somewhere.

We also have a hooker whose played over 200 games and who for many yrs has only missed out on Origin due to the fact he's had the best hooker of the modern era ahead of him. I'd say he warrants consideration too.
 
My guess for ROUND 1

1\. Tedesco
2\. Nofoaluma
3\. Simona
4\. Naiqama
5\. Addo-Carr - or maybe Peni?
6\. Moses
7\. Brooks (do we know if there for round 1? - if not, Rankin or Drinky
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10\. Sue
11\. Sironen
12\. Lawrence
13\. Edwards

14\. Seumanufagai
15\. Grant
16\. Halatau
17\. Cherrington - until Ballin returns.
 
@shakey4d said:
My guess for ROUND 1

1\. Tedesco
2\. Nofoaluma
3\. Simona
4\. Naiqama
5\. Addo-Carr - or maybe Peni?
6\. Moses
7\. Brooks (do we know if there for round 1? - if not, Rankin or Drinky
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10\. Sue
11\. Sironen
12\. Lawrence
13\. Edwards

14\. Seumanufagai
15\. Grant
16\. Halatau
17\. Cherrington - until Ballin returns.

I'd say that's pretty close to being the run on side. The only questions would be over Edwards at lock. JT might go with Sue at lock. Grant starting and Edwards on the bench.
As for the bench, JT might select Chee Kam to cover 2nd row and centre. Although Halatau can cover 2nd row and Lawerence centre (on your side). I like Cherrington coming on late when the defence is tried.
 
@GNR4LIFE said:
@cktiger said:
One of the selectors GNR or just hoping?
He would have been in reserves at Manly - can't see him getting too much game time if they really want to bring Cherrington forward.
Farah should be first choice hooker and we've got a ton of backrowers - including the need to fit in Halatau somewhere.

We also have a hooker whose played over 200 games and who for many yrs has only missed out on Origin due to the fact he's had the best hooker of the modern era ahead of him. I'd say he warrants consideration too.

Where's all the love for Ballin coming from - or is it you have it in for Farah?
Ballin was lucky to play 1 game for QLD - 6 years ago.
Even if Cameron Smith had retired the last few years he wouldn't have got close to getting picked.
I'm not saying he isn't a decent player, and is most probably a nice guy.
On the other hand, the simple fact is he's not as good as Farah.
Are you also prepared to risk losing our next long term hooker in Cherrington by having Ballin taking up his minutes?
 
@cktiger said:
@GNR4LIFE said:
@cktiger said:
One of the selectors GNR or just hoping?
He would have been in reserves at Manly - can't see him getting too much game time if they really want to bring Cherrington forward.
Farah should be first choice hooker and we've got a ton of backrowers - including the need to fit in Halatau somewhere.

We also have a hooker whose played over 200 games and who for many yrs has only missed out on Origin due to the fact he's had the best hooker of the modern era ahead of him. I'd say he warrants consideration too.

Where's all the love for Ballin coming from - or is it you have it in for Farah?
Ballin was lucky to play 1 game for QLD - 6 years ago.
Even if Cameron Smith had retired the last few years he wouldn't have got close to getting picked.
I'm not saying he isn't a decent player, and is most probably a nice guy.
On the other hand, the simple fact is he's not as good as Farah.
Are you also prepared to risk losing our next long term hooker in Cherrington by having Ballin taking up his minutes?

That question is so interchangeable. Why are you so against him, and trying to devalue his career to this point, because he's a threat to Farah's position?

As for Cherrington, i'm sure another yr to develop won't do him any harm, by which time i believe an agreement will be made for Farah to go to the SL in 2017, which will make Ballin and Cherry the rotation in 2017, leaving Cherrington with the reigns in 2018.
 
If Cherrington is still getting paid a first grade salary and knows he'll be the starting hooker in 2 years, then that's a great position to be in. We don't know, he might appreciate not being thrown into the deep-end too young, taking the time to work on his game whilst getting a few games here and there. It's been tough for Mitch and Luke getting part punished by the media after being thrown into 1sts at a young age, cherry won't have to deal with that.

Sounds like a good place for him to be to be honest.
 
@GNR4LIFE said:
@cktiger said:
@GNR4LIFE said:
@cktiger said:
One of the selectors GNR or just hoping?
He would have been in reserves at Manly - can't see him getting too much game time if they really want to bring Cherrington forward.
Farah should be first choice hooker and we've got a ton of backrowers - including the need to fit in Halatau somewhere.

We also have a hooker whose played over 200 games and who for many yrs has only missed out on Origin due to the fact he's had the best hooker of the modern era ahead of him. I'd say he warrants consideration too.

Where's all the love for Ballin coming from - or is it you have it in for Farah?
Ballin was lucky to play 1 game for QLD - 6 years ago.
Even if Cameron Smith had retired the last few years he wouldn't have got close to getting picked.
I'm not saying he isn't a decent player, and is most probably a nice guy.
On the other hand, the simple fact is he's not as good as Farah.
Are you also prepared to risk losing our next long term hooker in Cherrington by having Ballin taking up his minutes?

That question is so interchangeable. **Why are you so against him, and trying to devalue his career to this point,** because he's a threat to Farah's position?

As for Cherrington, i'm sure another yr to develop won't do him any harm, by which time i believe an agreement will be made for Farah to go to the SL in 2017, which will make Ballin and Cherry the rotation in 2017, leaving Cherrington with the reigns in 2018.

I can't see where I ever did that - just a figment of your imagination.
 
@Tiger Watto said:
Ballin is better than Farah because he is a Queenslander… We only play Finals when there is Queenslanders in the team

Good one Watto - isn't the Queenslander of the year a ladyboy? :laughing:
 
@cktiger said:
@Tiger Watto said:
Ballin is better than Farah because he is a Queenslander… We only play Finals when there is Queenslanders in the team

Good one Watto - isn't the Queenslander of the year a ladyboy? :laughing:

Funny because its true

10"/11" Robert Lui and Lote Tuqiri?

05" Scott Prince

Every season we had a qlder halfback we made the finals, correct me if i am wrong
 
I thought ck was smarter than that, and was waiting for the responce "because Farah was feeding them you idiot", but he cracks a ladyboy joke.

You do realise ck that Sydney is the lady boy/mardi gras capital of the world?

The NSW Blues Float will be out in force in a few weeks leading your march!!!
 
@Tiger Watto said:
I thought ck was smarter than that, and was waiting for the responce "because Farah was feeding them you idiot", but he cracks a ladyboy joke.

You do realise ck that Sydney is the lady boy/mardi gras capital of the world?

The NSW Blues Float will be out in force in a few weeks leading your march!!!

You seem to be upto date with the lady boy statistics !
You're a worry Mr Watson
:roll
 
@hobbo2803 said:
@Tiger Watto said:
I thought ck was smarter than that, and was waiting for the responce "because Farah was feeding them you idiot", but he cracks a ladyboy joke.

You do realise ck that Sydney is the lady boy/mardi gras capital of the world?

The NSW Blues Float will be out in force in a few weeks leading your march!!!

You seem to be upto date with the lady boy statistics !
You're a worry Mr Watson
:roll

Don't worry Hobbo , he just thinks that Robbie looks good in drag

Pity about the monobrow though , hey Watto :wink:
 
@happy tiger said:
@hobbo2803 said:
@Tiger Watto said:
I thought ck was smarter than that, and was waiting for the responce "because Farah was feeding them you idiot", but he cracks a ladyboy joke.

You do realise ck that Sydney is the lady boy/mardi gras capital of the world?

The NSW Blues Float will be out in force in a few weeks leading your march!!!

You seem to be upto date with the lady boy statistics !
You're a worry Mr Watson
:roll

Don't worry Hobbo , he just thinks that Robbie looks good in drag

Pity about the monobrow though , hey Watto :wink:

Say what you will but you can't deny it.
Gives a whole new meaning to the term 'bananabender' :laughing:
 
@Tiger Watto said:
I thought ck was smarter than that, and was waiting for the responce "because Farah was feeding them you idiot", but he cracks a ladyboy joke.

You do realise ck that Sydney is the lady boy/mardi gras capital of the world?

The NSW Blues Float will be out in force in a few weeks leading your march!!!

:unamused: Will this off-season never end…of course we are.. :smiley:

As for the hooker situation isn't it great that we are in a much stronger position than most other Clubs in terms of quality guys to choose from...all 3 with play a significant role this season...
 
Personally I'd like to see Cherrington on the bench as an impact players. It worked so well for Crunulla last year with Barba coming on late. They would be even or behind at half time, then bring on Barba with about 20 mins to go and win games. It happened week after week.
This year , with the reduced inter change , I can see someone in the Cherrington mould having real impact late in the game.
 
@Byron Bay Fan said:
Was it Blocker who did drag on the Footie Show? Will he be on the Blues Mardi Gay float?

They have not made a decision yet.

It is either Blocker on the float by himself or leave him off and have room for 25 others.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top