Brooks Article SMH

Status
Not open for further replies.
stryker 69 said:
Mate, that is a terrible sentence. Try again please.
Click to expand...

sparci said:
he really isnt though is he? What he said was 100% true. You think luke brooks would be a top4 halfback had he switched to a side like melbourne. Please give me a break, he'd do no better than someone like brody croft. There is literally no evidence to suggest otherwise. All those players mentioned earlier we didn't want to lose, they end up doing better elsewhere because they actually had the ability to do so. In watching brooks all these years, you can't put him in the same bracket.
Click to expand...
Moses and tedesco went to better teams
Woods a worse team and look at him no success
Brooks in a Melbourne Roosters or souths team would kill it. Souths could use him now Ilias is garbage and as good as body croft who is crap in ESL
 
. This was the time for him to step up and push them back into their box. Keep them down their end, maybe turn the tide with a 40/20, target their tired players in an almost bullying fashion…alas this is the stuff he doesn’t do and hence his polarising status within the club. - Stryker 69.

Please elaborate? I’m always ready to learn something new.
 
Jedi_Tiger said:
Moses and tedesco went to better teams
Woods a worse team and look at him no success
Brooks in a Melbourne Roosters or souths team would kill it. Souths could use him now Ilias is garbage and as good as body croft who is crap in ESL
Click to expand...
Brooks wouldn’t last 5 games in a roosters or storm jersey … they’d punt him !
 
Jedi_Tiger said:
Moses and tedesco went to better teams
Woods a worse team and look at him no success
Brooks in a Melbourne Roosters or souths team would kill it. Souths could use him now Ilias is garbage and as good as body croft who is crap in ESL
Click to expand...
Melbourne are known for making nuffies look like superstars...

Roosters, much the same.

I believe both clubs coaches wouldn't even bother with Brooks...
 
sparci said:
The response those players got upon leaving this club tells a different story. Consider the general response kelma is getting with respect to reports he's signed elsewhere, Brooks wouldn't get the same reception and there is a very definitive reason why.
Click to expand...
How people react isn’t the point. It’s irrelevant. It doesn’t mean he couldn’t excel at another club.
 
hobbo1 said:
173 games not long enough ?
Click to expand...
It seems long enough when you say it like that, but it depends on other factors which are relative to the success of any player. Brooks has had his growth stunted by playing with a club that is poorly administered (probably due to lack of cash flow) and poorly resourced. Had he been playing with Chooks or Storm during the last 8 years his confidence would have reached a peak.
Instead he is with WT whose fans tell him how terrible he is every day.
Think about it?
I’m not saying he is negatively affected by Pygmalion, but it is not helpful.
 
twentyforty said:
It seems long enough when you say it like that, but it depends on other factors which are relative to the success of any player. Brooks has had his growth stunted by playing with a club that is poorly administered (probably due to lack of cash flow) and poorly resourced. Had he been playing with Chooks or Storm during the last 8 years his confidence would have reached a peak.
Instead he is with WT whose fans tell him how terrible he is every day.
Think about it?
I’m not saying he is negatively affected by Pygmalion, but it is not helpful.
Click to expand...
The old chicken and the egg...

Which sucked first?
The club or Brooks...
😂🙄

Brooks going to carve up tomorrow against a weak spine knights, his future club.
 
Demps said:
The old chicken and the egg...

Which sucked first?
The club or Brooks...
😂🙄

Brooks going to carve up tomorrow against a weak spine knights, his future club.
Click to expand...
We were missing finals before he even debuted, so there’s your answer.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
It doesn’t even have to be a Melbourne or a Roosters. He could excel at the Broncos. Look at Walters last week, different player.
Click to expand...
Broncos are an interesting one.

Keen to see how they go tomorrow.

A few tweaks to their roster and they have improved massively, albeit early days.

That being said... Brodie Croft struggled at Broncos.
 
Demps said:
Broncos are an interesting one.

Keen to see how they go tomorrow.

A few tweaks to their roster and they have improved massively, albeit early days.

That being said... Brodie Croft struggled at Broncos.
Click to expand...
Brooks is a better player than Croft.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 516 (members: 25, guests: 491)
Back
Top