Luke Brooks - Mega Thread

Demps said:
I don't even know why it's a debate any more.

The guys so incredibly average and we'll never make the finals with him in the team.

Has a casual worker attitude and a below standard skill set.

The club needs to bite the bullet and allow his exit.
Click to expand...
Just him eh..
 
mike said:
Nah, I’d play Brooks at lock when AD comes back. Jacko and AD are the best halves we have.
Click to expand...
And thats only your qualified opinion,Brooks is doing well alongside Jacko...AD has to come back fit and prove he can out play Brooks...atm I dont think AD is anything more than a fill in...these other guys are doing the work and laying a platform..AD is the forum favourite who did well in a team that was a bottom 4/5 contender....lets see if he can man up and prove he should be the so called KING everyone is wetting their pants over...
Being out for a long time and having to adapt to new structures and new players puts pressure on a bloke who is sitting on the sidelines bascking in fan favourite glory...once he gets out there and proves himself for 80 mins ,then maybe I will change my mind..
Hastings/Brooks are building a great combo ..as the great Greg Hawick who coached me once said""I want you in the side but I dont want to split a winning combination that is just getting used to each other and the way I want them to play""..
As much as I appreciate AD ,,,he has to earn the right to be in the top side...this is the mistake the WTs have made over many years ,,,NEPOTISM and fan favourites with out the hard busted games to prove their worth...This year it starts ...prove yourself or go to NSW cup and earn your selection....
I know I will get flogged by many,but I dont care,its about time things went back to earning your way instead of being spoon fed for your pay...sorry just my rant for the week...
 
TrueTiger said:
I think the guys have run out of excuses to bag the bloke...Im the first to admit he still has some faults as do all the top NRL players,but his game is now starting to reach another level higher with the switch to 5/8 and having a genuine 7 to play alongside..
Click to expand...
Imagine if we got Finucane. Sharks could probably win with 9 players , quality players is the difference
 
TrueTiger said:
I think the guys have run out of excuses to bag the bloke...Im the first to admit he still has some faults as do all the top NRL players,but his game is now starting to reach another level higher with the switch to 5/8 and having a genuine 7 to play alongside..
Click to expand...
Hastings the Messiah🙏

All Bwooks needed was someone to come in and do his job for him. The job he's been excessively paid to do for quite some time.

Also, I'd say his contract needs major restructuring. He's being paid way above his worth, and should bite the bullet on a personal level to help out the rest of the squad.

If he won't take a pay cut, then PUNT HIM...
 
Demps said:
He's the main source of mediocrity.

Others that contribute such as Mikaele and reportably on the way out.

He should join them.
Click to expand...
Not having a go at you because you are entitled to your opinion but tell me what other player has copped all this criticism and still turned up every week and done his best which unfortunately in the eyes of many is not good enough. Does this mean that all the people who bag him were the best of the best at what they did for work. If not how do they justify bagging someone else who is just like them.
 
Kiama Tiger Tragic said:
Just guessing but did Brooks steal your car or something similar because that’s a lot of hate for someone who has polled well in our 3 2 1 votes for the last month. Is there anyone else you hate more who isn’t doing so well?
Click to expand...

Constantly calling for Luke Brooks head is about the only way the
"Golden Boy" will get the 6 jersey back from him.

AD has played 14/40 Games for us at 6. (Just over 1/3)
Won 5 games at 6 last year...
Won 3 games in the centres last year.
Fair chance most of the love for him - Is from his performances in positions outside the halves.
From 14 games, He's apparently streets ahead of anyone else??

Kid can play, But he's coming off an ACL and people want him back in a jersey he's barely played any NRL in..... (14 Games in 4.5 years)
Good Luck with that!!
 
Demps said:
He's the main source of mediocrity.

Others that contribute such as Mikaele and reportably on the way out.

He should join them.
Click to expand...

Love you Bro, But that's just not true....
He's about the only one that looks likely in forever.
Our forwards, Second Rowers and Centres (The position we fail to acknowledge to even exist)
Have had nothing for years...

Yeah - It might be seen to be his job to put a boot in their arse,
- There's only so long you can bark at sticks.
I remember him giving Adam Blair a spray at LO as an 18-19 year old...

He's playing well atm, As good if not better than any 5/8 we've had in the last 10 years....
Happy to roll with it.

AD will get a spot somewhere... Could really do a job at centre,
Even with the ball heading out to Peachey on the weekend looked likely at times on the WE.
 
batboy said:
Love you Bro, But that's just not true....
He's about the only one that looks likely in forever.
Our forwards, Second Rowers and Centres (The position we fail to acknowledge to even exist)
Have had nothing for years...

Yeah - It might be seen to be his job to put a boot in their arse,
- There's only so long you can bark at sticks.
I remember him giving Adam Blair a spray at LO as an 18-19 year old...

He's playing well atm, As good if not better than any 5/8 we've had in the last 10 years....
Happy to roll with it.

AD will get a spot somewhere... Could really do a job at centre,
Even with the ball heading out to Peachey on the weekend looked likely at times on the WE.
Click to expand...
 
batboy said:
Constantly calling for Luke Brooks head is about the only way the
"Golden Boy" will get the 6 jersey back from him.

AD has played 14/40 Games for us at 6. (Just over 1/3)
Won 5 games at 6 last year...
Won 3 games in the centres last year.
Fair chance most of the love for him - Is from his performances in positions outside the halves.
From 14 games, He's apparently streets ahead of anyone else??

Kid can play, But he's coming off an ACL and people want him back in a jersey he's barely played any NRL in..... (14 Games in 4.5 years)
Good Luck with that!!
Click to expand...
If AD wasnt a LEBANESE product he wouldnt get the backing he is getting,hence the Demps love for him...I really like the guy but Madge is trying to build a winning culture and players to play for 80 mins,it is showing results even with a makeshift team for weeks...
AD has to prove he can out play anyone in the NRL squad atm...otherwise we go back to picking fan and admin favourites,Madge is on the right track...AD has it all to do,these other blokes have spilt blood and got beat just to prove they have heart...AD has to prove he has heart or he is another also ran...
As my Dad used to say if you did your very best win lose or draw your mum and I will be proud of you..also a fair days pay for a fair days work...
 
hobbo1 said:
He still sucks ..
one field goal and the Brooks cult comes out from under there rocks
Punt him 🥾
Click to expand...
Have you been inhaling fumes again mate while painting...I told you before make sure there is plenty of ventilation before opening the paint cans...

Obviously you didnt listen...:mad:🙋‍♂️
 
TrueTiger said:
Have you been inhaling fumes again mate while painting...I told you before make sure there is plenty of ventilation before opening the paint cans...

Obviously you didnt listen...:mad:🙋‍♂️
Click to expand...
Not even funny …
Still waiting on your covid and Ukraine conspiracy theories to come to fruition lmao 🤣 … mushroom much !

Brooks is shit
Was average against Parra
Got lucky against south’s
Was shit house against Saints
Was diabolical against Manly
Manly stats
13 runs
86 meters
15 tackles
8 missed tackles
It really is mind blowing that people are so supportive of 1 player who’s continually been crap for a decade …lmao !
 
hobbo1 said:
Not even funny …
Still waiting on your covid and Ukraine conspiracy theories to come to fruition lmao 🤣 … mushroom much !

Brooks is shit
Was average against Parra
Got lucky against south’s
Was shit house against Saints
Was diabolical against Manly
Manly stats
13 runs
86 meters
15 tackles
8 missed tackles
It really is mind blowing that people are so supportive of 1 player who’s continually been crap for a decade …lmao !
Click to expand...
Lost your humour mate...the conspiracy theories will appear very soon...but your hate toward a bloke that still turns up and has a go even though he has covered for others mistakes is overwhelming ...Question for you..dont you think this team has been performing better with Hastings at 1/2 back and Brooks at 5/8...maybe the guys that favoured Benji,Farah,Mbye and others were playing Brooks out of position just so they could say its his team and not use him where he should have been ???

Put it this way ..why try and play an out and out prop in the centres just to appease the few who said it should work...??
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 682 (members: 42, guests: 640)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top