Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[851]

let me know when Madden gets halfback of the year

I don't rate Madden, but Brooks has had 9 seasons and delivered diddly squat, I think we should move both on

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

I don't rate Madden, but Brooks has had 9 seasons and delivered diddly squat, I think we should move both on

with a proper coach like Sheens let's see
move him on in 2024 but not 2023

 

[The SHADOW]

with a proper coach like Sheens let's see
move him on in 2024 but not 2023

Nah now

 

[Needaname]

"The Daily Telegraph can reveal the Panthers have begun talks with Madden and are hoping to lure him to Penrith as Sean O’Sullivan’s replacement."

Madden would be crazy not to jump at the opportunity imo

I agree. He will pretty much be in exactly the same position at both clubs. If all signs are pointing to Sheens preferring to stick with Doueihi and Brooks as preferred halves.
Why not be an understudy to another set of halves in a team that is very well built and coordinated.
Actually he probably plays more first grade going there as the trend Ivan has developed is to not rush back his origin players. Either Nathan or Leuli will miss about 5 games at least each year.

 

[The SHADOW]

If past trends continue at the Pawwawakker Seals they’ll be our BIT@hs for at least 6.5 years , just short of the seven years bad luck.

 

[The SHADOW]

keep saying it halfback of the year 2018
Madden will never be halfback of the year
Get rid of Brooks by all means but Jock Madden is not the answer

I looked heaps good in 2018 as well.🥰

 

[Curaeus]

I don't think he is coming back.

thinking exactly the same thing

 

[hsvjones]

HASTINGS $800k

And worth it too .. He is our on field coach and runs the ship..

 

[Tim Sheens]

A lot of people are getting too carried away with what the jersey means.

6 and 7 are jerseys. They don't mean "halfback" or "five-eighth" anymore. For many teams its left half and right half. If Hastings is in the 13, he's our first receiver and for all intents and purposes, our halfback. Just defends in the middle. Then our 6 & 7 would play as two second-receivers/"five-eighths".

If you put Tamou in the number 2 jersey and played him up the middle all game, would he be a winger? No.

I don't quite agree, particularly with the Hastings role. Well, at least after his initial week in the middle, when he did still try to play the halfback role too much.

For mine it worked much better in the following weeks when Hastings himself stated that he moved further into the true ball playing lock role, with Brooks the halfback before injury and then Madden, before the hip drop also put Jackson out for the year.

Reckon that this role, the one he was originally signed for is important in the current game, so a replacement needs to be found if Hastings doesn't want to stay.

 

[Tim Sheens]

Brooks has a long service discount so offer 700k it is 500k on your cap

Apart from him and Nofoaluma, does any other of our players qualify for the cap allowance next season?

Has to be a major consideration in who comes and goes when considering player values, as an extra $200k not included in the basic cap is not to be sneezed at.

 

[supercoach]

There were plenty who said Burton and Hynes would struggle outside their current clubs, I was not one of them, I was all in on both

Mate you have two types of players who come out of good systems. You have the creative type and you have the players who gained their reputation feeding off the creative players.
The creative ones can transfer their skills anywhere but the other ones can struggle at new clubs.

Burton and Hynes were definitely in the first category

 

[Cobarcats]

Apart from him and Nofoaluma, does any other of our players qualify for the cap allowance next season?

Has to be a major consideration in who comes and goes when considering player values, as an extra $200k not included in the basic cap is not to be sneezed at.

Ronnie Palmer, his services must be free by now. That energy dust of his isn't cheap you know.

 

[The SHADOW]

Ronnie Palmer, his services must be free by now. That energy dust of his isn't cheap you know.

I love him, ala Laurie Nichols .

 

[Stevec]

If Brooks plays for us in 2023 we have to pay him $1.1 mill we can't tell him here is 700 k take it or leave it .We are legally bound to pay amount in his contract . What we could try and do is extend his contract to end 2025 and offer say 2.3 mill or so .He would have to agree to it . IMO after 9 years he's not worth it and we lose Madden who might turn out to be a star .With Madden we have an extra $1mill +++ to try and attract a top class center .We need someone like a Ramien or a Staggs desperately

 

[Rusty]

T

Liam martin?

Wils

I don't rate Madden, but Brooks has had 9 seasons and delivered diddly squat, I think we should move both on

Agree Thinking ouside the box and a realistic chance Drew Hutchinson or Bryce Cartwright to accompany Doueihi
They would be a reasonable price, both ball players "eyes up" both have 50 plus games, bigger bodies and drew can kick as well.
Tim/ Benji projects!!

 

[sleeve]

There were plenty who said Burton and Hynes would struggle outside their current clubs, I was not one of them, I was all in on both

So was i. also tipped Hynes for NSW side at the start of the year,-just missed out.

 

[Hmm]

When did this happen?

This morning his player agent said quit the rumours he will be at tigers and commit to his deal and fox league posted it and had to eat their words

 

[momo_amp_medo]

Mitch Moses to remain at Pawwawakkas comewank stadium.
N Brown has become Pawwawakka proof, staying put.
ARTHUR & MARTHA to Stains.
Give it 4 weeks, World Cup year, get it done.
Get your Dennis back, the real King of pawwa

Are you on drugs mate.
Seriously you need help.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Apart from him and Nofoaluma, does any other of our players qualify for the cap allowance next season?

Has to be a major consideration in who comes and goes when considering player values, as an extra $200k not included in the basic cap is not to be sneezed at.

it is just nofo and Brooks that's it

 

[Rusty]

The 188k is per player or collective?