Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[tigerap]

Dylan Napa released for contract OS. Would he be a good cheap back up

The days of looking at discards are over

 

[WT46]

People happy to see Hastings go and wanna get Flanagan now.. jesus help please. Stop accepting mediocrity

 

[jadtiger]

Dylan Napa released for contract OS. Would he be a good cheap back up

Terrible signing

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Are you seriously suggesting we go into negotiations for Moses and finish up with Flanagan? 😲

Not really. Just saying what are our options should we miss out on MM

Kyle does remind me of Brooks though, ability but confidence driven player.
He was looking good till the Roosters shafted him and he hasn’t been the same since.
Form is temporary only, just remember that.

 

[GCfan]

The days of looking at discards are over

I can see him ending up at the Knights to replace Klem

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Not really. Just saying what are our options should we miss out on MM

Kyle does remind me of Brooks though, ability but confidence driven player.
He was looking good till the Roosters shafted him and he hasn’t been the same since.
Form is temporary only, just remember that.

At least brooks was the next Andrew Johns in the lower grades

 

[Cobarcats]

N

Not really. Just saying what are our options should we miss out on MM

Kyle does remind me of Brooks though, ability but confidence driven player.
He was looking good till the Roosters shafted him and he hasn’t been the same since.
Form is temporary only, just remember that.

Not for me.

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

N

Not for me.

Never thought I’d be advocating for him but being realistic, his numbers are not bad actually

 

[jirskyr]

Our plan B should be asking Gus who else he wants to target and staying away from those so we don’t publicly humiliate ourselves anymore.

Tigers haven't made any public comment about Moses or anyone else this off-season.

 

[Bones]

Just seems to be history repeating with the delay and back and forth from him and his uncle. If he really wanted to come would constantly topping the offer up make any diffrence, he either wants to be a Tiger or doesn't. Even if he does come across, he is the biggest diva in the game.

He’s been off contract/free to negotiate for 6 weeks, and most of that time he’s been on holidays. It’s hardly been a drawn out back and forth.

 

[Camel2281]

Who will be the half back in reserve grade in 23 do we have someone ?

We currently don't have a first grade halfback either

 

[Magpie_Magic]

Gee,

For a while there with all the signing hopes I was dreaming semis next year.

Been to quiet so I hope things haven't fell through.

 

[weststigers]

sorry folks,i don t speak often,but i run off at the mouth when i do ,ex WT player Ben Jeffries,Cowboys (Girls) coach is talking up poaching ESL players from the Ladies league over there,he was the coach of the PNG Womans side,,Roosters womans coach was also there (john Strange}looking to trade players,?,

What does this have to do with NRL or Wests Tigers?

Is there an NRLW thread this can go into?

 

[weststigers]

Who will be the half back in reserve grade in 23 do we have someone ?

The Fresh Prince 🤴🏽

 

[Tim Sheens]

Never thought I’d be advocating for him but being realistic, his numbers are not bad actually

WT are in need of a backup in the halves, and could do a lot worse than Kyle for that role. As always, the outlay in dollars is important.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Dylan Napa released for contract OS. Would he be a good cheap back up

Big no!!!

 

[WT46]

Gus did say that the leading up to Christmas should be exciting for the bulldogs fans.. so they got him?

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Wow.

MM to then Flanno - geez talk about getting a clubs rejects whilst they beat us to the primary target.

Flanno game style isn't suited to Sheens/Benji style. He is basically a Hastings model but smaller & takes the line on alot less. He isn't an attacking minded half.

- Flanno isn't a setup/controller, he needs structure setup for him to then benefit from things.
- He isn't a runner of the ball. He isn't an organiser and is more of a link man which in Sheens mould doesn't work, Sheens wants his halves to take the line on & play what's infront of them.
- If we look at basic stats over 60+ games he is a 35% try assist & 30% Line Drop merchant per game which is less than Brooks by a gap and he touches the ball more than Brooks per game. His effectiveness rating in an attacking style isn't high.
- His upside is in defence where he has 50% less misses than Brooks despite his attempts being similar over last 3yrs.

Honestly if we are looking at Flanno it should only be as a backup low cost option which I couldn't see happening. We would be better off keeping Brooks/AD as our halves options.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

We currently don't have a first grade halfback either

Camel you were backing Hastings and he was the Knights' Plan B - 7. Brooks was the Knights' Plan A - 7.

 

[hugh1954]

No to players like Napa, Brown I personally would look to Taupau if we are going after any big men with experience if the price is right