Luke Brooks #167

He was fantastic. So far this season he is performing well. He has had 2 periods of ineptitude all season. They were bad moments but he has been good and today he was one of our best.

He was a key component of 3 out of 4 tries we scored and the other try was the one To'a picked up and ran the length of the field.
 
Earl said:
He was fantastic. So far this season he is performing well.

He was a key component of 3 out of 4 tries we scored
Click to expand...
This comment is hilarious.

His involvements for 2 of those tries were literally managing to pass it to his outside men on their chest, rather than 0.5m behind them like he has done several times in most games this year. The outside men then did most of the work, i.e. Tupou, AJ, Staines. For the other try you could say he had the 'vision' to throw a long ball out to AD on the right (bit of a stretch since most peoples instinct would be to shift right when a massive linebreak occurs on the left with retracting defense), again most of the work done by Batemen.

Things that most halves in this competition are expected to do. Credit to him for managing to do that, but he was hardly fantastic, the over the top praise is more reflective of the contrast between him putting in a stock standard halves performance compared to the shambles he's been for the first five rounds. Quite easily his worst season in a tigers jersey so far, crazy if you think otherwise.
 
Earl said:
He was fantastic. So far this season he is performing well. He has had 2 periods of ineptitude all season. They were bad moments but he has been good and today he was one of our best.

He was a key component of 3 out of 4 tries we scored and the other try was the one To'a picked up and ran the length of the field.
Click to expand...
If you think he was fantastic then what superlatives do you use to describe the performance of his opposite number? 🤣🤣🤣
 
Robbie's Love Child said:
Brooks was good yesterday, kicking game was good and defense as always was strong. His confidence is growing and he threw some good passes and threatened several times to break the line. I thought Jake Arthur looked strong in the KOE game yesterday and would be a good foil for Brooks, good kicking game, strong and can control.
Click to expand...

He is a lock into our halves and a key member of our spine. I'm so glad Sheens is coaching the team rather than the some of the peeps on this forum who can't recognize when someone is playing well.

He wasn't just good though. He was really really really good.

We need to get him a decent halves partner. I'd love us to get Jake Arthur.
 
Earl said:
He was fantastic. So far this season he is performing well. He has had 2 periods of ineptitude all season. They were bad moments but he has been good and today he was one of our best.

He was a key component of 3 out of 4 tries we scored and the other try was the one To'a picked up and ran the length of the field.
Click to expand...

What an utterly insane and delusional take but then again, your opinions are about as consistent as Brooks performances. Key component? LOL

Performing well? Neither his performances is or his stats in the oppositions half throughout this season support that and neither does our 0-6 start. Our forwards have been laying the platform for the most part and he continued to do what he has done for most of his career which is fold under pressure and take the wrong option.
 
Last edited:
Earl said:
He is a lock into our halves and a key member of our spine. I'm so glad Sheens is coaching the team rather than the some of the peeps on this forum who can't recognize when someone is playing well.

He wasn't just good though. He was really really really good.

We need to get him a decent halves partner. I'd love us to get Jake Arthur.
Click to expand...
He was good for half a game. Still did diddley-squat in the first half.
We didn't win. We haven't won with him for a long time. Like keeping your grandmother on life support because her eye flickers every second month.
 
You Know Who said:
Performing well? Neither his performances is or his stats in the oppositions half throughout this season support that and neither does our 0-6 start. Our forwards have been laying the platform for the most part and he continued to do what he has done for most of his career which is good under pressure and take the wrong option.
Click to expand...

You have no idea at all. None.


Watch and weep. Brooksy is leaving the ladies weeping.

Our forwards haven't even been great. Our middles aren't making busts. IP has been good but not making busts. Bateman has been great.

Brooksy has had a couple of periods of incompetence but no more than any half in the comp. He isn't the problem and on that performance he is part of the solution.

Brooksy !
 
mikey said:
He was good for half a game. Still did diddley-squat in the first half.
We didn't win. We haven't won with him for a long time. Like keeping your grandmother on life support because her eye flickers every second month.
Click to expand...

He didn't make any mistakes in the first half and just didn't get the opportunities. When he did though he carved them up.

He is making fools of a bunch of you now and it must hurt.
 
Earl said:
You have no idea at all. None.


Watch and weep. Brooksy is leaving the ladies weeping.

Our forwards haven't even been great. Our middles aren't making busts. IP has been good but not making busts. Bateman has been great.

Brooksy has had a couple of periods of incompetence but no more than any half in the comp. He isn't the problem and on that performance he is part of the solution.

Brooksy !
Click to expand...

Okay so you’re either trolling or just a simpleton. That’s the only way to explain why you’re incapable of holding a consistent opinion that isn’t completely nonsensical. That or you have no spine.

Not that great? We’re first in offloads, top five in possession, line engaged, all run metres top 6 in post contact metres, 10th in missed tackles (down from 4th last year)

Bit hard to make busts when your halfback is giving you garbage passes leaving them flat footed or throwing it half a metre behind them. Try having some evidence next time you spout your nonsense.

So you think he’s part of the solution because he had a semi decent half in one game when we have had our worst ever start in our teams history? Put the pom poms down, watch all the games this season and come back down to reality.
 
mikey said:
Really?
Click to expand...

Yep. Just watch the game. It's obvious. I said prior to the game that there are people who aren't Tigers fans but instead Brooks haters. They are coming out in full force now because he had a great game.

Watch the highlights I just posted.

I wonder why people are so attached to their ideas. Just admit he had a really good game. Go and re-watch some of the passes.
 
Earl said:
Yep. Just watch the game. It's obvious. I said prior to the game that there are people who aren't Tigers fans but instead Brooks haters. They are coming out in full force now because he had a great game.

Watch the highlights I just posted.

I wonder why people are so attached to their ideas. Just admit he had a really good game. Go and re-watch some of the passes.
Click to expand...
I think you're missing the point. Half a game means very little in the greater context of a large number of losses in a row.
Perhaps you should analyse your own attachments to ideas. Rewatch some of his other games where he gets it wrong countless times- might take a year or two though. 🙂
I do admire your loyalty to the man though.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,390 (members: 7, guests: 1,383)
Back
Top