Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Demps said:
What do you think his best position is ?

Personally it's lock for me.
Click to expand...

Definitely. I think he is the best lock we have but Pole and Twal are probably better middles. I don't rate Seyfarth on an edge although he can do it.

We have to sort out our middle forwards. We have a lot of them and we need to get the balance right. I'm glad we let Joe O go and I like him as a player. I think we'll have to lose some more middles as well.
 
bptiger 0 said:
I still say Sam Walker is the stand out 1/2 we should be after , x- factor , goal kicker , him and fainu could be our 1/2s for the next 10 years or so
Click to expand...
Is think so too... Cogger out of the equation... Sezer and Sullivan not at his level.
Is walker a free agent?
 
Last edited:
mark my words... sullivan is going to be another shite signing... Flanno has shifted him onto us... because he knows how to rebuild a roster...

my father turned 80 this year... he loves saying "he who lives in hope, dies in hope"...

Sullivan is another "hope" signing... another guy who has a poor reputation at another club -- but that "we will get the best out of him... because he needs a change, needs a go, we have the best coaches who are similar to him etc etc"...

The guy has a bad attitude to training, a string of hamstring issues, and was unwanted, has played a handful of games and is unproven - yet we have taken him for 3 years? lol. to be our what 6, 7? start as 6 and then move to 7 when Sezer leaves so Fainu can play 6? Can be our #14 if he doesnt work at 6 or 7? So basically like another Douehi or Mbye -- they worked out well. lol.

My cousin is a major sponsor of the dragons -- speaks to the coaches -- goes into the dressing before and after games -- and said everyone is glad to see him leave... Flanno was just bluffing they wouldnt chip in... and now we are getting him lol
 
tigermate said:
mark my words... sullivan is going to be another shite signing... Flanno has shifted him onto us... because he knows how to rebuild a roster...

my father turned 80 this year... he loves saying "he who lives in hope, dies in hope"...

Sullivan is another "hope" signing... another guy who has a poor reputation at another club -- but that "we will get the best out of him... because he needs a change, needs a go, we have the best coaches who are similar to him etc etc"...

The guy has a bad attitude to training, a string of hamstring issues, and was unwanted, has played a handful of games and is unproven - yet we have taken him for 3 years? lol. to be our what 6, 7? start as 6 and then move to 7 when Sezer leaves so Fainu can play 6? Can be our #14 if he doesnt work at 6 or 7? So basically like another Douehi or Mbye -- they worked out well. lol.

My cousin is a major sponsor of the dragons -- speaks to the coaches -- goes into the dressing before and after games -- and said everyone is glad to see him leave... Flanno was just bluffing they wouldnt chip in... and now we are getting him lol
Click to expand...
He's a piece of the puzzle... for now.

In 3 years when his contract ends we will hopefully see the likes if Conti, Isdale, Large coming through and Fainu will be more experienced.

All that negativity aside... Sullivan isn't a franchise player but he'll do a job for us. When we played them earlier in the year, he carved us up. He's better than what we currently have & that's the goal - to improve the roster.

He could be 14 with Sezar and Fainu in the halves and he's just impact off the bench, we don't know yet
 
Demps said:
He's a piece of the puzzle... for now.

In 3 years when his contract ends we will hopefully see the likes if Conti, Isdale, Large coming through and Fainu will be more experienced.

All that negativity aside... Sullivan isn't a franchise player but he'll do a job for us. When we played them earlier in the year, he carved us up. He's better than what we currently have & that's the goal - to improve the roster.

He could be 14 with Sezar and Fainu in the halves and he's just impact off the bench, we don't know yet
Click to expand...
i hope you're right...

but again thats hope...

he takes up $500K worth of space and a potential "half" signing we could go for next year ... not an insignificant... plus its a 3 Year deal -- not 2.

if it was 2 - then id say ok - worse case you carry him for a year... but we always take players for that extra year too long IMO
 
tigermate said:
mark my words... sullivan is going to be another shite signing... Flanno has shifted him onto us... because he knows how to rebuild a roster...

my father turned 80 this year... he loves saying "he who lives in hope, dies in hope"...

Sullivan is another "hope" signing... another guy who has a poor reputation at another club -- but that "we will get the best out of him... because he needs a change, needs a go, we have the best coaches who are similar to him etc etc"...

The guy has a bad attitude to training, a string of hamstring issues, and was unwanted, has played a handful of games and is unproven - yet we have taken him for 3 years? lol. to be our what 6, 7? start as 6 and then move to 7 when Sezer leaves so Fainu can play 6? Can be our #14 if he doesnt work at 6 or 7? So basically like another Douehi or Mbye -- they worked out well. lol.

My cousin is a major sponsor of the dragons -- speaks to the coaches -- goes into the dressing before and after games -- and said everyone is glad to see him leave... Flanno was just bluffing they wouldnt chip in... and now we are getting him lol
Click to expand...
I’m not too concerned. We need depth in the halves. He’s better than what we have. He can take wakeham and Laurie’s spot. There’s a small chance he excels. Fainu may well leapfrog him in firsts anyway and that’s a good problem to have.
 
Tiger-ferret said:
I’m not too concerned. We need depth in the halves. He’s better than what we have. He can take wakeham and Laurie’s spot. There’s a small chance he excels. Fainu may well leapfrog him in firsts anyway and that’s a good problem to have.
Click to expand...
at least we might score some points lol...

i actually prefer losing when we actually are fun to watch.... right now losing is the worst bc we cant even score...

yeah - youre probably right
 
I think WT need to look at the success in 2005.

Centres were Shane Elford - who joined WT in 2004 after 69 games at Penrith and Paul Whatuira - who joined WT in 2005 after 73 games at various clubs. Both bought a lot of experience.

WT also rescued the careers of both injury plagued Scott Prince and Pat Richards.

WT only have Toa as a serviceable Centre with plenty of upsides. The rest like Naden can leave. Feledy might be some years off NRL.

Players like Mono (played with WT and in Grand Finals) and Brad Parker (26 years old and 112 NRL games) are experienced and NRL hardened players that we need to play the Elford, Whatuira roles especially with inexperienced full back, wingers and halves.

I am not trying to relive the 2005 season but we really need some more experienced and NRL hardened players who have played at least 50 NRL games and can tackle and pass the ball. I feel our wingers need more serviceable balls.
 
Last edited:
tigermate said:
i hope you're right...

but again thats hope...

he takes up $500K worth of space and a potential "half" signing we could go for next year ... not an insignificant... plus its a 3 Year deal -- not 2.

if it was 2 - then id say ok - worse case you carry him for a year... but we always take players for that extra year too long IMO
Click to expand...
This will be a big test for Tim, Benji, coaching staff & player leaders next season because he obviously has the talent & skills. Just needs to build his maturity, concentration, defensive efforts & game management.

I doubt we're taking him at full freight, surely not.
 
www.zerotackle.com

Wests Tigers youngster secures top 30 spot for next two seasons

After scoring a train and trial contract with the Wests Tigers for this season, young hooker Tallyn Da Silva has secured a top 30 spot for the next two seasons with the club.
www.zerotackle.com www.zerotackle.com

As we already assumed, TDS into the top 30 squad for next season. The next confirmation into top 30 I reckon will be Chris Faagutu.
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
www.zerotackle.com

Wests Tigers youngster secures top 30 spot for next two seasons

After scoring a train and trial contract with the Wests Tigers for this season, young hooker Tallyn Da Silva has secured a top 30 spot for the next two seasons with the club.
www.zerotackle.com www.zerotackle.com

As we already assumed, TDS into the top 30 squad for next season. The next confirmation into top 30 I reckon will be Chris Faagutu.
Click to expand...
I thought Fa'agutu would be a certainty for Top 30 but I'm really not certain with the lack of spots we have in the squad for next year. time will tell I spose.
 
Magpies1969 said:
I think WT need to look at the success in 2005.

Centres were Shane Elford - who joined WT in 2004 after 69 games at Penrith and Paul Whatuira - who joined WT in 2005 after 73 games at various clubs. Both bought a lot of experience.

WT also rescued the careers of both injury plagued Scott Prince and Pat Richards.

WT only have Toa as a serviceable Centre with plenty of upsides. The rest like Naden can leave. Feledy might be some years off NRL.

Players like Mono (played with WT and in Grand Finals) and Brad Parker are experienced and NRL hardened players that we need to play the Elford, Whatuira roles especially with inexperienced full back, wingers and halves.

That is my take.
Click to expand...
Us not moving on from 2005 is the reason why the club finds itself in the mess it's in currently.
 
tigermate said:
mark my words... sullivan is going to be another shite signing... Flanno has shifted him onto us... because he knows how to rebuild a roster...

my father turned 80 this year... he loves saying "he who lives in hope, dies in hope"...

Sullivan is another "hope" signing... another guy who has a poor reputation at another club -- but that "we will get the best out of him... because he needs a change, needs a go, we have the best coaches who are similar to him etc etc"...

The guy has a bad attitude to training, a string of hamstring issues, and was unwanted, has played a handful of games and is unproven - yet we have taken him for 3 years? lol. to be our what 6, 7? start as 6 and then move to 7 when Sezer leaves so Fainu can play 6? Can be our #14 if he doesnt work at 6 or 7? So basically like another Douehi or Mbye -- they worked out well. lol.

My cousin is a major sponsor of the dragons -- speaks to the coaches -- goes into the dressing before and after games -- and said everyone is glad to see him leave... Flanno was just bluffing they wouldnt chip in... and now we are getting him lol
Click to expand...

I tend to agree.

He's a bit of a Daine Laurie. I also don't think he has a position - and we have/had so many players like that.

I just don't see it working out, players like him at clubs like ours is a recipe for disaster.

But we're very, very short for options.
 
So who's our goal kicker if wakeham isn't in the team next year, if nothing else this year I have loved having a goal kicker with high percentages. Go up by 6s rather than 4s is huge.

I don't think API is the permanent goal kicker is he?
 
jrtiger said:
I thought Fa'agutu would be a certainty for Top 30 but I'm really not certain with the lack of spots we have in the squad for next year. time will tell I spose.
Click to expand...
I think he will be a priority for us to elevate into top 30 next season. For one, he is managed by Cove/Isaac Moses (same as Galvin) so for us to retain him we probably have to guarantee an immediate pathway. Not saying it's right but possibly the position we're in.
 
tigermate said:
i hope you're right...

but again thats hope...

he takes up $500K worth of space and a potential "half" signing we could go for next year ... not an insignificant... plus its a 3 Year deal -- not 2.

if it was 2 - then id say ok - worse case you carry him for a year... but we always take players for that extra year too long IMO
Click to expand...
What difference does 2/3 yr contract make. They can break their contracts whenever they wish anyway
 
Hbom said:
Tell me about Will Craig please.
Click to expand...
Very progressive centre/wing in Magpies SG Ball (bottom age) & Westfields SHS who is part of our earmarked pathways group (according to the recent WT article). Has filled out physically since last season in Harold Matts and looks a very strong powerful reasonably fast outside back (not overly tall) on both sides of the ball. Great combo with Lachlan Galvin, Tallyn Da Silva & Luke Laulilii.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 409 (members: 39, guests: 370)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top