Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Vicious]

60% of so of NRL players are Polynesian putting a kid not developed is a walking repeated long term injury away.

I would be very very surprised unless we had an injury crisis if Galvin plays NRL in 24. We have zero reason to rush him.

Benji will decide if and when he’s ready, he’s better placed than any of us to make that decision.
The fact is Benji rates this kid highly and he won’t be concerned about playing him at NRL level just because he’s more slightly built than others.
Based on that theory Sam Walker and Jayden Campbell should not have played any NRL by now, they both go ok.

 

[TigerNeddyK]

My point is Dragons are a perfect place for Nofo

The love our rejects

Manly would like to argue with this statement.. wholeheartedly

 

[Kelce68]

Isaako just had a career season with tries and goal-kicking!

He has the right wing locked up - and the rest will fight it out for left wing.

Tesi Niu is more likely to start there than Bostock!!

Why are you yelling?

 

[teddy23]

I don't think it's breaking news that a guy who's been playing in the NRL for 3 years & on a better attacking team is more threatening then a guy who hasn't even played 20 games & was on the worst attacking team in the comp.... here's a link to Bula fending off one of the best props in the game to score a try btw

I actually agree with @Vicious point, however you aren't telling any lies as well. Bula is a supreme talent BUT he's not a superstar YET. Could he be one day?..... Absolutely.

I feel as a club we can sometimes put too much pressure on a kid who has shown promise within a short period of time. I have this same worry about Latu Fainu too even I’m guilty of it.

I think we're looking for our next Benji constantly. Who’s gonna be the next wonder kid to come through and turn our success around. It was meant to be Tedesco then he eventually left due to bad management. I think we're starting to heap that onto both Bula/Fainu. I saw TDS play a handful of games and due to the high expectations seems like he overplayed his hand on occasions and it didn't look natural.

Personally, what I admire most about Bula's game is his maturity it’s impressive for someone who’s played limited games, it isn't his ability but more his comfortably he's just a natural footballer. His instincts are insane both attacking/defensively, his reading of the game is exceptional and his athleticism is top tier. He also takes a lot of tough carries and runs for 200 meters a game often. He’s more a Dylan Edwards mould than a Reece Walsh. Whenever the skills/ability start to click more often and he gets even more experience then we can have the conversation of calling him a star. At this moment of time he’s just a very talented footballer.

Overall, my point is we should lower our expectations on our youngsters and allow them to develop naturally without any added stress or expectations which can hinder them. Luai coming in will help with that as we now have 2 proven superstars in our spine with Api as well and won’t need to rely on rookies like we have the last decade.

It’s a refreshing change which we should enjoy.

 

[jrtiger]

Jesus Christ ! Wtf are you guys even arguing ? I’m literally saying if he’s training with the firsts , it means he’s right there . All I’m saying is if he’s got the skills don’t be surprised if he’s there round 1.
Sorry but unless you’ve got some insight into what Galvin benches , how he goes in wrestling drills , contact drills etc you have as much idea as I do .
How do you know what Galvins maturity is like ? Nofa is 30 and is the most immature dude in the team .

I've heard he is stupidly fit and deceptively strong from a coach within the pathways. the rumour about him breaking the 1.2km Bronco record Reynolds set when he was here is legitimate. no idea what he's benching but again, deceptively strong.

 

[Snidest 0]

Why are you yelling?

Does this read as all capitals to you?

Are you having a stroke?

Is there a metallic taste in your mouth?

 

[Snidest 0]

Ur entitled to ur say , I still think they are better than what we got , and lay of the sex affender thing , if the nrl register them , then we may as well get them rather than another team

Given any deal would be for 2025 - you are literally claiming Tyrone May is BETTER than:

Luai
Fainu
Sullivan
Galvin

He is a crap player and a worse person!!

‘Wake up to yourself’: Woman at centre of Tyrone May sex scandal breaks silence

Just when she thought the saga was finally over, the woman at the centre of the Tyrone May sex tape scandal had to relive the entire ordeal.

www.smh.com.au

 

[Glenji95]

And the main difference was that Brasher and Fittler - (and Rowdy for that matter speaking of players who debuted while at school) - were physically ready to make the jump to grade and had proven that playing reserve grade with and against seasoned veterans.

While their physiques matured over the years - their body shapes and relative playing weights did not dramatically change from their debuts until their retirements.

(* Notwithstanding Freddy's post-1990 Kangaroo Tour waistline blow out)

Compare that to the scrawny kid Benji was when he debuted in 2003 - and his necessary physical development from 2005 to 2010-11 when he was at he peak of his game.

That has to be the biggest consideration with Galvin - as we don't want a wasted 2025 for the kid (or our cap) by debuting him too early and risking a major injury that sees him in a lengthy rehab.

For me Galvin should be spending time in reserve grade before getting that call up. Hasn’t even played Flegg and hasn’t gone up against men yet. He’s got potential and I think he’ll make first grade at some stage. But playing him round 1 (well round 2 in our case) is a gamble that shouldn’t be happening yet.

 

[Dennisspicer1]

Just let Benji do what he is doing, and with Richo backing him we are in good hands.

And Richo stated after we secured Olam that another couple might be coming to the West Tigers in the next few weeks,

let's just wait and see what's going to happen, I feel pretty good about what there doing.

 

[BAGNF05]

For me Galvin should be spending time in reserve grade before getting that call up. Hasn’t even played Flegg and hasn’t gone up against men yet. He’s got potential and I think he’ll make first grade at some stage. But playing him round 1 (well round 2 in our case) is a gamble that shouldn’t be happening yet.

I suspect we need to find out what we’ve got and he’s being tested in pre-season to that end. The club is probably fielding many calls with potential players coming our way in return.

 

[TigerNeddyK]

If Galvin is in the team straight away (unless we have absolutely no choice) we’re screwed. Even if he’s training the house down, he’s never played against men before only boys at best. Kid needs to play Cup for a bit before getting the call up. However back on Miller, I don’t see him in the squad straight away, but given he’s top 30 at some point during the training session he’s gonna be training with the other top 30 as well even if it is just for an hour or so. All the top 30 train together especially during the pre season. It’ll break down as the season moves on and he’ll most likely be training a lot with the Flegg and Cup squads, but there will be times he’ll be training with the 30. The picture I mentioned is proof of that.

JFC it would not mean we are screwed!! It would mean that at training the “trainers” have noted that athletically and skill wise Galvin is up to it and maybe will get a trial to see if he ca no handle it under match conditions.. some prodigy’s just have it , and will make it wherever you throw them. Some kids are just born to play league and Galvin may just be one of them . We look like we may find out soon

 

[Snidest 0]

For me Galvin should be spending time in reserve grade before getting that call up. Hasn’t even played Flegg and hasn’t gone up against men yet. He’s got potential and I think he’ll make first grade at some stage. But playing him round 1 (well round 2 in our case) is a gamble that shouldn’t be happening yet.

I hope he doesn't play NRL in 2024 - because those sort of debuts normally occur when the team is struggling or out of options due to injury/rep selection (like TDS).

Or we blood them in the last rounds when out of contention for the 8...

It is a nice gesture to up and comers - but reflects where the club sits and is not the ideal environment to debut!

 

[Leck]

I am glad to see a few have woken up to the fact that advertising his attitude problems isn’t going to make him the easiest guy to offload.

His performance will be. Make or break this season.

 

[Snidest 0]

I am glad to see a few have woken up to the fact that advertising his attitude problems isn’t going to make him the easiest guy to offload.

Problem is that he is so stupid - he doesn't realise how toxic his actions have been to his future prospects!

 

[TigerNeddyK]

He was playing against butchers, bakers and candle stick makers.

Really ?? Mal Meninga , mark Mcgaw, Et , Daley , Chris Mortimer , Florine, Chris Jon’s , Michael O’Connor , Hancock , Fittler tery hill , Kevin iro , etc etc all seemed pretty good players to me at the time !! 😅😂🤣😁

 

[clontarfkid]

His performance will be. Make or break this season.

Not really..he gets $500k this year and next by just breathing!!

 

[BAGNF05]

Really ?? Mal Meninga , mark Mcgaw, Et , Daley , Chris Mortimer , Florine, Chris Jon’s , Michael O’Connor , Hancock , Fittler tery hill , Kevin iro , etc etc all seemed pretty good players to me at the time !! 😅😂🤣😁

Very good players who had day jobs and didn’t train 9 to 5.

 

[TigerNeddyK]

Remember Galvin couldn’t even make the Harold matthews side in the halves. You guys want to start him there this year, good luck!

Who said the halves ?? Talk is he may get a run in the centres or even on the wing .. plenty of super talented kids that ended up having 10 year plus NRL careers debuted on the wing just to get a run

 

[Glenji95]

I hope he doesn't play NRL in 2024 - because those sort of debuts normally occur when the team is struggling or out of options due to injury/rep selection (like TDS).

Or we blood them in the last rounds when out of contention for the 8...

It is a nice gesture to up and comers - but reflects where the club sits and is not the ideal environment to debut!

One thing I will say is while TDS probably wouldn’t have gotten his debut had Api not gone down with injury, he didn’t do too bad when he made his debut. Not perfect and obviously has things to work on, but he wasn’t crap either and actually did look threatening at times. Although this year I think he’ll spend at least 95% of the season in Cup unless we get hit again with injuries.

I’m hoping this year as well we don’t give debuts unless the player has earned it. Feledy and Kit I wouldn’t have named in our last game last season if I was the coach. Clearly weren’t ready although I think Kit will be ready at some stage, but whether that’s this year idk. Feledy needs at least the whole season in Cup if possible. Not writing him off he’s very young, but he’s not ready.

 

[rugbygoated]

Given any deal would be for 2025 - you are literally claiming Tyrone May is BETTER than:

Luai
Fainu
Sullivan
Galvin

He is a crap player and a worse person!!

‘Wake up to yourself’: Woman at centre of Tyrone May sex scandal breaks silence

Just when she thought the saga was finally over, the woman at the centre of the Tyrone May sex tape scandal had to relive the entire ordeal.

www.smh.com.au

View attachment 9664

Ivan Cleary is a big fan of Tyrone May. Let Penrith have him please. I'm not taking Terrell and Taylan if it means Tyrone has to come. He is trouble on and off the field