Stefano Utoikamanu #241

The insinuation on the local radio news this morning that the Tigers have a job to fight Canberra and the dolphins to keep him this year (before the June 30 deadline). “They are ready to pounce”

Manager is scum
If that’s true, today could be his last game for us.
 
The insinuation on the local radio news this morning that the Tigers have a job to fight Canberra and the dolphins to keep him this year (before the June 30 deadline). “They are ready to pounce”

Manager is scum

You know what, I'd take an immediate release to Canberra if it's a swap with Trey Mooney.

Yes Stef is currently a better player, but if he wants out and we secure a top prospect in Mooney for much less money, allowing us to sign an experienced prop like Hunt, we come out in front.

Id be happy if we added Mooney, Hunt and Jack Williams or Tallis Duncan to our middle.

I know Hunt has been coming off the bench, but you could start him. Instead of playing 15 minutes either side of half time, play him 15 min to start the game and set the scene. Then again at some stage on the 2nd half.
 
You know what, I'd take an immediate release to Canberra if it's a swap with Trey Mooney.

Yes Stef is currently a better player, but if he wants out and we secure a top prospect in Mooney for much less money, allowing us to sign an experienced prop like Hunt, we come out in front.

Id be happy if we added Mooney, Hunt and Jack Williams or Tallis Duncan to our middle.

I know Hunt has been coming off the bench, but you could start him. Instead of playing 15 minutes either side of half time, play him 15 min to start the game and set the scene. Then again at some stage on the 2nd half.
I’d take this swap as well. No question. We simply need more first graders.
 
Definitely gone - is saying so himself. Now the difficulty is for the club to find a player(s) to replace him. The only upside being that he isn’t that consistent and is often soft so replacing him with a solid aggressive prop who plays tough every week may just be an improvement for us.
Can’t say that he has won me over - his attitude needs adjusting.
 
If he is gone, as it sounds in that report, then take a serious Moneyball approach.

You will not replace the player Utoikamanu is with what is available. But you can get a big guy, a harder runner or a defensive demon as a combination of a couple of players for around the same value.

Canberra's reserves middles of Mooney, Saulo & Hola could be had all up for Utoikamanu money. Having watched them play- I'd hazard a guess you drop in talent but get as much statistical return from these guys.

The issue with losing Utoikamanu is his individual impact on the field. He draws defenders. He's strong. The remaining middles would need to either up their game (Klemmer/Twal/Matamua) or an additional impactful player added to the game day roster (Jordan Miller seems most likely).

I like Utoikamanu. But realistically, so long as the right recruits are brought in, adding Luai is much more of an upgrade than losing Utoikamanu.

Would be much easier to stomach if Fa'agutu was more ready to step in!
 
I think " huge" is overstating his efforts, Bags. We know what he's capable of because he gives us a little glimpse now & then. Just doesn't produce consistently for some reason. He'll go OK at a top team where he can be carried.
The reality is most front rowers toil hard and churn out good metres and make their tackles but largely go unnoticed. A select bunch (JFH / Haas types) are capable of more than that (and Stef is one of those ones as evidenced by an 800k offer and interest from Wayne and Belly ache). It just goes largely unnoticed in our side because the team rarely take advantage of his better moments. He was absolutely running over people last weekend. Put him behind the Sharks back 5 for example and watch the carnage that ensues as he takes the third charge with wind in his sails.

I’d love him to stay but can certainly understand why he’d leave.
 
He might not have signed elsewhere yet, but it does sound like he's made his mind up to move on.

I'm not terribly disappointed. At $800k that's way over what he's worth and he obviously doesn't have the fighting mentality we need. Just another who wants to be carried.
I won’t be terribly disappointed if he moves on either, he clearly wants to go. However, moving experienced forwards on without any suitable replacements in the wings is a tad worrying. Apart from the Turuva signing (a winger) early this year, all we’ve done is move players on.
 
I won’t be terribly disappointed if he moves on either, he clearly wants to go. However, moving experienced forwards on without any suitable replacements in the wings is a tad worrying. Apart from the Turuva signing (a winger) early this year, all we’ve done is move players on.
Chance for Richo & BQM to show their worth.
 
If he is gone, as it sounds in that report, then take a serious Moneyball approach.

You will not replace the player Utoikamanu is with what is available. But you can get a big guy, a harder runner or a defensive demon as a combination of a couple of players for around the same value.

Canberra's reserves middles of Mooney, Saulo & Hola could be had all up for Utoikamanu money. Having watched them play- I'd hazard a guess you drop in talent but get as much statistical return from these guys.

The issue with losing Utoikamanu is his individual impact on the field. He draws defenders. He's strong. The remaining middles would need to either up their game (Klemmer/Twal/Matamua) or an additional impactful player added to the game day roster (Jordan Miller seems most likely).

I like Utoikamanu. But realistically, so long as the right recruits are brought in, adding Luai is much more of an upgrade than losing Utoikamanu.

Would be much easier to stomach if Fa'agutu was more ready to step in!
Have a feeling Richo knew the writing was on the wall with Stef and his England trip was about finding some hard arse forwards to lay a platform for Luai & co.
 
Back
Top