Stefano Utoikamanu #241

Nothing will be announced until this year is done for the recruits.
I hope you’re right Bags, but I’m not holding my breath. If Richo thinks English players are the answer, it’s a big risk, imo. I’d rather some NRL hardened forwards, but that’s wishful thinking, I know.
 
I get the point and I wish we were a club attractive enough to be able to do this to players - but the reality is, we lose a quality (all be inconsistent player) and we replace him with someone like Klemmer....

It's all fine to cull players but we need to be replacing them with better - so far we have not.
I’d be going to the market now looking for someone else and telling him good bye and good luck. We’re not waiting for you. Club in the cellar, new recruits coming, club undergoing change. Great team to be a part of. As someone mentioned earlier, Pole runs heaps harder than Stefano.

The one I wanted and everyone shot me down was Nathan Brown. The guy now has a two year extension. Really could have used him off the bench.
 
To be fair though- Klemmer, Twal, Pole, Seyfarth, Sione Fainu, Jordan Miller & Matamua isn't a bad starting point for our middle rotation.

Twal is criminally underrated in his performances & other than physical dominance & offloads- matches Utoikamanu on the field.

Klemmer gets critisised for his slow play of the ball, but everything else he does is class.

And Pole is just coming up to his 50th game & so far this season...hasn't started at prop. Will be interesting to see how he goes today.

Offloading ability (which I'm pretty sure Klemmer is good at but has little support- and Seyfarth is actually quite good at) & that physical presence will be lost. This is where Miller can step in.

One thing that needs to be acknowledged with all our middles- they are a very strong defensive unit- all averaging early 90% tackle efficiency.

Maybe the Utoikamanu money should be spread out onto the edges where our wingers are the opposite in defensive abilities....
 
To be fair though- Klemmer, Twal, Pole, Seyfarth, Sione Fainu, Jordan Miller & Matamua isn't a bad starting point for our middle rotation.

Twal is criminally underrated in his performances & other than physical dominance & offloads- matches Utoikamanu on the field.

Klemmer gets critisised for his slow play of the ball, but everything else he does is class.

And Pole is just coming up to his 50th game & so far this season...hasn't started at prop. Will be interesting to see how he goes today.

Offloading ability (which I'm pretty sure Klemmer is good at but has little support- and Seyfarth is actually quite good at) & that physical presence will be lost. This is where Miller can step in.

One thing that needs to be acknowledged with all our middles- they are a very strong defensive unit- all averaging early 90% tackle efficiency.

Maybe the Utoikamanu money should be spread out onto the edges where our wingers are the opposite in defensive abilities....
If we’re running with those middles we are bottom four next year.
 
He consciously or subconsciously dropped off in form around origin selection time, with that ridiculous clause in his contract its too much if a coincidence for mine. Was giving him the benefit of the doubt but after reading those quotes I'm pretty gutted. If he doesn't drop off 30% over that few weeks we were certainly close enough in a couple to not be last.
 
He consciously or subconsciously dropped off in form around origin selection time, with that ridiculous clause in his contract its too much if a coincidence for mine. Was giving him the benefit of the doubt but after reading those quotes I'm pretty gutted. If he doesn't drop off 30% over that few weeks we were certainly close enough in a couple to not be last.
If Stef was bad during that month exactly what were Naden & Staines? 18 man game and until our squad is more reliable we’ll lose the winners.
 
If we’re running with those middles we are bottom four next year.
We already are.

As has been discussed previously, our back 3 do nothing to help our middles at all.

Using Utoikamanu money to build up our winger stock & have a better return out of our first couple of hit-ups per set does change the look of how a team plays.

I'd disagree that those middles are as bad as you are suggesting. Looking at a team like the Dolphins, for example, there's not a whole lot of difference to what they offer.

The Dolphins back 3, however...
 
If Stef was bad during that month exactly what were Naden & Staines? 18 man game and until our squad is more reliable we’ll lose the winners.
They were worse no doubt...but not saying to the media they want to go to a good club. To repeat, I was giving him the benefit of the doubt and didn't complain about his form at the time, these quotes read incredibly poorly to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
We already are.

As has been discussed previously, our back 3 do nothing to help our middles at all.

Using Utoikamanu money to build up our winger stock & have a better return out of our first couple of hit-ups per set does change the look of how a team plays.

I'd disagree that those middles are as bad as you are suggesting. Looking at a team like the Dolphins, for example, there's not a whole lot of difference to what they offer.

The Dolphins back 3, however...
Dolphins pack is much better than people give them credit for. All they’ve done is win at Melbourne and now Redcliffe.
 
They were worse no doubt...but not saying to the media they want to go to a good club. To repeat, I was giving him the benefit of the doubt and didn't complain about his form at the time, these quotes read incredibly poorly to me.
It’s just honesty mate. Look at Teddy’s career after leaving. The surprise and dismay on here is pretty shocking. If he keeps playing like last week for the rest of this year and moves on, good luck to him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Dolphins pack is much better than people give them credit for. All they’ve done is win at Melbourne and now Redcliffe.
Absolutely.

But that minimises the impact of that amazing back three of theirs. Same with the Storm, who historically get great returns from the first guys to take hit ups in their sets.

Statistically, the Dolphins forwards are very similar to the Tigers forwards.

However, Staines & the rolladex of wingers on the other side do not match up with what you get from the Dolphins.
 
Well if the pea heart and all his other forward mates had shown some ticker and had a go like bennets basically unknown forward pack, they would have won more games

Don’t worry ,.. he will be gone soon… so we will be able to move onto the next “pea heart “..
 
It’s just honesty mate. Look at Teddy’s career after leaving. The surprise and dismay on here is pretty shocking. If he keeps playing like last week for the rest of this year and moves on, good luck to him.
Rationally you're right, but im a WT fan not League fan and still half hate Teddy haha
 
Absolutely.

But that minimises the impact of that amazing back three of theirs. Same with the Storm, who historically get great returns from the first guys to take hit ups in their sets.

Statistically, the Dolphins forwards are very similar to the Tigers forwards.

However, Staines & the rolladex of wingers on the other side do not match up with what you get from the Dolphins.
I’m with you there. It’s the biggest change in the game in the last ten years. Outside backs do more dirty work so forwards aren’t as spent.
 
Back
Top