Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[bptiger 0]

Makasini will play wing for the next few years at least.

Like Cobbo, starting out wide is easiest and maybe in time as defence is proven they can move inside.

If the kid is any good he can play centre, Tim brasher played fullback at 17 and while at school , the coaches will know if he can or can’t play against men

 

[The Chad]

bateman for ravalawa was thrown to us via the dragons

club turned it down want to create a spot for sione

dragons and souths sniffing still

Interesting.

If it was simply an issue with roster spots, Bateman & Doueihi for Ravalawa...I'd do that.

I know Ravalawa is going to be described as potentially the worst signing ever by some on here, but there is always a place for big bodied, try scoring wingers.

 

[The Chad]

Yep, and Doueihi wont be able to lift. Its a stupid cause trying to fit him in.
Olam and Bird will be the centres for round one surely.

I'm not buying in to the Doueihi negativity completely.

Better defenders around him will disguise the failings better than last season.

 

[mtd#2]

When the Roosters finish bottom 3 in 2025, Galvin won’t want to go anywhere near them.

he isnt going anywhere as it is...
I'm happy to take bets on this 😛

 

[Lestronge]

You need your better defenders on at the start of the game. Pole is ordinary.

But he’s pretty good in contact . His issues are when he tires , he’s lazy to his position around the ruck . Which gets exploited .

 

[mtd#2]

Have you tried turning it off and then on again?

have you unplugged it and plugged it back in?

 

[mtd#2]

Our only hope is that Bud gets pissed off stuck in KOE or RM Cup and asks for a release....

the roosters might have no choice but to pick him up

 

[Tucker]

I'm not buying in to the Doueihi negativity completely.

Better defenders around him will disguise the failings better than last season.

Weve been trying to fit him into the team for years and he has always been ordinary. Its only recently that people have started waking up to him.
Nice guy and seems to give a shit, not what we require.
Very much like Brooks.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

Except....Bird played extensively at centre (with a hand full of games at 5/8) and not at all in the forwards in 2024

I think if the focus is on defence especially on the edges, we may see Bird at right centre inside Skelton and outside Seyfarth to bring some experience to that edge (with Sam Fainu/Olam/Turuva on the left).

But in saying that, I do remember at the time of his signing, it was said Turuva would be given first crack at centre and maybe that's just in the trials to see how it goes.

In a perfect world, To'a will take a quantum leap forward in defence, physicality & effort and say 'right centre is mine'!!!

 

[Tucker]

But he’s pretty good in contact . His issues are when he tires , he’s lazy to his position around the ruck . Which gets exploited .

Yes, like most average defenders, if you run straight at them, theyll get you.
His Kryptonite is his lateral movement defending against footwork or angle changes around the ruck as you said.

 

[jrtiger]

Except....Bird played extensively at centre (with a hand full of games at 5/8) and not at all in the forwards in 2024

yes and he was below first grade standard there. he's not a week-to-week outside back anymore. it's time for him to become a utility player.

 

[Tcat]

It’s crazy how Lee presented it that he was doing right by his club , when in actuality he was rorting the club big time . And I reckon he knew it all along .

Lee should be arrested and locked up if ever comes near a WTs game. Egotistical prick.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

Jordan Miller into the personal fitness classes with Michael Fualalo who trains a lot of NRL players in the off-season.

 

[WestsEffTheRest]

If it was simply an issue with roster spots, Bateman & Doueihi for Ravalawa...I'd do that.

That would be one of the worst deals in the history of Rugby League.

 

[weststigerman]

Hope Turuva makes a go of it at centre, but I'd really like to see the 1-2 hitups from Skelton and Turuva to get our sets going.

Although later in the year if he starts on the wing Makasini and Skelton would be even better.

 

[The Chad]

That would be one of the worst deals in the history of Rugby League.

Fair enough

 

[The Chad]

Weve been trying to fit him into the team for years and he has always been ordinary. Its only recently that people have started waking up to him.
Nice guy and seems to give a shit, not what we require.
Very much like Brooks.

You know what he was though?

A pretty good winger. That was his original gig at Souths I think- thought he was pretty good.

 

[The Chad]

yes and he was below first grade standard there. he's not a week-to-week outside back anymore. it's time for him to become a utility player.

Dragons were not held back by the play of their outside backs.

Bird was fine. That team over achieved last season.

 

[The Chad]

View attachment 17800
Jordan Miller into the personal fitness classes with Michael Fualalo who trains a lot of NRL players in the off-season.

Looks like he has his workout crocs on.

Nothing says pro-athlete like some workout crocs I reckon.

 

[jrtiger]

Dragons were not held back by the play of their outside backs.

Bird was fine. That team over achieved last season.

they did overachieve, but Jack was dropped mid-season in favour of Max Feagai.

he has a role to play at WT, but it's not in the centres.