Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Kelce68 said:
Correct. I don't.

I was pointing out a clear and obvious duality between retiring to return to the regular workforce, which is the case for the vast, vast majority of NRL footballers or continuing what is a well-remunerated, privileged and fortunate career.

There's nothing overly contentious about my original post and you're being contrarian for the sake of it.

You're not very good at it, obviously, being you 🙂.
Click to expand...
I pointed out something you acknowledged, then take an each way bet and say I’m being contrarian?
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Given what just happened with Galvin, plus the players who walked out on the club last year, you’d think people wails be a little more sheepish on why we are such an attractive destination, but apparently not.
Click to expand...
yes, let's look at one 19-year-old mercenary who has jumped from club to club from the moment he was shot out of the womb as the only example of whether we are an attractive destination or not, as opposed to the club's recruitment record over the last 18 months. what a foolproof idea.
 
jrtiger said:
yes, let's look at one 19-year-old mercenary who has jumped from club to club from the moment he was shot out of the womb as the only example of whether we are an attractive destination or not, as opposed to the club's recruitment record over the last 18 months. what a foolproof idea.
Click to expand...
Let’s also look at Stef, Ice and Bateman. But hey, never the club who might have to look at themselves. Always someone else’s fault.
 
Bus 2 Terrigal said:
I’m not sure what happened at Westfields but Galvin played in the back row for one year in junior reps (Matt’s Cup). At that time, Latu Fainu was at Manly 🤷‍♂️
Click to expand...
He may be referring to the city v country game where they repped together. Latu was 6 in that one.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Let’s also look at Stef, Ice and Bateman. But hey, never the club who might have to look at themselves. Always someone else’s fault.
Click to expand...
don't shift the goalposts any further or I'll start calling you Gus. you were implying that we aren't an attractive destination to potential external recruits.

Terrell May, Jarome Luai, Sunia Turuva and Royce Hunt all came from top four clubs last year to play for Wests Tigers this year. I can guarantee you there'll be more to come.

maybe you should put a mirror next to your bed so you can wake up to yourself.
 
jrtiger said:
don't shift the goalposts any further or I'll start calling you Gus. you were implying that we aren't an attractive destination to potential external recruits.

Terrell May, Jarome Luai, Sunia Turuva and Royce Hunt all came from top four clubs last year to play for Wests Tigers this year. I can guarantee you there'll be more to come.

maybe you should put a mirror next to your bed so you can wake up to yourself.
Click to expand...
I love Luai, but we all know what got him to the club. May, love the guy, but he was unwanted. Turuva had his cousin here. I’m not even going to acknowledge the 15 minute man. I wouldn’t be touting him mate.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Given what just happened with Galvin, plus the players who walked out on the club last year, you’d think people wails be a little more sheepish on why we are such an attractive destination, but apparently not.
Click to expand...
It’s pretty obvious we aren’t an attractive destination. Similar to Haas as Reed alluded to last night…players want to win
 
GNR4LIFE said:
I love Luai, but we all know what got him to the club. May, love the guy, but he was unwanted. Turuva had his cousin here. I’m not even going to acknowledge the 15 minute man. I wouldn’t be touting him mate.
Click to expand...
you're still missing the point.

all of them were pursued by rival clubs. they all chose us, despite the fact that we were anchored to the bottom of the ladder for three years.
 
jrtiger said:
yes, let's look at one 19-year-old mercenary who has jumped from club to club from the moment he was shot out of the womb as the only example of whether we are an attractive destination or not, as opposed to the club's recruitment record over the last 18 months. what a foolproof idea.
Click to expand...
It’s hilarious how butthurt a lot of you are over this.
I never once saw this narrative from you or anyone else about this kid last year, he was the second coming of Fittler and could do no wrong.
Our recruitment is getting better but it’s still in deficit. We’ve lost more than we gained and of those we gained….
Luai - No where near earning his salary. Lost his Origin jersey for good reason.
May - excellent.
Turuva - really good, bordering on great at times.
Bird - average.
Hunt - lazy and ineffective
Skelton - good but missed twice as many games as he has played.
By my count we’ve had two really good wins in recruitment, and another 2 who could be great - one has to pull his finger out and the other needs to get healthy.
I’ll withhold judgement entirely until the season concludes but the hive mind opinion on here that our recruitment is kicking huge goals doesn’t hold much weight currently.
 
jrtiger said:
you're still missing the point.

all of them were pursued by rival clubs. they all chose us, despite the fact that we were anchored to the bottom of the ladder for three years.
Click to expand...
How do you know who they were pursued by? The only one Id say for sure would be Luai. The rest is just conjecture. Given how May seems to have been blackballed for Origin, whose to say other clubs didn’t take the same stance. Hunt definitely wasn’t pursued. He was retiring.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
I pointed out something you acknowledged, then take an each way bet and say I’m being contrarian?
Click to expand...
I acknowledged simply the fact that, in Felise's specific case, I don't know what he has on offer post-football. But that wasn't my point.

And yes. You're a contrarian.

You present counter arguments to statements or assertions for the sake of it. Not for any purpose.

I was floating the idea that it is not inconceivable that somebody would continue their playing career, even if for a modest contract which included a move.

And, what? you decided to present a counter that it IS inconceivable...?
 
Kelce68 said:
I acknowledged simply the fact that, in Felise's specific case, I don't know what he has on offer post-football. But that wasn't my point.

And yes. You're a contrarian.

You present counter arguments to statements or assertions for the sake of it. Not for any purpose.

I was floating the idea that it is not inconceivable that somebody would continue their playing career, even if for a modest contract which included a move.

And, what? you decided to present a counter that it IS inconceivable...?
Click to expand...
Incase you aren’t aware, there are two of us. @batboy and I arguing the same point. So hardly contrarian.
 
TSP said:
My understanding is:

If a court says he’s guilty, that’s still bad.

The DV charge was only withdrawn because the prosecution witnesses didn’t come to court. It wasn’t withdrawn because the Police thought they didn’t have a case. They just couldn’t prove it.

At least he went off for counselling etc, so he’s got some insights.

Yes, there are many crims in the game. Case by case basis for me.
Click to expand...
 
 
batboy said:
You don't need to tell me anything?
I like how you find the bottom of the barrel wage rate you can like he's going to get a job in Subway or something.
By your own logic, He could also go play Japanese Rugby for another 3 years for much more money than he'll make in the NRL - At the Tigers. Or a stint in France with his family for a couple years....
All far more appealing than the Tigers in Sydney would be at the moment (Probably even the Subway gig)

You may see Allure - I see ridiculous speculation and mostly fantasy - at best.


Might, in fact - Like Carpentry as well (And hate Pre-seasons)

www.dolphinsnrl.com.au

Kaufusi prepares for life after football with carpentry trade

NRL veteran Felise Kaufusi is preparing for life after football, pursuing carpentry qualifications with support from Brisbane Barn Doors.
www.dolphinsnrl.com.au www.dolphinsnrl.com.au
Click to expand...
Yes. It was a proof of concept you pumpkin.

As in, if it would present some allure still at a modest rate, then it follows that a fatter contract north of that would improve said allure.

Are you simple?

'You may see Allure - I see ridiculous speculation and mostly fantasy - at best.'

My point is that it is not inconceivable. Which it, objectively, is not.

Felise Kaufusi (as an example only), and other player of his ilk, given that stage in their career, may find it attractive to continue their career over jump into retirement. Regardless of the side, their location or other factors.

But, imagine someone 'speculating' about possible signings in a signings and suggestions thread.
 
"The DV charge was only withdrawn because the prosecution witnesses didn’t come to court. It wasn’t withdrawn because the Police thought they didn’t have a case. They just couldn’t prove it."

It wouldn't be the first time that either party had to face the fact of providing the evidence under oath and under cross-examination - it's sort of confronting when you see the sentences for perjury.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TSP
GNR4LIFE said:
Incase you aren’t aware, there are two of us. @batboy and I arguing the same point. So hardly contrarian.
Click to expand...
Your points are tangential, and that is not a counter-argument, it's a red herring.

You have a well-established pattern of being a contrarian poster, as is your right. You do not need to be isolated to be so.

Try and keep up.
 
Tucker said:
It’s hilarious how butthurt a lot of you are over this.
I never once saw this narrative from you or anyone else about this kid last year, he was the second coming of Fittler and could do no wrong.
Our recruitment is getting better but it’s still in deficit. We’ve lost more than we gained and of those we gained….
Luai - No where near earning his salary. Lost his Origin jersey for good reason.
May - excellent.
Turuva - really good, bordering on great at times.
Bird - average.
Hunt - lazy and ineffective
Skelton - good but missed twice as many games as he has played.
By my count we’ve had two really good wins in recruitment, and another 2 who could be great - one has to pull his finger out and the other needs to get healthy.
I’ll withhold judgement entirely until the season concludes but the hive mind opinion on here that our recruitment is kicking huge goals doesn’t hold much weight currently.
Click to expand...
nice work trying to pile on when you, like GNR, completely missed the point. for such a high-level, pragmatic, conscientious businessman like you seem to tell everyone you are, you sure as hell know how to stir the pot when it's completely unnecessary.

Lachlan Galvin is a great player and I've never questioned his ability. feel free to go back and read my posts if you want. he'll do well, wherever he goes. the only 'narrative' that's been created is the one you've just tried to manufacture.

I'm disappointed with the fact that he's left the club, of course I am. he's a wonderful footballer. but we move on. it's time you did too.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 692 (members: 18, guests: 674)
Back
Top