Addo Carr signs with Storm...

[Flippedy]

chambers has missed half the year due to injury, munster is a replacement for billy slater and came from no where. The rest of the team are names you wouldnt even recognise or players who were average in other teams. So Craig Bellamy deserves no credit for 2016?

What's giving him credit got to do with it? You said besides the 3 players you named, the rest are no names. I just gave you two others that aren't, with a another 2 that are also quality.

Some of you are missing the point completely. They aren't no names _now_, but they _were_ when they started with Bellamy at the Storm. They have developed into good/great players under his coaching - how hard is that to understand?

No we're not missing the point you're just trying to make a completely different one. He's saying they have a scrub roster for 2016 outside a couple of big names and we're saying that they don't have a scrub roster.

I'm not trying to make a different point, I made the original one :unamused:

 

[Nelson]

What's giving him credit got to do with it? You said besides the 3 players you named, the rest are no names. I just gave you two others that aren't, with a another 2 that are also quality.

Some of you are missing the point completely. They aren't no names _now_, but they _were_ when they started with Bellamy at the Storm. They have developed into good/great players under his coaching - how hard is that to understand?

No we're not missing the point you're just trying to make a completely different one. He's saying they have a scrub roster for 2016 outside a couple of big names and we're saying that they don't have a scrub roster.

I'm not trying to make a different point, I made the original one :unamused:

I'm pretty sure the original point was something to do with Addo-Carr signing with the Storm…

 

[tigers2005]

What's giving him credit got to do with it? You said besides the 3 players you named, the rest are no names. I just gave you two others that aren't, with a another 2 that are also quality.

Some of you are missing the point completely. They aren't no names _now_, but they _were_ when they started with Bellamy at the Storm. They have developed into good/great players under his coaching - how hard is that to understand?

No we're not missing the point you're just trying to make a completely different one. He's saying they have a scrub roster for 2016 outside a couple of big names and we're saying that they don't have a scrub roster.

I'm not trying to make a different point, I made the original one :unamused:

Tim glasby, Nelson Solomona, Ben Hampton, Felise kaufasi, Jordan Mclean, Suliasi Vunivali no names.

Thank you very much, someone gets it. FinucAne, Green, morgan, korobite , average nrl players blossoming under bellamy. Thats 10 players up above. Compare that the cowboys, roosters, rabbits, sharks, broncos, bulldogs.. id say inferior to all those on paper. Credit to Bellamy, did something not even Bennett could do. Lost some superstars and re-built his team into a premiership force. Hats of.

 

[tigers2005]

Back on topic, any updates on JAC. Are we getting him back or what.

 

[Geo]

Some of you are missing the point completely. They aren't no names _now_, but they _were_ when they started with Bellamy at the Storm. They have developed into good/great players under his coaching - how hard is that to understand?

No we're not missing the point you're just trying to make a completely different one. He's saying they have a scrub roster for 2016 outside a couple of big names and we're saying that they don't have a scrub roster.

I'm not trying to make a different point, I made the original one :unamused:

Tim glasby, Nelson Solomona, Ben Hampton, Felise kaufasi, Jordan Mclean, Suliasi Vunivali no names.

Thank you very much, someone gets it. FinucAne, Green, morgan, korobite , average nrl players blossoming under bellamy. Thats 10 players up above. Compare that the cowboys, roosters, rabbits, sharks, broncos, bulldogs.. id say inferior to all those on paper. Credit to Bellamy, did something not even Bennett could do. Lost some superstars and re-built his team into a premiership force. Hats of.

I notice you didn't list Wests Tigers as having a superior roster to the Storm…on paper..

On topic..No Addo-Carr won't be with the Wests Tigers in 2017...Although if he doesn't get a run straight away under Bellemy he may well ask for another release..

 

[tigers2005]

No we're not missing the point you're just trying to make a completely different one. He's saying they have a scrub roster for 2016 outside a couple of big names and we're saying that they don't have a scrub roster.

I'm not trying to make a different point, I made the original one :unamused:

Tim glasby, Nelson Solomona, Ben Hampton, Felise kaufasi, Jordan Mclean, Suliasi Vunivali no names.

Thank you very much, someone gets it. FinucAne, Green, morgan, korobite , average nrl players blossoming under bellamy. Thats 10 players up above. Compare that the cowboys, roosters, rabbits, sharks, broncos, bulldogs.. id say inferior to all those on paper. Credit to Bellamy, did something not even Bennett could do. Lost some superstars and re-built his team into a premiership force. Hats of.

I notice you didn't list Wests Tigers as having a superior roster to the Storm…on paper..

On topic..No Addo-Carr won't be with the Wests Tigers in 2017...Although if he doesn't get a run straight away under Bellemy he may well ask for another release..

So the whole paying compensation and he wants to stay, is that done and dusted? :frowning:

We have the potential to be with the likes of moses, tedesco and brooks. I still think we are lacking the forward grunt and aggression to really challenge the big boys consistently. Do you think our roster is better than than the storm?

 

[Geo]

So the whole paying compensation and he wants to stay, is that done and dusted? :frowning:

We have the potential to be with the likes of moses, tedesco and brooks. I still think we are lacking the forward grunt and aggression to really challenge the big boys consistently. Do you think our roster is better than than the storm?

If we signed Jesse Bromwich Tahu Harris Kevin Proctor Dale Finucane Will Chambers and Addo-Carr…for sure we would be better...

 

[tigers2005]

So the whole paying compensation and he wants to stay, is that done and dusted? :frowning:

We have the potential to be with the likes of moses, tedesco and brooks. I still think we are lacking the forward grunt and aggression to really challenge the big boys consistently. Do you think our roster is better than than the storm?

If we signed Jesse Bromwich Tahu Harris Kevin Proctor Dale Finucane Will Chambers and Addo-Carr…for sure we would be better...

You mean our Addo carr, maybe if we also had korobite…. But we dont like our wingers to have pace.

 

[diedpretty]

Saw this article on " Mr I want to be a superstar now."

http://rugbyleagueweek.com.au/addo-carr-ready-play-best/?adbsc=social_20161216_68775216&adbid=1351893211518585&adbpl=fb&adbpr=110919635615955

 

[happy_tiger]

60 Pages on JAC

You have to be kidding

 

[greatodensraven]

I think he'll do well down there

 

[gallagher]

I remember blake Ferguson leaving cronulla so he could win a comp.
It doesn't always work out that easy.

 

[Masterton]

As someone who was pretty disappointed when Addo Carr left, I'm now feeling a little more confident that the club knew what it was doing after Suli's debut.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

As someone who was pretty disappointed when Addo Carr left, I'm now feeling a little more confident that the club knew what it was doing after Suli's debut.

JAC is freakish and will be exceptional, but Suli seems to have the more solid overall game of the two.

 

[851]

As someone who was pretty disappointed when Addo Carr left, I'm now feeling a little more confident that the club knew what it was doing after Suli's debut.

Why couldn't we have both, Suli will likely move in to the centres.

 

[gallagher]

As someone who was pretty disappointed when Addo Carr left, I'm now feeling a little more confident that the club knew what it was doing after Suli's debut.

Why couldn't we have both, Suli will likely move in to the centres.

And boot Kev.
I'd rather have kept him too

 

[Masterton]

As someone who was pretty disappointed when Addo Carr left, I'm now feeling a little more confident that the club knew what it was doing after Suli's debut.

Why couldn't we have both, Suli will likely move in to the centres.

And boot Kev.
I'd rather have kept him too

Yep, that would be the best result, but we already tried to boot Kev and failed.

 

[gallagher]

As someone who was pretty disappointed when Addo Carr left, I'm now feeling a little more confident that the club knew what it was doing after Suli's debut.

Why couldn't we have both, Suli will likely move in to the centres.

And boot Kev.
I'd rather have kept him too

Yep, that would be the best result, but we already tried to boot Kev and failed.

Boot him to reserves. He's just terrible.

 

[Flippedy]

As someone who was pretty disappointed when Addo Carr left, I'm now feeling a little more confident that the club knew what it was doing after Suli's debut.

Why couldn't we have both, Suli will likely move in to the centres.

Same here, Masterton! I was filthy when JAC was let go and we were left with Rankin, but Suli has come out of nowhere and, if last night is any indication, he is gonna be real good.

Agree 851 having both would've been awesome 😛ray:

 

[Guest]

As someone who was pretty disappointed when Addo Carr left, I'm now feeling a little more confident that the club knew what it was doing after Suli's debut.

Ideally I would have liked JAC on the wing and Suli in the centres. JAC played very well for the Storm yesterday and will go well this year.