Alex Seyfarth #232

BAGNF05 said:
How would you best utilise two very similar smaller forwards who lack any leg speed?
Click to expand...
Can we get forwards on the same coin that will do a better job? That's the question you need to ask. A team fall of superstars won't fit in the salary cap.
 
I can understand supporters feeling underwhelmed with Twal and Seyfarth extending.I thought Twal was our best foward towards the end of the season,also Seyfarth looked like a first grader when given the opportunity this season.
Not saying these Lads are elite,game breakers ,but both can be pretty solid role players.
Having players wanting to stay is really refreshing.A crucial part of success is cohesion,something we’ve lacked for over a decade.
 
Sausagesorcerer said:
I can understand supporters feeling underwhelmed with Twal and Seyfarth extending.I thought Twal was our best foward towards the end of the season,also Seyfarth looked like a first grader when given the opportunity this season.
Not saying these Lads are elite,game breakers ,but both can be pretty solid role players.
Having players wanting to stay is really refreshing.A crucial part of success is cohesion,something we’ve lacked for over a decade.
Click to expand...
One can make the argument that it’s these kinds of players that are holding us back. I suppose you can argue that Twal offers something, but the fact he received no interest when told he was free to leave is telling. As for Seyfarth, he’s the kind of player who could only have a career at a club that’s bottom of the table.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
One can make the argument that it’s these kinds of players that are holding us back. I suppose you can argue that Twal offers something, but the fact he received no interest when told he was free to leave is telling. As for Seyfarth, he’s the kind of player who could only have a career at a club that’s bottom of the table.
Click to expand...

I disagree. I think these players can be the players who make your squad because they allow you to sign other players on more dollars and these guys will deliver value on the park.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
One can make the argument that it’s these kinds of players that are holding us back. I suppose you can argue that Twal offers something, but the fact he received no interest when told he was free to leave is telling. As for Seyfarth, he’s the kind of player who could only have a career at a club that’s bottom of the table.
Click to expand...
I’m more of the opinion that our lack of outside backs and established halves are holding us back .
 
earl said:
I disagree. I think these players can be the players who make your squad because they allow you to sign other players on more dollars and these guys will deliver value on the park.
Click to expand...
If we had a stronger squad Id agree. But outside of Bula, Api and Ice, our squad are full of Seyfarth types.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
If we had a stronger squad Id agree. But outside of Bula, Api and Ice, our squad are full of Seyfarth types.
Click to expand...

We need some class players. My take is we will only get those players via developing them. There will be plenty of spots available over the next couple of seasons. We just have to hope we actually develop some quality players.
 
earl said:
We need some class players. My take is we will only get those players via developing them. There will be plenty of spots available over the next couple of seasons. We just have to hope we actually develop some quality players.
Click to expand...
Nothing short of a Penrith style development program is good enough at this point. There should be no excuses with the catchment area we have and the supposed millionaires that back the club.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Nothing short of a Penrith style development program is good enough at this point. There should be no excuses with the catchment area we have and the supposed millionaires that back the club.
Click to expand...

We might not get that lucky but hopefully we do see some big improvements.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
If we had a stronger squad Id agree. But outside of Bula, Api and Ice, our squad are full of Seyfarth types.
Click to expand...
I could make the argument that both Twal and Seyfarth add just as much as Bateman and Klemmer.
Twal is paid about half their wages and Seyfarth about a third of their wages, who is providing the better value for money ?
 
GNR4LIFE said:
One can make the argument that it’s these kinds of players that are holding us back. I suppose you can argue that Twal offers something, but the fact he received no interest when told he was free to leave is telling. As for Seyfarth, he’s the kind of player who could only have a career at a club that’s bottom of the table.
Click to expand...
Twal was given permission to test the market given his current price tag of $525k. He received interest from both the Bulldogs and Manly, both long term deals, but at significantly reduced rates. Twal chose to extend at a reported $400k. Seyfarth was also rumoured to have held discussions with the Bulldogs. Both wanted to stay, both are very passionate about the Tigers, both are hard workers and have great work ethic, and both were retained, at the right price.
 
jmello said:
Twal was given permission to test the market given his current price tag of $525k. He received interest from both the Bulldogs and Manly, both long term deals, but at significantly reduced rates. Twal chose to extend at a reported $400k. Seyfarth was also rumoured to have held discussions with the Bulldogs. Both wanted to stay, both are very passionate about the Tigers, both are hard workers and have great work ethic, and both were retained, at the right price.
Click to expand...
I don’t think some understand the importance of heart & soul players like these two.
Anyone watching surely agrees they were 2 of our best performed forwards over the back end of the 2023 season, not sure what more can be expected of them ?
 
Sausagesorcerer said:
I can understand supporters feeling underwhelmed with Twal and Seyfarth extending.I thought Twal was our best foward towards the end of the season,also Seyfarth looked like a first grader when given the opportunity this season.
Not saying these Lads are elite,game breakers ,but both can be pretty solid role players.
Having players wanting to stay is really refreshing.A crucial part of success is cohesion,something we’ve lacked for over a decade.
Click to expand...
When you are 20 points in front with 15 min. to go they come in handy for Tigers to hang in there!
 
GNR4LIFE said:
One can make the argument that it’s these kinds of players that are holding us back. I suppose you can argue that Twal offers something, but the fact he received no interest when told he was free to leave is telling. As for Seyfarth, he’s the kind of player who could only have a career at a club that’s bottom of the table.
Click to expand...
Yes. We have extended the contracts of the plod brothers.
 
One thing about twal and seyfarth contracts is they are deemed to be of better value to the club than before. Wonder if this is Fulton doing or that the club is in a better position to bargain even though we just received a second spoon
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,304 (members: 3, guests: 1,301)
Back
Top