Chammas Article

Why do you not want them to sell?

Do you think the people who own this club are capable of making it a successful one?
I am not convinced the HBG use their power to over rule the football department aka Richo near as often as what many people seem to believe.
It’s convenient to blame others other than those making the decisions when things go wrong.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BZN
Doesn't seem to be the case for young guys at many other clubs.

I think it is more of an us thing than a "those dang kids" thing Hal.
Yes and no, PD( interesting handle).
I understand what your saying about our players but I think there’s been enough movement in other clubs to say it’s a trend. Just not at the same level of hype and money.
 
I am not convinced the HBG use their power to over rule the football department aka Richo near as often as what many people seem to believe.
It’s convenient to blame others other than those making the decisions when things go wrong.
I am not implying they do. But it is an interesting argument to delegate blame lower than where the buck ultimately stops when we have rotated through 6 coaches and 4 CEOs since we last made the finals.

But they don't have to in order for them to wear blame.

If I worked for a company and discovered the owner was a dribbling idiot that consistently makes dumb decisions and verifiably has no idea how to operate the company properly my morale would be effected. I would expect many others would too. Performance is affected by many things but not having alignment with your ultimate owner is one of the biggest.

Compare how Wests Tigers football staff, coaches and players would view "The Holman Barnes Group" compared to how other clubs football departments view their owners. How does Politis treat his players, or even Crowe? How do you think the Broncos are treated by the owners of the team?

Not only are hey demonstrably incapable of operating it well, they appear to have no real interest in it either. The HBG are more interested in meat raffles and upgrading the seating at the bistro than the success of the NRL franchise they own. Google Holman Barnes Group annual report and read it for yourself.

Think about what the independent review into the HBG actually determined. They advised the HBG to appoint an independent board to operate the Wests Tigers. They essentially said "you are the problem".

The HBG then installed a chair that already had history here and of the 3 tie breaking independent members the recruitment firm was supposed to have appointed one was the CEO of a club sponsor.
 
I am not implying they do. But it is an interesting argument to delegate blame lower than where the buck ultimately stops when we have rotated through 6 coaches and 4 CEOs since we last made the finals.

But they don't have to in order for them to wear blame.

If I worked for a company and discovered the owner was a dribbling idiot that consistently makes dumb decisions and verifiably has no idea how to operate the company properly my morale would be effected. I would expect many others would too. Performance is affected by many things but not having alignment with your ultimate owner is one of the biggest.

Compare how Wests Tigers football staff, coaches and players would view "The Holman Barnes Group" compared to how other clubs football departments view their owners. How does Politis treat his players, or even Crowe? How do you think the Broncos are treated by the owners of the team?

Not only are hey demonstrably incapable of operating it well, they appear to have no real interest in it either. The HBG are more interested in meat raffles and upgrading the seating at the bistro than the success of the NRL franchise they own. Google Holman Barnes Group annual report and read it for yourself.

Think about what the independent review into the HBG actually determined. They advised the HBG to appoint an independent board to operate the Wests Tigers. They essentially said "you are the problem".

The HBG then installed a chair that already had history here and of the 3 tie breaking independent members the recruitment firm was supposed to have appointed one was the CEO of a club sponsor.
Your views are shared by many.
I see it differently, I don’t think most of our players have any interest in who owns the club and probably don’t even know who our board members are.
All they care about is collecting their monthly pay cheques and know they answer to Benji and Richo.
Richo has the power to sack Benji or any of our coaching staff and has the power to try and retain or recruit any players he wants.
I realise Richo has plenty of knowledge and experience in running NRL clubs so we have to trust he has us heading in the right direction, but he was happy to take the big money, chose to do 3 roles and therefore the buck stops with him.
 
I think, as solely a Wests Tigers supporter, with no affiliation to either merger club, that all the infighting and moaning that still goes on, in our 26th season as Wests Tigers, is the reason we are the bread and butter clickbait. Nothing easier to attack than an acrimonious union.
You're a much more learned person than I am with you being a schoolteacher and me having been just a poorly paid [for the responsibility we have] bus driver.
Tell us your thoughts about how we go about fixing the very obvious acrimonious union
Suzie-Q:
 
Your views are shared by many.
I see it differently, I don’t think most of our players have any interest in who owns the club and probably don’t even know who our board members are.
All they care about is collecting their monthly pay cheques and know they answer to Benji and Richo.
Richo has the power to sack Benji or any of our coaching staff and has the power to try and retain or recruit any players he wants.
I realise Richo has plenty of knowledge and experience in running NRL clubs so we have to trust he has us heading in the right direction, but he was happy to take the big money, chose to do 3 roles and therefore the buck stops with him.

Even if you are right do you think that the players are the only people whose performances would be negatively affected by club owners?

Take for example coaches? Or CEOs?

If their performance was negatively affected by the quality of the owners would that not have an impact on the football team results?

You can say the buck stops with Richo and it does to a degree as he is the appointed CEO but the truth is he is an old unwell man with mixed priorities at this point in his life. Who is holding him accountable to be the best version of himself if not the owners?
 
Again, the question is why. Sources at the Tigers, talking on the condition of anonymity, say Richardson had wanted to prioritise keeping future star Da Silva at the club. Benji Marshall, however, favoured Koroisau, and Richardson let his coach have his way.
A similar thing happened in the off-season, when Richardson’s preference was to bring in Paul McGregor in as an assistant coach.
Marshall, however, wanted 2005 premiership-winning teammate Brett Hodgson to partner fellow ex-teammates John Morris and Chris Heighington on the coaching staff following the departure of another former teammate, Robbie Farah.
The coach won that battle, too.
What the actual!
 
BHG needs to stand up and put their hand in their pocket
Yes that is correct.

They also need to actually commercialise the JV properly and intelligently.

NRL teams are extremely valuable media brands and it would be easy to build diversified revenue streams with them in today's economy. Content is king and the Wests Tigers are the NRL's most valuable content brand for better or worse.

Rather than thinking backwards and trying to convince small business to shell out for corporate hospitality packages and shirt sponsorships they should be expanding the content they have shown they are pretty good at and using the eyeballs they get on their content to drive advertising. Smart advertisers recognise the value of that type of marketing is far greater than logos on signs and jerseys because its measurable. Powerhouse online media buying brands like Pilot etc. would pay very good money for media partnership if the Tigers simply asked. Brands like that buy up media space like its the last loaf of bread.

How we managed to only have a low rent pro wrestling company as the primary podcast sponsor is a total indictment on the commercial operators at the club. They are talking to the wrong buyers.

Hell you could make a pretty hilarious media partnership with Pilot I am sure. Help the Tigers rise up the ladder with Pilot.

Have that one for free Tigers.
 
I am not implying they do. But it is an interesting argument to delegate blame lower than where the buck ultimately stops when we have rotated through 6 coaches and 4 CEOs since we last made the finals.

But they don't have to in order for them to wear blame.

If I worked for a company and discovered the owner was a dribbling idiot that consistently makes dumb decisions and verifiably has no idea how to operate the company properly my morale would be effected. I would expect many others would too. Performance is affected by many things but not having alignment with your ultimate owner is one of the biggest.

Compare how Wests Tigers football staff, coaches and players would view "The Holman Barnes Group" compared to how other clubs football departments view their owners. How does Politis treat his players, or even Crowe? How do you think the Broncos are treated by the owners of the team?

Not only are hey demonstrably incapable of operating it well, they appear to have no real interest in it either. The HBG are more interested in meat raffles and upgrading the seating at the bistro than the success of the NRL franchise they own. Google Holman Barnes Group annual report and read it for yourself.

Think about what the independent review into the HBG actually determined. They advised the HBG to appoint an independent board to operate the Wests Tigers. They essentially said "you are the problem".

The HBG then installed a chair that already had history here and of the 3 tie breaking independent members the recruitment firm was supposed to have appointed one was the CEO of a club sponsor.
They only have 2 seats on the board now, and I just read the other day , that’s the wests rep is n ex player who wasn’t apart of the bullshit shenanigans that went on last year re. Julie and her coup , only to get stabbed by Denny boy and his coup on the coup . He’s still on the board though … unfortunately.
They haven’t made a single decision yet . The proof will be when / if they replace benji and richo in the coming years . We will know then if we have made the right decisions .
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top