Farah/Taylor Thread...

Compare Robbie's comments to ET's comments about Griffen. ET comes out and says how much he liked playing at Penrith and how much he learnt and makes his leaving Penrith all about him wanting to play first grade.

I do think JT really cocked this up though. I suppose it was made worse because Robbie is an egotistical twat. I'd love to see them both leave the club but lately JT has been handling himself better than Roobie.
 
"Sorry, mate. I don't want to dwell on the past. I'm just focussed on winning for Wests Tigers & NSW and playing my best."

-what Robbie should have said.
 
@supercoach said:
To be honest he has a good reason to have a chip on his shoulder, he signed a contract in good faith that the club offered him and than they try and force him out the door. In saying that, there is a time and place to air your dirty washing and now is not the right time. Farah should keep all his emotions for his book when he leaves the club when ever that might be
Click to expand...

Yeah well he signed that contract knowing there was a risk that such a situation would materialise as he's acknowledged. He signed it knowing that, whatever happened to the team, he was going to be getting paid a mint. When he was in negotiations he (via Ayoub) did everything he could to drive his price up. There was talk at one point that he was out the door to Parramatta. So he gouged the maximum he could out of the club. Now he was perfectly entitled to do that, but it doesn't mark him as a selfless club man who is prepared to put the interests of the team ahead of himself. A contract of that magnitude at his age was always going to create salary cap dramas.
 
Tigertigertiger - You obviously didn't watch Ballin in last nights game, and Steve - assume we are talking about Farah - JT is not a Moron. He had his own reasons for wanting to sack Farah - he was forced to apologise in front of the whole team (his reasons have been proven correct), and he has not dragged this up in ensuing articles, nether has the club - that is because he has class.

Farah says he loves the Wests Tigers but continually puts them in a bad light - something that you would not do if you loved something/someone. The only thing I can see now is a former football legend that is tarnishing his own reputation unfortunately because he loves himself more than something/someone else.

The "Class" I spoke of, is something that Farah can only aspire to - he hasn't got it and will never have it.

It is a real pity, he was a great bloke, a good player and a club legend that is destroying himself with self interest.
 
**"I can't even start to tell you about the support I had: from my teammates, ex-teammates, staff, players from other clubs, just walking down the street and hearing it from fans from other clubs. People saying, 'We don't support the Tigers but what's being done to you is crap'. It felt like I wasn't just fighting a battle for myself, but fighting a battle for everyone else because everyone kind of felt like it was morally wrong what was happening."**

This really got to me, doesn't mention even once about the fans at the club which cheer for him every time he runs out on that field. But then goes on to mention that fans from other clubs even approached him that's a big kick in the balls from our perspectives.

I still have respect for Robbie and he will forever be known as a club legend but it's time Robbie, for a player to obviously imo consider origin as more important than playing for Wests Tigers is idiotic and it's time for you to go.

Have fun in England, Ballin and Liddle will do the job you couldn't do!
 
@Russell said:
Tigertigertiger - You obviously didn't watch Ballin in last nights game, and Steve - assume we are talking about Farah - JT is not a Moron. He had his own reasons for wanting to sack Farah - he was forced to apologise in front of the whole team (his reasons have been proven correct), and he has not dragged this up in ensuing articles, nether has the club - that is because he has class.

Farah says he loves the Wests Tigers but continually puts them in a bad light - something that you would not do if you loved something/someone. The only thing I can see now is a former football legend that is tarnishing his own reputation unfortunately because he loves himself more than something/someone else.

The "Class" I spoke of, is something that Farah can only aspire to - he hasn't got it and will never have it.

It is a real pity, he was a great bloke, a good player and a club legend that is destroying himself with self interest.
Click to expand...

JT stuffed up the Farah situation. He handled it terribly. He is a moron for how he handled that situation. He was also a complete moron last season with his comments regarding the previous players/coaches etc at the club. He handled himself with no class whatsoever. He has improved this season but it is off a low low base.

My feelings on Robbie are pretty obvious in this thread. For years I haven't rated him highly. I've seen him hog it and stuff up critical plays on too many occasions.

At the moment though I still think Robbie is a better player than Ballin and it's not close.

If I was JT I would be picking the best team which has to include Robbie.

It shouldn't be a Robbie vs JT thing which is what I think a lot of people do. That is dumb. Judge them both on how they act and perform.
 
@teddy23 said:
**"I can't even start to tell you about the support I had: from my teammates, ex-teammates, staff, players from other clubs, just walking down the street and hearing it from fans from other clubs. People saying, 'We don't support the Tigers but what's being done to you is crap'. It felt like I wasn't just fighting a battle for myself, but fighting a battle for everyone else because everyone kind of felt like it was morally wrong what was happening."**

This really got to me, doesn't mention even once about the fans at the club which cheer for him every time he runs out on that field. But then goes on to mention that fans from other clubs even approached him that's a big kick in the balls from our perspectives.

I still have respect for Robbie and he will forever be known as a club legend but it's time Robbie, for a player to obviously imo consider origin as more important than playing for Wests Tigers is idiotic and it's time for you to go.

Have fun in England, Ballin and Liddle will do the job you couldn't do!
Click to expand...

He won't go next year though. I'd love him too but I can't see it happening. We signed him up. We should get the most possible value out of him.
 
Totally without class. On and of the field.
He is daring Taylor to dump him to reserves.i hope he's accommodated.
 
@stevetiger said:
@Russell said:
Tigertigertiger - You obviously didn't watch Ballin in last nights game, and Steve - assume we are talking about Farah - JT is not a Moron. He had his own reasons for wanting to sack Farah - he was forced to apologise in front of the whole team (his reasons have been proven correct), and he has not dragged this up in ensuing articles, nether has the club - that is because he has class.

Farah says he loves the Wests Tigers but continually puts them in a bad light - something that you would not do if you loved something/someone. The only thing I can see now is a former football legend that is tarnishing his own reputation unfortunately because he loves himself more than something/someone else.

The "Class" I spoke of, is something that Farah can only aspire to - he hasn't got it and will never have it.

It is a real pity, he was a great bloke, a good player and a club legend that is destroying himself with self interest.

JT stuffed up the Farah situation. He handled it terribly. He is a moron for how he handled that situation. He was also a complete moron last season with his comments regarding the previous players/coaches etc at the club. He handled himself with no class whatsoever. He has improved this season but it is off a low low base.

My feelings on Robbie are pretty obvious in this thread. For years I haven't rated him highly. I've seen him hog it and stuff up critical plays on too many occasions.

At the moment though I still think Robbie is a better player than Ballin and it's not close.

If I was JT I would be picking the best team which has to include Robbie.

It shouldn't be a Robbie vs JT thing which is what I think a lot of people do. That is dumb. Judge them both on how they act and perform.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

I actually totally disagree with you. but that is ok - it is our individual opinions.

I think it is the club that handled it badly - imo JT did what the board, the CEO and himself wanted - as it started to go bad - JT was hung out to dry. In a way I guess that does make him a moron for trusting them. However he took it on the chin and he has my respect.
 
@Russell said:
@stevetiger said:
@Russell said:
Tigertigertiger - You obviously didn't watch Ballin in last nights game, and Steve - assume we are talking about Farah - JT is not a Moron. He had his own reasons for wanting to sack Farah - he was forced to apologise in front of the whole team (his reasons have been proven correct), and he has not dragged this up in ensuing articles, nether has the club - that is because he has class.

Farah says he loves the Wests Tigers but continually puts them in a bad light - something that you would not do if you loved something/someone. The only thing I can see now is a former football legend that is tarnishing his own reputation unfortunately because he loves himself more than something/someone else.

The "Class" I spoke of, is something that Farah can only aspire to - he hasn't got it and will never have it.

It is a real pity, he was a great bloke, a good player and a club legend that is destroying himself with self interest.

JT stuffed up the Farah situation. He handled it terribly. He is a moron for how he handled that situation. He was also a complete moron last season with his comments regarding the previous players/coaches etc at the club. He handled himself with no class whatsoever. He has improved this season but it is off a low low base.

My feelings on Robbie are pretty obvious in this thread. For years I haven't rated him highly. I've seen him hog it and stuff up critical plays on too many occasions.

At the moment though I still think Robbie is a better player than Ballin and it's not close.

If I was JT I would be picking the best team which has to include Robbie.

It shouldn't be a Robbie vs JT thing which is what I think a lot of people do. That is dumb. Judge them both on how they act and perform.

I actually totally disagree with you. but that is ok - it is our individual opinions.

I think it is the club that handled it badly - imo JT did what the board, the CEO and himself wanted - as it started to go bad - JT was hung out to dry. In a way I guess that does make him a moron for trusting them. However he took it on the chin and he has my respect.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

IMO what made JT look like a Moron was…....that if JT had the backing of the Club to oust Farah ? The board should of had the funds to pay out Farah if he refused to do what JT said , that is where JT was let down and was forced to back track and apologize for something he felt had the best interest of the Club moving forward.
So he had the backing of the Club but got embarrassed cause the Club didn't back him and pay Farah out if worst case scenario was to happen.
 
From 2003 to 2009 I had a man crush on Robbie. From 09 I was ambivalent as I would often the good things outweighed by selfish or stupid things but i still woudnt have swapped him for any other number 9.

Now I pretty much cant stand the guy. The ego, the selfishness, the self-delusion. Everything his about him and woe if any coach tries to change things in a way thay Robbie doesnt agree.

Whether you agree with JT or not, as coach he was and is entitled to say that he would like to move in new direction. To carry on like he slept with your sister is just downright crazy.
 
@Russell said:
Tigertigertiger - You obviously didn't watch Ballin in last nights game, and Steve - assume we are talking about Farah - JT is not a Moron. He had his own reasons for wanting to sack Farah - he was forced to apologise in front of the whole team (his reasons have been proven correct), and he has not dragged this up in ensuing articles, nether has the club - that is because he has class.

Farah says he loves the Wests Tigers but continually puts them in a bad light - something that you would not do if you loved something/someone. The only thing I can see now is a former football legend that is tarnishing his own reputation unfortunately because he loves himself more than something/someone else.

The "Class" I spoke of, is something that Farah can only aspire to - he hasn't got it and will never have it.

It is a real pity, he was a great bloke, a good player and a club legend that is destroying himself with self interest.
Click to expand...

You summed it up very well mate. For people to have a go at JT for wanting to make changes and trying to do behind the scenes, before RF and his manager decided to use the media to their advantage, is a disgrace.

I hope he never plays for the Tigers again. I have never booed a Wests Tigers player but I am reconsidering this position when it comes to RF. Calling him a dog does a disservice to canines.
 
Robbie Farah lost any ounce of credibility when my kids (4&6 year olds) approached him to say hi and he looked at them and ran the other way. Scared of kids or to cool for school I would say the latter. Oh by the way he was captain at the, time potter was coach who had a chat to them as did Noffa, brooks and Tedesco after a training session. Not hard for them. Too hard for Farah to say hi, i felt it was time to say bye to him then.
 
We are not privy to what really went on in the Farahgate saga a lot of people are judging both Farah and Taylor on what the media told them and from experience most stuff the media churn out on the NRL you can take with a grain of salt.

Okay after Pascoe came into the club and put the Farahgate thing to bed that should have been the end of it as far being out there in the public domain and certainly Pascoe needs to get Farah into his office and laying down the law to him about what is acceptable and what not is acceptable. Other than that I do not see what all the hate for Farah is based on and I do not see what all the hate for Taylor is based on. I am not saying I support either of them but I just do not get all the hate
 
@supercoach said:
We are not privy to what really went on in the Farahgate saga a lot of people are judging both Farah and Taylor on what the media told them and from experience most stuff the media churn out on the NRL you can take with a grain of salt.

Okay after Pascoe came into the club and put the Farahgate thing to bed that should have been the end of it as far being out there in the public domain and certainly Pascoe needs to get Farah into his office and laying down the law to him about what is acceptable and what not is acceptable. Other than that I do not see what all the hate for Farah is based on and I do not see what all the hate for Taylor is based on. I am not saying I support either of them but I just do not get all the hate
Click to expand...

It's not hate, it's just calling someone out for being a dick.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 519 (members: 40, guests: 479)
Back
Top