Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
@ said:The players haven't trained together for at least four weeks! Therefore they almost certainly haven't personally heard from Cleary for four weeks. So how are the players to personally know the latest intentions from Ivan Cleary! He made a statement wwweeks ago that he intends to meet his contract with Wests Tigers for the next two season so why are so many fickle fans, who have no concrete evidence at all, muddying the waters and casting aspersions?
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:When half the forum was blowing up at Ivan Cleary, the other half suggested to calm the farm as we dont know what has happened. i cant believe what Pascoe has said has been so conveniently missed by most on here and swept under the carpet;
**_‘‘ Once he [Ivan Cleary] talked to Penrith, he compromised that and I had to put the Tigers first._**
PASCOE specifically stating that Ivan Cleary comprised his position at the tigers by talking to Penrith. we dont need to guess anymore, we dont need to blame gus or the media that is all out to get us. Its there in black and white. For all those still sticking up for the guy i find it so bewildering. The guy has no integrity , would have walked out on us that week if we let him and people still have their head in the sand. The guy is a fake and should be no where near our team next year.
Missed it by that much. Context is everything. Read it again. In the conversation, Pascoe is referring to his relationship with Cleary when he says "he compromised that". So Pascoe never says Cleary compromised his position at the tigers, even if it does suit certain agendas on this forum.
Exactly NT - context is everything - but take it out of context if it fits your argument.
Where have I taken it out of context?
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:So the fact Brooks and Mbye don't even know who is coaching the team next year sits well with you, well it doesn't sit well with me, that needs in your words, to be addressed :crazy
I thought Cleary was coaching next season have I missed something not heard anything! My read if nothing is stated it is Fake News !
No mate, Brooks when asked last week said he didn't know who was coaching the team next year, Mbye when asked on the weekend said the same thing, that to me is rather disturbing and needs addressing.
I thought Brooks said it would be hard to get behind a coach that signed with another club in 2 years time .i have not heard these quotes if the 2 players quoted that they did not know who the coach was next season that is a worry ..I only have your post to rely on there as I have heard nothing.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Missed it by that much. Context is everything. Read it again. In the conversation, Pascoe is referring to his relationship with Cleary when he says "he compromised that". So Pascoe never says Cleary compromised his position at the tigers, even if it does suit certain agendas on this forum.
Exactly NT - context is everything - but take it out of context if it fits your argument.
Where have I taken it out of context?
Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Missed it by that much. Context is everything. Read it again. In the conversation, Pascoe is referring to his relationship with Cleary when he says "he compromised that". So Pascoe never says Cleary compromised his position at the tigers, even if it does suit certain agendas on this forum.
Exactly NT - context is everything - but take it out of context if it fits your argument.
Where have I taken it out of context?
Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:I thought Cleary was coaching next season have I missed something not heard anything! My read if nothing is stated it is Fake News !
**No mate, Brooks when asked last week said he didn't know who was coaching the team _<big>next year</big>_**, Mbye when asked on the weekend said the same thing, that to me is rather disturbing and needs addressing.
I thought Brooks said it would be hard to get behind a coach that signed with another club in 2 years time .i have not heard these quotes if the 2 players quoted that they did not know who the coach was next season that is a worry ..I only have your post to rely on there as I have heard nothing.
https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl-premiership/luke-brooks-says-it-would-be-hard-to-play-under-ivan-cleary-if-he-signs-for-panthers-from-2021/news-story/2801cfbfbba7ccc27aa81b02ced48a9e
“It’s a tough one. **I think it could be difficult if we knew that a coach is already going _<big>two years down the track,</big>_”** Brooks told NRL Tonight.
“We don’t know if it’s going to happen but if it does we will worry about it when it gets to that point.”
If there was no doubt Cleary was staying, Brooks would have said Ivan told us he is coaching here for the next 2 years, but he never once said anything like we know what is happening, or anything like that.
As for Mbye, another forum member asked him on the weekend who was coaching next year, he replied he didn't know.
If you go back a few pages in this thread you will find it mate.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Youre concerned?
Signings made months apart, with an apparent view im assuming to Cleary taking them to Penrith with him in two years time…all designed to fit the balance of that squad and their cap without knowing who is recruited, released & retired in the meantime???
That would be some feat!
\
\
:deadhorse:
Another day trolling the net hey ink?
Rex, He doesn’t need to take players to Penrith,
They keep churning good players out of their system every year , there’s not too many spots open in
Their team and their Developement pathways
I didn’t say he was GT ,was another poster
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:So speaking to the Panthers only compromised their personal relationship? that makes no sense. Why would he need to put the tigers first if the tigers werent compromised. Thats Pascoes own words. The whole world has an agenda against Cleary lol. Its so obvious he is only here because legally he has to be. Why would we want to have someone coach us like that.
**_‘‘It’s the Wests Tigers before our friendship,’’ Pascoe said. ‘‘Yeah we have a close relationship, but we need to be pragmatic and professional. Once he [Ivan Cleary] talked to Penrith, he compromised that and I had to put the Tigers first._**
You don't need to quote it again, I know what it says and what it means.
Ivan Cleary talked to Penrith the exact content of which I don't know. Something in the circumstances of Ivan talking to Penrith, compromised his close relationship with Pascoe.
Pascoe has put the Tigers first, presumably by making it clear to Ivan that there was no chance of a release from his contract.
Hmmmm, Oh I get it, putting the WT first must mean Pascoe thinks that making Ivan stay to the completion of his contract is what he thinks is best for the Wests Tigers. This is so, even though his relationship with Ivan has been compromised.
Ok I'll go with that.
So you just agreed that a) Ivan met with Penrith and b) their friendship (therefore the tigers) was compromised by most likely as you stated him asking for a release. Well that’s what im saying…..
You confused me with your second part of your argument. So can’t really respond to it.
Yes, surprise, surprise, I agreed that (according to media reports) a) Ivan met with the Panthers. He openly admitted as much. Major scoop there.
The next bit b) is where either your comprehension drops off, or your agenda kicks in, or both.
Justin Pascoe makes a clear distinction between his friendship with Ivan and his professional relationship with him through the WT. You cannot simply assume that because Justin Pascoe says his personal relationship with Ivan was compromised, he also means that Ivan's professional relationship was compromised. That's not what Pascoe said. So no I don't agree with your grand assumption there.
I did not state anywhere, anything about "him asking for a release". Another of your assumptions. Remember, Pascoe has said publicly that Ivan has not yet asked for a release.
As for the last bit that you found confusing, I'm not surprised. You seem to be pretty confused about the whole thing in general. But don't let that get in the way of your agenda.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Exactly NT - context is everything - but take it out of context if it fits your argument.
Where have I taken it out of context?
Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
What are you both on about. So let’s get this straight. Cleary compromised his personal relationship with Pascoe and Pascoe felt the need to let us know about it. He also felt the need to separate his friendship with Cleary in dealing with him meeting up with one of our competitors. But this meeting didnt have any affect or compromise his position as the tigers coach. Or lead to a legal letter being sent to the panthers. Not hereSay anymore it’s all out in the open. My ten year old gets it.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Where have I taken it out of context?
Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
What are you both on about. So let’s get this straight. Cleary compromised his personal relationship with Pascoe and Pascoe felt the need to let us know about it. He also felt the need to separate his friendship with Cleary in dealing with him meeting up with one of our competitors. But this meeting didnt have any affect or compromise his position as the tigers coach. Or lead to a legal letter being sent to the panthers. Not hereSay anymore it’s all out in the open. My ten year old gets it.
I am reasonably certain that if Justin Pascoe and/or Marina Go thought that Ivan Cleary had compromised his (Ivan's)position as coach or his professional relationship with the Wests Tigers Management or the playing group by talking with Penrith, the Wests Tigers Management would have undertaken legal action against him, as they said they would. Far from that, they have done what they can to ensure that Ivan Cleary will be here to coach the Wests Tigers until the end of his contract. From where I stand, that is an endorsement.
So presumably you know more. What exactly makes you so sure that Ivan Cleary's tenure is compromised?
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
What are you both on about. So let’s get this straight. Cleary compromised his personal relationship with Pascoe and Pascoe felt the need to let us know about it. He also felt the need to separate his friendship with Cleary in dealing with him meeting up with one of our competitors. But this meeting didnt have any affect or compromise his position as the tigers coach. Or lead to a legal letter being sent to the panthers. Not hereSay anymore it’s all out in the open. My ten year old gets it.
I am reasonably certain that if Justin Pascoe and/or Marina Go thought that Ivan Cleary had compromised his (Ivan's)position as coach or his professional relationship with the Wests Tigers Management or the playing group by talking with Penrith, the Wests Tigers Management would have undertaken legal action against him, as they said they would. Far from that, they have done what they can to ensure that Ivan Cleary will be here to coach the Wests Tigers until the end of his contract. From where I stand, that is an endorsement.
So presumably you know more. What exactly makes you so sure that Ivan Cleary's tenure is compromised?
His talking about his friendship and how he believed loyalty was a big part of that. By talking to the Panthers behind Pascoe, Ivan has broken that bond, so now it’s business before leisure.
Ivan has made pascoe wise up to the fact that his relationship in respect to the Tigers needs to remain professional between the two of them.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Missed it by that much. Context is everything. Read it again. In the conversation, Pascoe is referring to his relationship with Cleary when he says "he compromised that". So Pascoe never says Cleary compromised his position at the tigers, even if it does suit certain agendas on this forum.
Exactly NT - context is everything - but take it out of context if it fits your argument.
Where have I taken it out of context?
Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Exactly NT - context is everything - but take it out of context if it fits your argument.
Where have I taken it out of context?
Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
What are you both on about. So let’s get this straight. Cleary compromised his personal relationship with Pascoe and Pascoe felt the need to let us know about it. He also felt the need to separate his friendship with Cleary in dealing with him meeting up with one of our competitors. But this meeting didnt have any affect or compromise his position as the tigers coach. Or lead to a legal letter being sent to the panthers. Not hereSay anymore it’s all out in the open. My ten year old gets it.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Where have I taken it out of context?
Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
What are you both on about. So let’s get this straight. Cleary compromised his personal relationship with Pascoe and Pascoe felt the need to let us know about it. He also felt the need to separate his friendship with Cleary in dealing with him meeting up with one of our competitors. But this meeting didnt have any affect or compromise his position as the tigers coach. Or lead to a legal letter being sent to the panthers. Not hereSay anymore it’s all out in the open. My ten year old gets it.
I'm not as vehement on the issue in general as you, but it ceased being hearsay on that first Saturday when Cleary confirmed he had discussionS with the Panthers boss, not just the initial one that wasn't supposed to be about him.
Some are just digging in their heels, despite the facts being established long ago. That said, maybe Ivan was only talking to Pascoe about leaving early to take the new twiddlywinks flipping girls team coaching position at the foot of the mountains and they won't release him, even if he asks really nicely.
@ said:How about we let Ivan leave now with Reynolds and we get Maloney.
@ said:@ said:@ said:@ said:Where have I taken it out of context?
Lol - you haven't NT - Tigerpower did.
I was agreeing with you.
What are you both on about. So let’s get this straight. Cleary compromised his personal relationship with Pascoe and Pascoe felt the need to let us know about it. He also felt the need to separate his friendship with Cleary in dealing with him meeting up with one of our competitors. But this meeting didnt have any affect or compromise his position as the tigers coach. Or lead to a legal letter being sent to the panthers. Not hereSay anymore it’s all out in the open. My ten year old gets it.
I am reasonably certain that if Justin Pascoe and/or Marina Go thought that Ivan Cleary had compromised his (Ivan's)position as coach or his professional relationship with the Wests Tigers Management or the playing group by talking with Penrith, the Wests Tigers Management would have undertaken legal action against him, as they said they would. Far from that, they have done what they can to ensure that Ivan Cleary will be here to coach the Wests Tigers until the end of his contract. From where I stand, that is an endorsement.
So presumably you know more. What exactly makes you so sure that Ivan Cleary's tenure is compromised?