Luke Brooks - Mega Thread

[batboy]

And I expect to get piled on well and truly for this, (idc I’m fearless) but you could easily make a case that Brooks is better than any of those from 6 down.

I know who I'd be buying....

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

 

Is there a page 2 ? ?

5 of those halves I couldn't argue with....
Interesting the see how Reynolds goes this year, Without all the class around him he's had for his whole career.

7-10 are kidding....

Luke is probably around that group of players realistically.

 

[Demps]

And I expect to get piled on well and truly for this, (idc I’m fearless) but you could easily make a case that Brooks is better than any of those from 6 down.

Bro, Clarkey is a tool.
He has no idea, is a massive fan boy... and hates on us whenever he can.

Deluxe halfwit

 

[Demps]

Surprised he didn't put the Titans #7 as first.

Whoever that is.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

And I expect to get piled on well and truly for this, (idc I’m fearless) but you could easily make a case that Brooks is better than any of those from 6 down.

I know who I'd be buying....

I doubt many would be banging down the door for Townsend or Hunt. We might get the old “they can’t do any worse”. However, that’s more a dig at how bad Brooks is, not an endorsement for how good they are.

 

[The_Patriot]

And I expect to get piled on well and truly for this, (idc I’m fearless) but you could easily make a case that Brooks is better than any of those from 6 down.

Bro, Clarkey is a tool.
He has no idea, is a massive fan boy... and hates on us whenever he can.

Deluxe halfwit

100%

I've pulled him up a few times on his Wests Tigers opinions. This time no comments I'll just wait for the avalanche of Luke Brooks supported to tell him he is wrong.

Or maybe not.

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

Oh never mind...
Saw its a list by well known idiot , Dane Clarke.

He hates the Tigers.

That fool has no idea. Disregard the list completely

 

[The_Patriot]

Personally I think the top 7 are fair. Then it's pure conjecture and bias

 

[isaaktigers]

And I expect to get piled on well and truly for this, (idc I’m fearless) but you could easily make a case that Brooks is better than any of those from 6 down.

Bro, Clarkey is a tool.
He has no idea, is a massive fan boy... and hates on us whenever he can.

Deluxe halfwit

One of the worst.

Honestly a toss of a human.. Someone back in the day that made him a fool was a Wests Tigers supporter and he’s hated us ever since.

 

[Nathser]

Jamal was almost losing his spot to Toby Sexton wasn't he? and Brooks got our player of the year and still didn't crack ol' clarkeys list haha - Go figure.

 

[Geo]

Oh never mind...
Saw its a list by well known idiot , Dane Clarke.

He hates the Tigers.

Clarkey.. is that bloke still alive...

 

[tigerballs]

 

Is there a page 2 ? ?

5 of those halves I couldn't argue with....
Interesting the see how Reynolds goes this year, Without all the class around him he's had for his whole career.

7-10 are kidding....

Broncos will kill it with Reynolds at half. Check their backline...Staggs, Farnworth, Cobbo, Oates, maybe Isaako, plus a good young pack. Top 4.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

 

Is there a page 2 ? ?

5 of those halves I couldn't argue with....
Interesting the see how Reynolds goes this year, Without all the class around him he's had for his whole career.

7-10 are kidding....

Broncos will kill it with Reynolds at half. Check their backline...Staggs, Farnworth, Cobbo, Oates, maybe Isaako, plus a good young pack. Top 4.

You left out the best one. Tesi Niu. I’m not as convinced with them. I think they are a bottom 8 side. I know Reynolds is massive, but the rest of their spine is puss.

 

[tigerballs]

 

Is there a page 2 ? ?

5 of those halves I couldn't argue with....
Interesting the see how Reynolds goes this year, Without all the class around him he's had for his whole career.

7-10 are kidding....

Broncos will kill it with Reynolds at half. Check their backline...Staggs, Farnworth, Cobbo, Oates, maybe Isaako, plus a good young pack. Top 4.

You left out the best one. Tesi Niu. I’m not as convinced with them. I think they are a bottom 8 side. I know Reynolds is massive, but the rest of their spine is puss.

I think Niu is one of those rocks or diamonds. We'll find out this year I think. Could be anything. Hooker is letting them down but Reynolds is confident in a few of the youngsters there.

 

[JC99]

Ben Hunt is getting underrated a bit on here I reckon. Isn't as good as he used to be but he can be a real quality halfback and always plays very well for QLD. Take him over Brooks any day of the week

Brooks is better than Townsend, borderline with Fogarty, not better than Johnson and worse than Moses based on current form. Moses had a good 2021

 

[tigerballs]

Ben Hunt is getting underrated a bit on here I reckon. Isn't as good as he used to be but he can be a real quality halfback and always plays very well for QLD. Take him over Brooks any day of the week

Always rated Hunt. I wish we had him.

 

[JC99]

Ben Hunt is getting underrated a bit on here I reckon. Isn't as good as he used to be but he can be a real quality halfback and always plays very well for QLD. Take him over Brooks any day of the week

Always rated Hunt. I wish we had him.

People still think about his dropped ball in the grand final. Been a good halfback for a while now

 

[tigerballs]

Ben Hunt is getting underrated a bit on here I reckon. Isn't as good as he used to be but he can be a real quality halfback and always plays very well for QLD. Take him over Brooks any day of the week

Always rated Hunt. I wish we had him.

People still think about his dropped ball in the grand final. Been a good halfback for a while now

They remember the dropped ball but not how they got there in the first place.

 

[crazycat]

Tesi Niu

Wait,
You upgrade the back line with "Tesi Niu" when it has Oates, Farnworth, Isakko, etc. Then you still don't rate them with Reynolds at 7 and Staggs at 6 maybe?

I won't rate their first few games. 3 week in, I expect them to be scoring well and 5 weeks to have all the bugs ironed out.

I doubt their forwards except for Payne Haas. That guy is Incredible, leaves me confused why so many other forwards are talked of as Million dollar players yet I would drop 1 mil instantly to have him play here.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Tesi Niu

Wait,
You upgrade the back line with "Tesi Niu" when it has Oates, Farnworth, Isakko, etc. Then you still don't rate them with Reynolds at 7 and Staggs at 6 maybe?

I won't rate their first few games. 3 week in, I expect them to be scoring well and 5 weeks to have all the bugs ironed out.

I doubt their forwards except for Payne Haas. That guy is Incredible, leaves me confused why so many other forwards are talked of as Million dollar players yet I would drop 1 mil instantly to have him play here.

Will Oates even be there? I’m no expert on the Broncos but I thought he was cooked.