tigermac88
New member
@king sirro said:@tigermac88 said:@king sirro said:His defence in 2016 had been oustanding. Very strong on contact. If there is one thing im confident about regarding Luke is that his defence will be as good as Andrew Johns. As for the rest of his game, well i do admit im losing confidence. Im also starting to wonder if Moses is a better player when Luke isnt in the team.
Watch that game again some of Brooks' arm grabbing defence on that edge was nothing short of embarrassing for a 1st grader. I coach local park footballers with better defence than he displayed today
They rolled through us embarrassingly the 2nd half. Everyone was grabbing. Sue got run past by Faifita 3 times. Judge Brooks on defending the egde when his forwards do there job and control the opposition pack. First 3 games he has hit like a truck. His defence im very happy with. Im not happy with his attack. His decision to run it on the last in our 2nd set of the 2nd half was under 6 mistake.
I agree I'm not happy with his attack and his defence has been spot on in the last few games hitting well with his shoulder… The part I can't agree with is arm and shirt grabbing has nothing to do with how the men in the middle are defending whatsoever... Making a choice to arm grab or hit with your shoulder is all about attitude and commitment in defence which he clearly had none of today... Just because you're getting rolled thru the middle doesn't mean Brooks can't hit and stick with a shoulder