Madge Maguire - Mega Thread

[tony soprano]

Just want to know what amazing work Hartigan has carried out since he has been with the club?

Sweet nothing

How can you bag Hartigan, who’s been responsible for the pathways and identification of talent (Laurie, Stef etc) and then strongly defend Madge who has achieved nothing other than make a bad team much much worse?

People like to talk like they know what he does he is redundant.

 

[cochise]

Just want to know what amazing work Hartigan has carried out since he has been with the club?

Sweet nothing

How can you bag Hartigan, who’s been responsible for the pathways and identification of talent (Laurie, Stef etc) and then strongly defend Madge who has achieved nothing other than make a bad team much much worse?

People like to talk like they know what he does he is redundant.

Avo is right

 

[GCfan]

Certainly not against Pascoe moving on(same result etc) but if we think sacking him will do anything for 2022 is laughable.


So what’s the point of sacking him then?
If sacking fixes nothing I don’t get the point

Cause you want to change the next 5 years not the next year. Need to look for coach or players

I still think our bigger issue is weak minded individuals in the team. Much harder to fix though.

 

[BalmainJnr]

Certainly not against Pascoe moving on(same result etc) but if we think sacking him will do anything for 2022 is laughable.


So what’s the point of sacking him then?
If sacking fixes nothing I don’t get the point

Cause you want to change the next 5 years not the next year. Need to look for coach or players

I still think our bigger issue is weak minded individuals in the team. Much harder to fix though.

I would argue that is our identity.

 

[GCfan]

Certainly not against Pascoe moving on(same result etc) but if we think sacking him will do anything for 2022 is laughable.


So what’s the point of sacking him then?
If sacking fixes nothing I don’t get the point

Cause you want to change the next 5 years not the next year. Need to look for coach or players

I still think our bigger issue is weak minded individuals in the team. Much harder to fix though.

I would argue that is our identity.

Yep that would be hard to argue against

 

[weststigerman]

Certainly not against Pascoe moving on(same result etc) but if we think sacking him will do anything for 2022 is laughable.


So what’s the point of sacking him then?
If sacking fixes nothing I don’t get the point

Cause you want to change the next 5 years not the next year. Need to look for coach or players

I still think our bigger issue is weak minded individuals in the team. Much harder to fix though.

Bingo

 

[Aesopian]

Punt someone

 

[frullens]

Certainly not against Pascoe moving on(same result etc) but if we think sacking him will do anything for 2022 is laughable.


So what’s the point of sacking him then?
If sacking fixes nothing I don’t get the point

Cause you want to change the next 5 years not the next year. Need to look for coach or players

I still think our bigger issue is weak minded individuals in the team. Much harder to fix though.

Agree - punting madge just awards this mentality.

Madge is just asking the team to do the basics.

Tackle and kick to corners and never give up.
If they can't knuckle down and do that as a professional- move them on

 

[frullens]

Punt someone

Brooks, Nofa & Pascoe

 

[CCWT]

Just want to know what amazing work Hartigan has carried out since he has been with the club?

Sweet nothing

How can you bag Hartigan, who’s been responsible for the pathways and identification of talent (Laurie, Stef etc) and then strongly defend Madge who has achieved nothing other than make a bad team much much worse?

And you know for sure Maguire had nothing at all to do with them?

I judge Madge on his coaching given he’s the coach.

So we should judge Madge on the coaching and Hartigan on recruitment?

 

[WT2K]

Punt the chairman

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Just want to know what amazing work Hartigan has carried out since he has been with the club?

Sweet nothing

We have the best crop of juniors recruited from all parts by Hartigan and his network. Hartigan is a our diamond.

There seems to be considerable obfuscation in terms of the review. Press articles advised it is confined to the Football Dept

 

[avocadoontoast]

Just want to know what amazing work Hartigan has carried out since he has been with the club?

Sweet nothing

How can you bag Hartigan, who’s been responsible for the pathways and identification of talent (Laurie, Stef etc) and then strongly defend Madge who has achieved nothing other than make a bad team much much worse?

And you know for sure Maguire had nothing at all to do with them?

I judge Madge on his coaching given he’s the coach.

So we should judge Madge on the coaching and Hartigan on recruitment?

We should judge Madge on his coaching and Hartigan on developing pathways and talent identification.

 

[Tiger Tarl]

How long left on Madge's contract?
If he gets the flick then we will be paying two coaches, right?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

How long left on Madge's contract?
If he gets the flick then we will be paying two coaches, right?

2 years

 

[GCfan]

Punt the chairman

Punt the fans. We’re all gooses for supporting this rabble when you think about it

 

[Pascoes_barber]

Punt the chairman

Punt the fans. We’re all gooses for supporting this rabble when you think about it

Folding the club would probably be less painful/frustrating overall after the initial shock.

 

[CCWT]

Just want to know what amazing work Hartigan has carried out since he has been with the club?

Sweet nothing

How can you bag Hartigan, who’s been responsible for the pathways and identification of talent (Laurie, Stef etc) and then strongly defend Madge who has achieved nothing other than make a bad team much much worse?

And you know for sure Maguire had nothing at all to do with them?

I judge Madge on his coaching given he’s the coach.

So we should judge Madge on the coaching and Hartigan on recruitment?

We should judge Madge on his coaching and Hartigan on developing pathways and talent identification.

Fair enough, isn’t that going to be Sheens job? I just think Madge and Hartigan are both involved in recruitment so surely he gets some of the blame when we can’t recruit the right players

 

[avocadoontoast]

Just want to know what amazing work Hartigan has carried out since he has been with the club?

Sweet nothing

How can you bag Hartigan, who’s been responsible for the pathways and identification of talent (Laurie, Stef etc) and then strongly defend Madge who has achieved nothing other than make a bad team much much worse?

And you know for sure Maguire had nothing at all to do with them?

I judge Madge on his coaching given he’s the coach.

So we should judge Madge on the coaching and Hartigan on recruitment?

We should judge Madge on his coaching and Hartigan on developing pathways and talent identification.

Fair enough, isn’t that going to be Sheens job? I just think Madge and Hartigan are both involved in recruitment so surely he gets some of the blame when we can’t recruit the right players

Sheens job seems to be changing daily so I’m not sure on that. I think we’ve had trouble getting signings over the line but the identification has been good.

 

[cochise]

Just want to know what amazing work Hartigan has carried out since he has been with the club?

Sweet nothing

How can you bag Hartigan, who’s been responsible for the pathways and identification of talent (Laurie, Stef etc) and then strongly defend Madge who has achieved nothing other than make a bad team much much worse?

And you know for sure Maguire had nothing at all to do with them?

I judge Madge on his coaching given he’s the coach.

So we should judge Madge on the coaching and Hartigan on recruitment?

We should judge Madge on his coaching and Hartigan on developing pathways and talent identification.

Fair enough, isn’t that going to be Sheens job? I just think Madge and Hartigan are both involved in recruitment so surely he gets some of the blame when we can’t recruit the right players

The Flegg side is where it is on the players Hartigan brought to the club, the most promising players in 1st grade, are players Hartigan has brought to the club. The salary cap is in good shape due to Hartigan.