Madge Maguire - Mega Thread

[The_Patriot]

I don't mind the club talking down our chances for 22. Might be a realisation that the coach and playing group cracked under the pressure of the expectations that the tales from tiger town cameras brought to 21.

Much better to fly under the radar this season while having in house expectations to challenge for the 8

 

[Swordy]

I think a lot of people on this forum , have got it all wrong , the board nor the chairman don’t coach the football team , they may be behind us not signing players , but the buck falls at the coaches feet . How can anyone on this forum support Madge when in the last 3 years our defence has gone from bad to out right pathetic, and our attack is nothing to right home about , all year I have sat and watched our defence do the must dum shit , yet it never changes so what the hell is the coach doing , he’s not addressing the situation or the players refuse to listen , then it’s his fault for not dropping them , the job of the coach is to coach and direct the team , and let’s face it , Madge has failed , not to do with the board , that’s not to say there are useless but that another story .

I also think a lot of people have got it wrong too !
Neither the board, the GM or the coach put the jersey on and run onto a playing field and dish up pathetic performances.
I'm pretty sure the coach hasn't missed a single tackle all season.
But you are right about our defence. Yes, it is pathetic. I have done some research and discovered that Madge, the board AND Pascoe haven't missed a single tackle all year. But I have uncovered the culprits. IT'S THE PLAYERS.
They are first grade. They shouldn't need anyone to show them how to tackle.
The ones you watch doing the dumb shit are indeed the ones who take the blame for our "pathetic" defence.

While I agree with you, the club accepts those standards when they don’t act. See what the Roosters do when a player doesn’t measure up? JTJ should be a memory at this club and our second rowers should really be on notice. I suspect we will see the same issues next year and that’s a weakness as we can’t seem to hold players accountable for poor performance.

All of this is true - but some are presuming we have unlimited salary cap and no carry over debt, and top class representative players.

It is the coach's job to coach and improve, correct. But when you walk into a joint that is a basket case, no junior pathways, with millions in wasted and overpaid player debt, and you have the equivalent of 13 Datsun 120Y's at your disposal, what are you supposed to manufacture from that?

Maguire may be good or bad - and history will tell that tale, but there is no doubting he CAN coach, but to lay all the blame at his feet with no context is unfair and unreasonable.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Looks like everyone at the club is aligned

Year 1 assess
Year 2 action
Year 3 Its on like Donkey Kong

Wooden spoon is a real possibility for next season.

 

[Spartan117]

Wooden spoon is a real possibility for next season

If its based on recruitment and injuries, other clubs appear to have done better for 2022.

Its all about attitude of the players to compete in each play.

**We should be looking at becoming hard to beat no matter who is on the team.** That would be a success in my eyes.

 

[The_Patriot]

Wooden spoon is a real possibility for next season

If its based on recruitment and injuries, other clubs appear to have done better for 2022.

Its all about attitude of the players to compete in each play.

**We should be looking at becoming hard to beat no matter who is on the team.** That would be a success in my eyes.

We dont lack talent we lack commitment.

If they fix that no chance in hell we get the spoon.

 

[426Tlgerland]

The key ingredient for us this coming season is starting well , if we can come out and be 3 wins from first 5 games we are holding well , if we come out and get beat 4 out of 5 the players are the ones who start to get a wobble up of hear we go again , it’s critical our coaches get this team on a high in the off season , believe in them selfs , gel amongst all players , enjoy training , that’s Madge and the other new coaches who have joined us job , believe in yourself’s and you can do a hole lot better than just going through the motions , Hastings will be key as well he needs to be a strong leader in he group let Brooks do his job while he takes control control of the team , Our forwards need to stand up and hurt opposition with firm defence and hard running , the addition of the 2 new coaches I think will be a plus , nice fresh input , Gildart will only want to prove he can be in the team that’s a positive same for Hastings and Peach , plus we have some new young guys and they look solid , Blore , And big Stef will go good after last season experience , I’m pretty confident we go ok and jump up to compete for the 8 in season 22 season 2023 let’s just wait til 22 is over ,

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Maguire loves big boppers. He was quoted not long ago when asked who he'd like to sign and he said another quality prop would be good. He also said that 2023 is our year. I know that might be an indemnity type statement but it now seems to be the aim. Have a look at our better young players, they are getting more experience with each game and then you throw in some quality signings, fix up the office and coaching/support staff and things turn around. Apart from Stef's upgrade the signing priority should be the best go forward man available. I got hammered in the Cotric thread by saying 'please no more backs'. I understand people comments and I'm a Cotric fan, but I was trying to say that backs are cheaper and we have a development system for that [hopefully]. There is our recent signings in young Topou and Gildart and also JTJ who could assist [possibly next year a bargain back might become available at the right money] but forwards like Stef plus Paulo or Thompson you can build your club around them and your spine, spend the dosh.

Forwards win games backs determine by how much.
Build the forward pack first, Paulo is a must

 

[Eternal Tiger]

I don't mind the club talking down our chances for 22. Might be a realisation that the coach and playing group cracked under the pressure of the expectations that the tales from tiger town cameras brought to 21.

Much better to fly under the radar this season while having in house expectations to challenge for the 8

Our season was done and dusted before Ep1 even went to air though.

 

[Swordy]

I don't mind the club talking down our chances for 22. Might be a realisation that the coach and playing group cracked under the pressure of the expectations that the tales from tiger town cameras brought to 21.

Much better to fly under the radar this season while having in house expectations to challenge for the 8

Our season was done and dusted before Ep1 even went to air though.

Agreed. I dont think the TV stuff had anything at all to do with performance in any way, shape or form.
But it certainly highlighted the club lacked genuine leaders on and off the field. Which most of us already knew.

 

[KH1988]

I think if we don't make the 8 in 2022 Maguire won't be coach in 2023 based on Sheens interviews.

 

[twentyforty]

The key ingredient for us this coming season is starting well , if we can come out and be 3 wins from first 5 games we are holding well , if we come out and get beat 4 out of 5 the players are the ones who start to get a wobble up of hear we go again , it’s critical our coaches get this team on a high in the off season , believe in them selfs , gel amongst all players , enjoy training , that’s Madge and the other new coaches who have joined us job , believe in yourself’s and you can do a hole lot better than just going through the motions , Hastings will be key as well he needs to be a strong leader in he group let Brooks do his job while he takes control control of the team , Our forwards need to stand up and hurt opposition with firm defence and hard running , the addition of the 2 new coaches I think will be a plus , nice fresh input , Gildart will only want to prove he can be in the team that’s a positive same for Hastings and Peach , plus we have some new young guys and they look solid , Blore , And big Stef will go good after last season experience , I’m pretty confident we go ok and jump up to compete for the 8 in season 22 season 2023 let’s just wait til 22 is over ,

LOL, you could feel the excitement build when Stef gets in the clear ball tucked under the arm and Madge screaming "Go you big bugger!" lol

 

[Tim Sheens]

Maguire loves big boppers. He was quoted not long ago when asked who he'd like to sign and he said another quality prop would be good. He also said that 2023 is our year. I know that might be an indemnity type statement but it now seems to be the aim. Have a look at our better young players, they are getting more experience with each game and then you throw in some quality signings, fix up the office and coaching/support staff and things turn around. Apart from Stef's upgrade the signing priority should be the best go forward man available. I got hammered in the Cotric thread by saying 'please no more backs'. I understand people comments and I'm a Cotric fan, but I was trying to say that backs are cheaper and we have a development system for that [hopefully]. There is our recent signings in young Topou and Gildart and also JTJ who could assist [possibly next year a bargain back might become available at the right money] but forwards like Stef plus Paulo or Thompson you can build your club around them and your spine, spend the dosh.

Forwards win games backs determine by how much.
Build the forward pack first, Paulo is a must

Going to miss his prime as he is likely there atm, though would happily take Joseph playing as a 29yo in 2023 with a couple or few good years left in him.

Much better player than Tamou, but more importantly Paulo won't be arriving as a 32yo player (now 33) loitering around for a final contract pay day.

As for Maguire, whilst I would have shown him the door, am trusting that the changes forced upon him will reap dividends. Especially appointing new assistants in Gardiner and Cayless, who along with Sheens will positively impact the way our squad and particularly their individual talents are utilised.

 

[Cobarcats]

Maguire loves big boppers. He was quoted not long ago when asked who he'd like to sign and he said another quality prop would be good. He also said that 2023 is our year. I know that might be an indemnity type statement but it now seems to be the aim. Have a look at our better young players, they are getting more experience with each game and then you throw in some quality signings, fix up the office and coaching/support staff and things turn around. Apart from Stef's upgrade the signing priority should be the best go forward man available. I got hammered in the Cotric thread by saying 'please no more backs'. I understand people comments and I'm a Cotric fan, but I was trying to say that backs are cheaper and we have a development system for that [hopefully]. There is our recent signings in young Topou and Gildart and also JTJ who could assist [possibly next year a bargain back might become available at the right money] but forwards like Stef plus Paulo or Thompson you can build your club around them and your spine, spend the dosh.

Forwards win games backs determine by how much.
Build the forward pack first, Paulo is a must

Going to miss his prime as he is likely there atm, though would happily take Joseph playing as a 29yo in 2023 with a couple or few good years left in him.

Much better player than Tamou, but more importantly Paulo won't be arriving as a 32yo player (now 33) loitering around for a final contract pay day.

As for Maguire, whilst I would have shown him the door, am trusting that the changes forced upon him will reap dividends. Especially appointing new assistants in Gardiner and Cayless, who along with Sheens will positively impact the way our squad and particularly their individual talents are utilised.

Good point about Paulo's age mate, didn't even think about that, Thompson looks obvious but a lot of cash, now I'm sounding hypocritical eh, shouldn't drink and post ?
Any alternatives then for 2023? and how much would you pay for Stef for a 4 year deal?

 

[tig_prmz]

It seems like anyone from the club doing a media piece is under orders to talk things down for season 22. Both Sheens and Madge have been very reluctant to make any predictions for next season and basically talk expectations down. Although they do seem to be positive about 23.

Maybe it’s about getting people onboard with the idea of a average year ahead but light at the end of the tunnel. Of course it might also be about trying to save your job

We are favourites for the spoon on almost all betting agencies.

I made a thread this time last year that we will be favourites for the spoon for 2021, seems I was a year early into my prediction.

We will not be making the 8 and that means Madge will not be surviving.

 

[tig_prmz]

Actually we are at longest odds to make the 8 and the top 4 too.

Anyone who believes in us should put a cheeky $50 on us at $5 and $11 respectively

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

Actually we are at longest odds to make the 8 and the top 4 too.

Anyone who believes in us should put a cheeky $50 on us at $5 and $11 respectively

I believe in us but I believe in money in the bank more.

 

[earl]

We will not be making the 8 and that means Madge will not be surviving.

That sort of gives Madge a chance for another year doesn't it. We don't look anything like a top 8 team this year but maybe we improve the year after.

 

[earl]

Actually we are at longest odds to make the 8 and the top 4 too.

Anyone who believes in us should put a cheeky $50 on us at $5 and $11 respectively

We could make the 8. It's unlikely but it could happen.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

think 2022 we finish 10 or 11 and Madge survives for 2023
Make 8 in 2023

 

[tig_prmz]

I highly doubt Madge survives if we don't make the 8.. wouldn't that make it 4 yeras of bottom 8 finishes?

I don't know the right answer but the pressure will be on the board/CEO/Sheens...