Moore vs sheens vs elliot

bigdamo

New member
well what is the dif moore is been called on to be sacked he is on the same points as us as was elliot he was sacked moore could be as well sheens is a myth an aura that stops reason he should be sacked and with humpty i mean sheens record is not flash one comp win in 05 a semi final apperance but two semis in all that time is not good enough. :imp: :smiling_imp:
 
I think the best word to answer your question is "myth". A myth can grow to great proportions and become invincible…...no matter how vulnerable the myth should actually be. Tim Sheens is a myth.
 
Tells us what the myth is then…..we run 3rd last year and your only as good as your last.

If anythings a myth its marshall and farah been classed as top players.
 
@tiger4ever said:
Tells us what the myth is then…..we run 3rd last year and your only as good as your last.

If anythings a myth its marshall and farah been classed as top players.

Well that logic doesnt work because you say Sheens isnt a myth because your only as good as your last…..then you say Marshall isnt a class player......he was golden boot last year.
 
@tiger4ever said:
Tells us what the myth is then…..we run 3rd last year and your only as good as your last.

If anythings a myth its marshall and farah been classed as top players.

:blah Penrith ran 2nd last year and theyre coach got the arse
 
Our coach has ridden a once in a generation talent in Benji.

Take out Benji and Sheens would have been out of the NRL years ago. 100% fact.

We have no gameplan. We are a rabble as soon as Benji is 10% off his game.
 
@king sirro said:
@tiger4ever said:
Tells us what the myth is then…..we run 3rd last year and your only as good as your last.

If anythings a myth its marshall and farah been classed as top players.

Well that logic doesnt work because you say Sheens isnt a myth because your only as good as your last…..then you say Marshall isnt a class player......he was golden boot last year.[/quote

Your the one that says sheens is a myth so i put another spin on it and then you make your own comments look silly if it doesnt work like that.ah

We still in the 8 currently.
 
@Granto87 said:
@tiger4ever said:
Tells us what the myth is then…..we run 3rd last year and your only as good as your last.

If anythings a myth its marshall and farah been classed as top players.

:blah Penrith ran 2nd last year and theyre coach got the arse

Lol penrith run 5 or 6th actually….
 
@tiger4ever said:
@Granto87 said:
@tiger4ever said:
Tells us what the myth is then…..we run 3rd last year and your only as good as your last.

If anythings a myth its marshall and farah been classed as top players.

:blah Penrith ran 2nd last year and theyre coach got the arse

Lol penrith run 5 or 6th actually….

:roll
2010 NRL seasonv · d · e
Team Pld W D L B PF PA PD Pts
1 St. George Illawarra Dragons 24 17 0 7 2 518 299 +219 38
2 Penrith Panthers 24 15 0 9 2 645 489 +156 34
3 Wests Tigers 24 15 0 9 2 537 503 +34 34
4 Gold Coast Titans 24 15 0 9 2 520 498 +22 34
5 New Zealand Warriors 24 14 0 10 2 539 486 +53 32
6 Sydney Roosters 24 14 0 10 2 559 510 +49 32
7 Canberra Raiders 24 13 0 11 2 499 493 +6 30
8 Manly-Warringah Sea Eagles 24 12 0 12 2 545 510 +35 28
9 South Sydney Rabbitohs 24 11 0 13 2 584 567 +17 26
10 Brisbane Broncos 24 11 0 13 2 508 535 −27 26
11 Newcastle Knights 24 10 0 14 2 499 569 −70 24
12 Parramatta Eels 24 10 0 14 2 413 491 −78 24
13 Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs 24 9 0 15 2 494 539 −45 22
14 Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks 24 7 0 17 2 354 609 −255 18
15 North Queensland Cowboys 24 5 0 19 2 425 667 −242 14
16 Melbourne Storm 24 14 0 10 2 489 363 +126 01
 
omg you play semis you know and that determines where you finish….penrith played 2 and lost both.

The laughs on you
 
Every club has different circumstances that we dont know about….elliots job was on the line after his first year...Its no suprise he got punted.
 
I don't think you should base it solely on where a team finished. If so, the tigers are one of the worst performing teams since 2006 with only one single finals appearance in 5 years. I place a lot of weight on whether a team comes to play each week and consistency. The tigers are amongst the worst in both counts, year in, year out.

I'll always support the tigers even if they lose every week, but they are a damn frustrating team to watch and make us fans prove our commitment every bloody week.
 
@tiger4ever said:
omg you play semis you know and that determines where you finish….penrith played 2 and lost both.

The laughs on you

IMO where you finish on the ladder at the end of the competition rounds defines whether or not you have had a sucessful season.
 
We have played tough, consistent football for about 15 weeks out of 8 years under Sheens. You tell me what other coach in the NRL could get away with that and still have a job?
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 

Latest posts

Back
Top