OFFICIAL Pathways - KOE General Discussion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cobarcats
  • Start date Start date
Really proud of the KOE boys yesterday. Showed a lot of effort against an always well gelled and trained Jets. Doesn't help when they can bring Hamlin uele and Rudolf on for the last 15-20 mins.
I feel Lobb, Feledy and Saukuru played well.
Lobb obviously struggled kicking but he had some great moments and I feel we will definitely see him back in first grade. I will say he is definitely not a first grader though and will bounce around KOE teams for his career.
Saukuru looked big and strong. Definitely didn't struggle to defend due to size. I feel there is something there but then again he will play out this season in reserve grade.
Very happy with Feledy in attack. Him and Lobb definitely the favoured side of the field. Strong and gritty but not that smart. Kind of a shame he hasn't played out like the club wished but some good effort and a lesson or two from Chris Lawrence wouldn't hurt.
The forwards did well and held their own. Quite a few lapses letting a couple tries up the middle.
Jordan Miller surprisingly played big minutes and didn't disappoint. Great runs bringing in at least 3 defenders sometimes 4. Thought they definitely relied on him as a crutch and i think that is bound to happen when Johanssen and Porter are the starting props. Really happy with his big minutes and I didn't see anything too shocking in defence from him.
Bud Sullivan was horrendous. In a side that is begging for a leader he was M.I.A. Had some shocking handling errors and didn't stand up when the team needed him most.
Latu Fainu looked alright in his return. Did his job and not much else. In one of the stranger things i have seen he left the ground at halftime in full kit due to restricted minutes to load manage. Came back with 10 to go. Brent Naden did his job and nothing else. Found he was playing hero ball looking for the outstanding plays to win it but it just didn't happen. When they needed a pass he ran it on multiple occasion. Definitely in England next year.
Tallyn was definitely an interesting one. Very poor service from dummy half but was great in defence. I have heard from the S and C staff he does lift well above average for his size. Lets hope Robbie teaches him a few things.

Very happy with the brave and valiant performane. Newtown are never an easy team to come up against and I believe this is the strongest team magpies have put on the park this year. With Sullivan at seven he really needs to stand up as a leader. Otherwise onto next week aganst the chooks at Wenty.

Playing for pride this season
 
Tigers_Wests said:
Hoping they work hard with Luke Laulili'i in the pre season on his bomb defusal. Never looks comfortable under them. Only young and plenty of time to work on it, but he will be targeted if it doesn't get sorted.
Click to expand...
He's just too small. Same size as Faalogo but without the pace and skill. Even Melbourne would rotate him to centre on the last to put a big body on wing for kick defusal. I just don't see either of the Lauliliis making first grade careers, both too small and so far lack the skills to compensate against men
 
Last edited:
balmain boy said:
He's just too small. Same size as Faalogo but without the pace and skill. Even Melbourne would rotate him to centre on the last to put a big body on wing for kick defusal. I just don't see either of the Lauliliis making guest grade careers, both too small and so far lack the skills to compensate against men
Click to expand...

Same boat as Tumeth and Matamua for mine...
Just not showing enough in lower grades to do it on the big stage.
 
balmain boy said:
He's just too small. Same size as Faalogo but without the pace and skill. Even Melbourne would rotate him to centre on the last to put a big body on wing for kick defusal. I just don't see either of the Lauliliis making guest grade careers, both too small and so far lack the skills to compensate against men
Click to expand...
Luke to lock , train him up he hits hard , runs hard , has some pace , could work
 
balmain boy said:
Tigers_Wests said:
Hoping they work hard with Luke Laulili'i in the pre season on his bomb defusal. Never looks comfortable under them. Only young and plenty of time to work on it, but he will be targeted if it doesn't get sorted.
Click to expand...
He's just too small. Same size as Faalogo but without the pace and skill. Even Melbourne would rotate him to centre on the last to put a big body on wing for kick defusal. I just don't see either of the Lauliliis making guest grade careers, both too small and so far lack the skills to compensate against men
Click to expand...
What is it with Wests Tigers and small players. Just love 'em.
 
balmain boy said:
He's just too small. Same size as Faalogo but without the pace and skill. Even Melbourne would rotate him to centre on the last to put a big body on wing for kick defusal. I just don't see either of the Lauliliis making guest grade careers, both too small and so far lack the skills to compensate against men
Click to expand...
Having both of them along with Sukkar and Saukuru all on top 30 deals next season is ridiculous.
All deserve to be on Development deals to see how they progress, but none of them would be top 30 players at any other NRL club just yet.
 
Last edited:
Vicious said:
Having both of them along with Sukkar and Saukuru all on top 30 deals next season is ridiculous.
All deserve to be on Development deals to see how they progress, but none of them would be top 30 players at any other NRL club just yet.
Click to expand...
Isn't Sukkar on a development contract now? This year is important for his development plus a hard pre-season.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Isn't Sukkar on a development contract now? This year is important for his development plus a hard pre-season.
Click to expand...
He is, but he's never going to be a first grader. Surely one contract we try pay out unless we can offload him.

Being a development club does not mean that all decent 17 years old get given long terms contracts. They should still have to earn it. That's what professional clubs do. It creates a culture of excellence and high performance.

Taking a punt on a generational potential player like Galvin, Latu or even Miller is ok. Players who have stood out above the rest at a very high level you take that punt on. What has Sukkar ever done to suggest he could be an NRL player? Has he ever even been man of the match in any game, in any grade? Has he ever been in the top 5 in flegg or Cup?
No.
He's a long way behind the likes of Broederlow, Johannsen in our pecking order
 
balmain boy said:
He is, but he's never going to be a first grader. Surely one contract we try pay out unless we can offload him.

Being a development club does not mean that all decent 17 years old get given long terms contracts. They should still have to earn it. That's what professional clubs do. It creates a culture of excellence and high performance.

Taking a punt on a generational potential player like Galvin, Latu or even Miller is ok. Players who have stood out above the rest at a very high level you take that punt on. What has Sukkar ever done to suggest he could be an NRL player? Has he ever even been man of the match in any game, in any grade? Has he ever been in the top 5 in flegg or Cup?
No.
He's a long way behind the likes of Broederlow, Johannsen in our pecking order
Click to expand...
I did watch Sukkar in an NRL trial and he looked comfortable at that level. We need to remember he is what Flegg age and level? Forwards do take time to mature although there are exceptions like Pole. Some of our players have been given accelerated development while others like Faagutu who should be lock in NSW Cup is continually played out of position at prop in Flegg.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
I did watch Sukkar in an NRL trial and he looked comfortable at that level. We need to remember he is what Flegg age and level? Forwards do take time to mature although there are exceptions like Pole. Some of our players have been given accelerated development while others like Faagutu who should be lock in NSW Cup is continually played out of position at prop in Flegg.
Click to expand...
We have to remember that these days forwards peak at 24-26 and by the time they reach 30 many are barely able to keep up with the pace of the NRL.
 
Charbel Tasipale is a Lebanon international rugby league footballer who last played as a second-row forward or centre for the Castleford Tigers in the Super League. He was released from his contract with the Tigers in June 2024, after returning home on compassionate grounds. Wikipedia
Born: 24 February 2000 (age 24 years), Australia
Height: 1.88 m
 
At least 2 of the tries conceded by our Flegg team last weekend were straight through where Vaihu was defending.
For that effort he gets promoted to NSW Cup ?
Is there any type of criteria for who goes up and down between grades as it doesn’t often seem to be form related ?
 
Last edited:
Aceshigh said:
Is he of K O cup standard or better?
Click to expand...
I always thought he was a promising player, much like Elie El Zakem and Brad Morkos - all from the Cedar world cup team.

Definitely NSW cup standard but a welcome addition to our sub par squad.

Perhaps the Farah connection got this deal worked out.

See how he goes.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 512 (members: 1, guests: 511)
Back
Top