Original_Magpie
New member
how is it a fair merger when the majority of games are played closer to one half of the mergers fan base than the other?
Save Our Sides Protest Rally - SUN 05FEB11
- Thread starter galahs
- Start date
G
Guest
Guest
@galahs said:
Exhibit A, page 1, post 1\. This is the basis for this particular thread. Stick to it, or don't post.
Original_Magpie
New member
i asked a simple question how is it exactly fair when the majority of games are played closer to one half of the mergers fans than the others?
because technically 8 games played in the city and only 4 out at ctown
because technically 8 games played in the city and only 4 out at ctown
Well put Knuckles both the Magpies and Balmain live on in the Wests Tigers after all, without the tiger and the magpie in the first place, there wouldn't be a Wests Tigers. I also agree that Wests Tigers could spend a bit more time in the Macarthur area to keep reinforcing their presence to the community and the kids playing junior league. Pushing the WTs presence may also need to be pushed in the Balmain area, I don't know not living there but I can speak for Macarthur and I haven't seen a lot of publicity for things the club does in the area.
@cunno said:
I lived in Leichhardt for a while and recall stuff all being done. I don't even remember them having a presence at the Leichhardt Street Fair but I may be mistaken.
Anyway my point is (to reinforce your comments) more can always be done to promote the club in all the areas it considers its territories.
S
system
Guest
@galahs said:
Two possible options.
1\. The IC will change those rules in a step to modernise the current structure
2\. Wests Tigers is deemed to represent both Western Suburbs and Balmain junior districts. Even if the Western Suburbs Magpies block this move the Balmain junior district can appoint WT as their district representative.
Not any kind of stumbling block moving forward really though it will be interesting if Western Suburbs football club agree to this or allow Balmain to nominate WT and than spend the next 3 years whining about how nothing is fair
The future of the West Tigers is at Campbelltown. There are hundreds of teenagers (especially Pacific Islander kids) who reside in the Campbelltown region. These young people should be aiming to play for a team the represents the south west and that team should be the tigers. Keep the name, keep the jersey but fully represent the Macarthur region by being based at the Campbelltown Stadium, then kids will aspire to play and fans who have relocated to the myriad of housing developments in the area will embrace the team as their own.
This seems so simple to me and i do not know why the NRL is not enforcing a more permanent move for the Tigers to Campbelltown. Securing the South West of Sydney should be the priority for the NRL and also for the Tigers to secure the juniors in the area.
This seems so simple to me and i do not know why the NRL is not enforcing a more permanent move for the Tigers to Campbelltown. Securing the South West of Sydney should be the priority for the NRL and also for the Tigers to secure the juniors in the area.
Why we feel let down in pictures…..
\
\
\
8 games in the inner city, 4 in the South West
\
\
\
The proud Magpies on the Shoulders....
\
\
became the vanishing Magpie on the cuff of the sleeve...
\
\
\
the main jersey has a distinct Balmain feel yet the alternative jersey is a nothing design
\
\
\
\
Why do Magpies have to play for Balmain to get a chance at making the Wests Tigers teams...
\
\
\
\
Maybe if the Wests side felt like they were being treated fairly, there would be greater support for a joint venture Wests Tigers team in the NSW Cup.
Maybe the Wests Tigers should have done a better job at selling it to us... not dictating terms.
To quote the famous Magpie legend Noel Kelly... "time and time again the Wests side gets the rough end of the stick"
\
\
\
8 games in the inner city, 4 in the South West
\
\
\
The proud Magpies on the Shoulders....
\
\
became the vanishing Magpie on the cuff of the sleeve...
\
\
\
the main jersey has a distinct Balmain feel yet the alternative jersey is a nothing design
\
\
\
\
Why do Magpies have to play for Balmain to get a chance at making the Wests Tigers teams...
\
\
\
\
Maybe if the Wests side felt like they were being treated fairly, there would be greater support for a joint venture Wests Tigers team in the NSW Cup.
Maybe the Wests Tigers should have done a better job at selling it to us... not dictating terms.
To quote the famous Magpie legend Noel Kelly... "time and time again the Wests side gets the rough end of the stick"
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
@Fumbles said:
I understand that things need to stay fair, and that one side should never be favoured over the other, but i can just never comprehend why people are so blas'e when it comes to Campbelltown. I mean we have the second biggest junior area in Sydney at our disposel. Why every single Tigers fan isn't screaming the house down that we make Campbelltown a priority is beyond me. Not for one minute saying Inner Sydney should be abandoned at all, but we need to use our heads and realize which area long term is going to be more viable
My husband and I would like to wish you Good luck with your rally galahs you are a very passionate man. This forum seems to be a very clicky group who don't want anything to do with Campbelltown.
I grew up in Auburn and always supported the Magpies I would have been there to support you but I now live in Brisbane.
I grew up in Auburn and always supported the Magpies I would have been there to support you but I now live in Brisbane.
I really do appreciate your kind words.
I feel I am often mistaken as someone who is against the Joint Venture and that is completely untrue.
I grew up out at Camden, played junior footy for the Camden Rams, went to High School at Campbelltown and had the benefit of growing up in an area that had a full time 1st Grade Rugby League team.
I understand why the joint venture happened. Though terrible news, I understood why it was completely necessary.
What saddens me now is the total decay in Rugby League out in the area I grew up.
- We now only get 4 NRL games a year… the district suffers
- The Wests group is fractured.... the Wests side suffers
- Junior League is a shambles... local players suffer
- The area loses its last senior rep side... opportunities suffer
- politics, backroom deals, under the table deals, back stabbing, short sightedness... everyone suffers
how long do you sit back and let this happen to the game and area you love?
I feel I am often mistaken as someone who is against the Joint Venture and that is completely untrue.
I grew up out at Camden, played junior footy for the Camden Rams, went to High School at Campbelltown and had the benefit of growing up in an area that had a full time 1st Grade Rugby League team.
I understand why the joint venture happened. Though terrible news, I understood why it was completely necessary.
What saddens me now is the total decay in Rugby League out in the area I grew up.
- We now only get 4 NRL games a year… the district suffers
- The Wests group is fractured.... the Wests side suffers
- Junior League is a shambles... local players suffer
- The area loses its last senior rep side... opportunities suffer
- politics, backroom deals, under the table deals, back stabbing, short sightedness... everyone suffers
how long do you sit back and let this happen to the game and area you love?
G
Guest
Guest
@galahs said:
So stop whinging about it and proactively do something about it. Do you think 30 pages of whinging and arguing on here will solve any of the perceived problems you have highlighted? Nope.
None of us here are on any Wests board and I seriously doubt whether any Rugby League figures or members of power will be taking any notice of this thread.
I understand venting on here may make people feel better, but really, given the issues raised by you galahs, venting on here won't achieve anything. You have managed to gather some media attention via newspapers and radio. Maybe you should be focusing more on what you plan to say and do at the Wests rally and organising speakers for the rally rather than crying over spilt milk here.
If you want to be noticed and make a positive difference, then lead by example.
@galahs said:
I've deleted the pictures to save space. I'm sure I'm wasting my time but here goes.
The match split is 4 games Wests, 4 games Balmain, 4 games commercial. Any claim to contrary is disingenuous at best. If Campbelltown or some ground closer to Macarthur has the cash to fund these games you might have a point. To claim these are "inner city" games is misleading. The SFS offers capacity (so fans aren't turned away), access to fans throughout Sydney, state of the art facilities, and the chance to play at one of the country's best stadiums. Personally I'd be happy to play 2 commercial games in Macarthur if you and your mates or the Campbelltown club pay the $200k per game (or whatever it is) to do it. Not a problem at all.
I have no problem with increasing the size of the magpie if it makes a difference. None of you guys seemed to bother with steve-o's objection that the Balmain name was being lost at senior level. But if having a large magpie on the sleeve is a priority I really don't care.
The jumper thing has been done to death. Personally I have no objection to jumpers that feature a lot of black although as I recall the complaint before was there wasn't enough white. Now it's mostly white and their are still complaints. Seems the only complaint is too much orange…
You know full well why "Magpies" (who are mostly WT signed players) have to turn out for Balmain. There are close to 50 pages of discussion across various threads on the matter...
I don't see that WT are dictating anything. These are decision made with the approval of close to all the board including a majority of Wests Magpies directors. The blame lies in the decision making on the Magpies side.
But this has zero (or very close to it) to do with the juniors. 14 year old kids want to play for Wests Tigers not Western Suburbs Magpies. So the size of the magpie is not an issue to them nor is the lack of a State Cup team, nor the jumper design. Maybe the game allocation is an issue to them, to be honest I don't know if increasing the allocation from 4 to 6 would be a factor.
S
system
Guest
Name change in order
Sydney Basin Cat Birds :slight_smile:
Sydney Basin Cat Birds :slight_smile:
All I was demonstrating is the multiple reasons why people from Wests feel disenchanted over the Joint Venture.
If you are not from the Macarthur, or not a long term Magpie supporter, I don't expect you to understand how certain people feel.
\
\
\
As for not being called Balmain… Wests and Balmain BOTH agreed to that in 1999
As for the 2 Magpies on the shoulders... Wests and balmain BOTH agreed to that in 1999
As for the Tiger logo on the Chest... Wests and Balmain BOTH agreed to that in 1999
As for having two seperate NSW Cup teams... Wests and Balmain BOTH agreed to that in 1999
If you are not from the Macarthur, or not a long term Magpie supporter, I don't expect you to understand how certain people feel.
\
\
\
As for not being called Balmain… Wests and Balmain BOTH agreed to that in 1999
As for the 2 Magpies on the shoulders... Wests and balmain BOTH agreed to that in 1999
As for the Tiger logo on the Chest... Wests and Balmain BOTH agreed to that in 1999
As for having two seperate NSW Cup teams... Wests and Balmain BOTH agreed to that in 1999
@smeghead said:
With a new homeground to be build at the midway point from Leichhardt to Campbelltown?
@galahs said:
They also agreed that Leichhardt and Campbelltown should receive the same amount of games right?
@galahs said:
Wow… That post is in stark contrast to the following:
**OUR FAIR DEMANDS INCLUDE**
>
- Wests Tigers need a greater presense in the area. Plans need to be in place for a full time relocation of their HQ to the region as was the original plan back when the joint venture was formed.
>
- We need a fully funded NSW Cup side to provide a stepping stone for our kids to NRL
>
- We need professionally run District Competition for the Wests Junior district area
>
- Teams need to be able to train and play on grounds of their own choosing
>
- More than 4 NRL games a year at Campbelltown Stadium
>
- More junior development programs for our kids
WT jersey designs and location of the magpie is not mentioned in your OP, and you mention nothing about the plight of the juniors in the Macarthur first post. It's quite obvious that the region doesn't want to lose their identity as the Magpies, but as per your OP, that's not the root cause of this rally.
Make up your mind on what you want, and clearly dictate what your demands are because it's quite obvious there are other motives at hand for this rally other than what you originally stated. The cynicism you're receiving here is due to the fact that you're not being forthright. Enough of the smoke & mirrors...
S
system
Guest
@Yossarian said:
Demolish Warwick Farm racecourse and build a giant stadium, carpark and stage setup for the annual CatBirdPalooza concert
Staff online
-
DempsModerator
Members online
- Raybannedman
- GNR4LIFE
- 69-05-41
- Tiger_Yoshi
- Glenji95
- ashman
- phil1986
- Lestronge
- hank37w
- Criz
- InBenjiWeTrust
- Mighty_Tiger
- Rusty
- Tom Shines
- claws1
- upthetigers
- cochise
- Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan
- Rock Hopper Steve
- Tiger-ferret
- philgood
- oldschooltiger
- gallagher
- Bula
- TIGERS
- Ecto-1
- tiger05premier
- poopy_diaper
- Leica_Tiger
- Nadz4483
- moetk
- BunganHead Tiger
- Kearnsy
- Demps
- Westie
- teddy23
- townsvilletiger
- magpies forever
- KH1988
- mikey
- Aceshigh
- noideaaswell
- happy_tiger
- Hazard_10
- steve2422
- Telltails
- Speed2burn
- Tiger4life43