I’m not against letting Brooks go but I have a couple of issues.Agreed. Brooks has looked better moving to the six but he's not worth the big money to justify playing "well" as opposed to what you'd expect from a player earning marquee money.
Let him go, re-sign Madden as we lose nothing between him and Brooks playing outside Duke and it'll be cheaper and free up a spot to chase Burton and put him in the centres with either To'a or Naden.
1. Brooks is still better than Madden, so we potentially weaken one spot to strengthen another.
2. Who do we sign? We are already struggling to find players to spend the money we have so having another $500k+ (depending on release deal) is useless when there’s no one on the market.
I don’t see us being stronger next year without Brooks unless someone can walk from a contract. 2024 is obviously different. There will be a few options available and worst case Brooks takes a haircut to stay.