Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[jirskyr]

Mitchell Pearce on NBN news just now endorsing the club to lure Luke Brooks to the knights asap.

Perhaps Mitchell should talk to their CEO..

'Knights CEO Phil Gardner dispelled those rumours, claiming they were unable to speak to Brooks due to him being contracted until the end of 2023.'

It was a Danny Weidler special, asked him specifically about Brooks.

Such a weasel

That's offensive to weasles and other mustelids.

 

[jirskyr]

Ew a Greyhound. Good luck to him!

Downvote!!!!! LOL

Singleton were my most hated opposition.

My two boys are greyhounds. I would have been a thoroughbred but now they are the scumbags of the area!

The guys that played for Singleton in my age group were dirty players and their parents were trash, so my dislike comes from there. I remember one game when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, we ended up punching on and they walked from the game with their parents abusing us. Worst game I have ever been involved in.

So I take it you don't enjoy being squirreled.

 

[Camel2281]

Mitchell Pearce on NBN news just now endorsing the club to lure Luke Brooks to the knights asap.

Pearce just confirmed how dumb he is…Newcastle can’t lure Brooks till Nov 2022…only way they can get him earlier is if WT allow Brooks to talk to other clubs….

To be fair Weidler asked him about Brooks out of the Blue and Pearce just answered his question. Weidler pushing the agenda not Pearce

 

[JD Tiger]

To @cochise, @jirskyr, @tigerballs, @Strongee and plenty of others - I ask you to please move it to another thread.
>Or do we want to just do away with topics and have it all as a free-for-all?

Whilst I support your position in general, to ask that people "stay on topic" in this thread, of all the threads on the website, is in interesting one. This must be the most meandering, ill-defined, arbitrary and baseless collection of jumbled musings on the whole forum.

On a technicality, discussions about salary caps and TPAs do have a direct, single-degree of relationship to signings news. They are the mechanism by which signings occur. This is not the "signing news" thread, this is the suggestions and speculation thread, and some folks are discussing new suggestions about how signings can be better policed in the competition. I would put it to you that ongoing discussions about Liddle and Simpkin similarly have nothing specifically to do with whether Josh Hodgson has signed with the Tigers, but rather are a line of discussion about the potential impacts of the rumour or suggestion.

And respectfully, anyone who reads 10 pages of this thread and gets their hopes up must not have been around long enough to know better.

I do agree that the Liddle/Simpkins talk should also have been located elsewhere, but I choose to try and focus on the one I thought might be more easily relocated.

And yes, one could argue that the TPAs is related to signings, suggestions and rumours. Just about everything is related when you boil down to it.
But that's not meant to be the focus of that/this thread, and I think you've been around long enough to know that.

And it is the off season as well, so more leniency should be given. All fair enough.

Your final comment is a cheap shot. You say 'respectfully' and then put a barb in about not knowing better for good measure. I don't see the respect in doing that. That sort of thing is why I don't comment much, I'm not interested in a slinging match. Throwing put-downs around. No thank you.

I come here hoping for good news about the WT, as unoptimistic as I might be, always hoping against hope.

 

[happy_tiger]

Brooks for Ponga ...done

 

[BAGNF05]

Brooks for Ponga ...done

Isnt that his forum nickname?

 

[jirskyr]

To @cochise, @jirskyr, @tigerballs, @Strongee and plenty of others - I ask you to please move it to another thread.
>Or do we want to just do away with topics and have it all as a free-for-all?

Whilst I support your position in general, to ask that people "stay on topic" in this thread, of all the threads on the website, is in interesting one. This must be the most meandering, ill-defined, arbitrary and baseless collection of jumbled musings on the whole forum.

On a technicality, discussions about salary caps and TPAs do have a direct, single-degree of relationship to signings news. They are the mechanism by which signings occur. This is not the "signing news" thread, this is the suggestions and speculation thread, and some folks are discussing new suggestions about how signings can be better policed in the competition. I would put it to you that ongoing discussions about Liddle and Simpkin similarly have nothing specifically to do with whether Josh Hodgson has signed with the Tigers, but rather are a line of discussion about the potential impacts of the rumour or suggestion.

And respectfully, anyone who reads 10 pages of this thread and gets their hopes up must not have been around long enough to know better.

I do agree that the Liddle/Simpkins talk should also have been located elsewhere, but I choose to try and focus on the one I thought might be more easily relocated.

And yes, one could argue that the TPAs is related to signings, suggestions and rumours. Just about everything is related when you boil down to it.
But that's not meant to be the focus of that/this thread, and I think you've been around long enough to know that.

And it is the off season as well, so more leniency should be given. All fair enough.

Your final comment is a cheap shot. You say 'respectfully' and then put a barb in about not knowing better for good measure. I don't see the respect in doing that. That sort of thing is why I don't comment much, I'm not interested in a slinging match. Throwing put-downs around. No thank you.

I come here hoping for good news about the WT, as unoptimistic as I might be, always hoping against hope.

I apologise if I offend, not intentional.

But also I stand by what I said - this thread is notorious for throwing up pages and pages of gobbledygook and page counts invariably have no relation to actual news. So to see "10 pages" of content and hope for news is one thing, and it's a thing I share myself, but to see 10 pages of content and *expect* news... something else entirely.

It's not a barb specifically aimed at you, it's the reality that this thread is about 110K posts in 4 years (almost 28K posts per year) and an overwhelmingly large amount of it is fluff. There have been, what, maybe 40 signings by Tigers in the past 4 seasons? That's approx one signing announced every 2750 posts.

 

[jirskyr]

Ew a Greyhound. Good luck to him!

Downvote!!!!! LOL

Singleton were my most hated opposition.

My two boys are greyhounds. I would have been a thoroughbred but now they are the scumbags of the area!

The guys that played for Singleton in my age group were dirty players and their parents were trash, so my dislike comes from there. I remember one game when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, we ended up punching on and they walked from the game with their parents abusing us. Worst game I have ever been involved in.

So I take it you don't enjoy being squirreled.

"I remember one game, when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, so we met up in the sheds after FT and all got on really well with one another."

 

[cochise]

Ew a Greyhound. Good luck to him!

Downvote!!!!! LOL

Singleton were my most hated opposition.

My two boys are greyhounds. I would have been a thoroughbred but now they are the scumbags of the area!

The guys that played for Singleton in my age group were dirty players and their parents were trash, so my dislike comes from there. I remember one game when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, we ended up punching on and they walked from the game with their parents abusing us. Worst game I have ever been involved in.

So I take it you don't enjoy being squirreled.

"I remember one game, when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, so we met up in the sheds after FT and all got on really well with one another."

I think that says more about you then anyone else mate. lol

 

[jirskyr]

Ew a Greyhound. Good luck to him!

Downvote!!!!! LOL

Singleton were my most hated opposition.

My two boys are greyhounds. I would have been a thoroughbred but now they are the scumbags of the area!

The guys that played for Singleton in my age group were dirty players and their parents were trash, so my dislike comes from there. I remember one game when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, we ended up punching on and they walked from the game with their parents abusing us. Worst game I have ever been involved in.

So I take it you don't enjoy being squirreled.

"I remember one game, when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, so we met up in the sheds after FT and all got on really well with one another."

I think that says more about you then anyone else mate. lol

It says a lot about squirrels.

Speaking of which, did you know Germans commonly struggle to say "squirrel"?

 

[LeichhardtTiger]

Ew a Greyhound. Good luck to him!

Downvote!!!!! LOL

Singleton were my most hated opposition.

My two boys are greyhounds. I would have been a thoroughbred but now they are the scumbags of the area!

The guys that played for Singleton in my age group were dirty players and their parents were trash, so my dislike comes from there. I remember one game when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, we ended up punching on and they walked from the game with their parents abusing us. Worst game I have ever been involved in.

So I take it you don't enjoy being squirreled.

"I remember one game, when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, so we met up in the sheds after FT and all got on really well with one another."

I think that says more about you then anyone else mate. lol

It says a lot about squirrels.

Speaking of which, did you know Germans commonly struggle to say "squirrel"?

H o g a n!!!!

 

[balmain boy]

Man Michael Roberts James Roberts brother looks like a mini inglis. Would be interested to know which nrl club he is with.

He's with Titans u18s for 2022 but then uncontracted after that

 

[TigerWest]

I’m curious to see if the lure to pick up Hodkinson is to change tack and direction in the spine. Could very well be obtained to offset the loss of Brooks, I guess the first domino has fallen so we’ll wait to see what move is next.

What domino has fallen?

 

[cktiger]

I’m curious to see if the lure to pick up Hodkinson is to change tack and direction in the spine. Could very well be obtained to offset the loss of Brooks, I guess the first domino has fallen so we’ll wait to see what move is next.

What domino has fallen?

Pearce gone from Newcastle.

 

[tony soprano]

Ew a Greyhound. Good luck to him!

Downvote!!!!! LOL

Singleton were my most hated opposition.

My two boys are greyhounds. I would have been a thoroughbred but now they are the scumbags of the area!

The guys that played for Singleton in my age group were dirty players and their parents were trash, so my dislike comes from there. I remember one game when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, we ended up punching on and they walked from the game with their parents abusing us. Worst game I have ever been involved in.

So I take it you don't enjoy being squirreled.

"I remember one game, when we were about 12 or 13, they were going the squirrel all game, so we met up in the sheds after FT and all got on really well with one another."

Lucky

 

[WT2K]

Barnstorming Eels back-rower Isaiah Papali'i looks set to knock back a massive approach from the new Dolphins franchise for 2023, leaving his future a two-horse race.

Papali'i's manager Daniel O'Loughlin has told Wide World of Sports that the much-improved forward doesn't want to leave Sydney.

That reduces his options to staying at Parramatta or accepting a big offer from Wests Tigers.

"Isaiah is settled in Sydney with his family and prefers to stay here," O'Loughlin said.

"The Tigers are very keen but he also feels a loyalty to Parramatta so will probably give them the last say.

"I think they are meeting this week so we will see what they come up with."

His ability to play both middle and edge forward adds to his value and the tough forward has been in hot demand.

Papali'i finished 2021 third in the NRL for post-contact metres and should only get better in coming years.

The Eels are desperate to keep him but also have several big names off contract including skipper Clint Gutherson, hooker Reed Mahoney and prop Junior Paulo.

https://wwos.nine.com.au/nrl/the-mole-isaiah-papalii-parramatta-eels-dolphins-wests-tigers-contract-russell-fairfax/a2e92991-cbba-4406-9a5a-d05a4729edaa

 

[Roar_Power]

Barnstorming Eels back-rower Isaiah Papali'i looks set to knock back a massive approach from the new Dolphins franchise for 2023, leaving his future a two-horse race.

Papali'i's manager Daniel O'Loughlin has told Wide World of Sports that the much-improved forward doesn't want to leave Sydney.

That reduces his options to staying at Parramatta or accepting a big offer from Wests Tigers.

"Isaiah is settled in Sydney with his family and prefers to stay here," O'Loughlin said.

"The Tigers are very keen but he also feels a loyalty to Parramatta so will probably give them the last say.

"I think they are meeting this week so we will see what they come up with."

His ability to play both middle and edge forward adds to his value and the tough forward has been in hot demand.

Papali'i finished 2021 third in the NRL for post-contact metres and should only get better in coming years.

The Eels are desperate to keep him but also have several big names off contract including skipper Clint Gutherson, hooker Reed Mahoney and prop Junior Paulo.

https://wwos.nine.com.au/nrl/the-mole-isaiah-papalii-parramatta-eels-dolphins-wests-tigers-contract-russell-fairfax/a2e92991-cbba-4406-9a5a-d05a4729edaa

Need to make this happen...

 

[Telltails]

Can't make it happen if players want to stay where they are. All it will take is for the Eels to come back with a competitive offer. The ball is in their court, we have done all we can do.

 

[Newtown]

To @cochise, @jirskyr, @tigerballs, @Strongee and plenty of others - I ask you to please move it to another thread.
>Or do we want to just do away with topics and have it all as a free-for-all?

Whilst I support your position in general, to ask that people "stay on topic" in this thread, of all the threads on the website, is in interesting one. This must be the most meandering, ill-defined, arbitrary and baseless collection of jumbled musings on the whole forum.

On a technicality, discussions about salary caps and TPAs do have a direct, single-degree of relationship to signings news. They are the mechanism by which signings occur. This is not the "signing news" thread, this is the suggestions and speculation thread, and some folks are discussing new suggestions about how signings can be better policed in the competition. I would put it to you that ongoing discussions about Liddle and Simpkin similarly have nothing specifically to do with whether Josh Hodgson has signed with the Tigers, but rather are a line of discussion about the potential impacts of the rumour or suggestion.

And respectfully, anyone who reads 10 pages of this thread and gets their hopes up must not have been around long enough to know better.

I do agree that the Liddle/Simpkins talk should also have been located elsewhere, but I choose to try and focus on the one I thought might be more easily relocated.

And yes, one could argue that the TPAs is related to signings, suggestions and rumours. Just about everything is related when you boil down to it.
But that's not meant to be the focus of that/this thread, and I think you've been around long enough to know that.

And it is the off season as well, so more leniency should be given. All fair enough.

Your final comment is a cheap shot. You say 'respectfully' and then put a barb in about not knowing better for good measure. I don't see the respect in doing that. That sort of thing is why I don't comment much, I'm not interested in a slinging match. Throwing put-downs around. No thank you.

I come here hoping for good news about the WT, as unoptimistic as I might be, always hoping against hope.

 

[Glenji95]

Can't make it happen if players want to stay where they are. All it will take is for the Eels to come back with a competitive offer. The ball is in their caught, we have done all we can do.

True but there’s only one more thing we can do and that’s up the offer from our end too to see if that’ll entice him to leave but with Eels the more they keep the more they’ll lose too e.g. if they do retain Papali”I they could lose Matterson, Paulo and a couple more forwards depending on how much they plan on paying Papali”I but honestly if he does stay I would give Paulo an offer I think him and Nofa are good friends so it could push him over to us