Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Bula]

Foran - against.

 

[Tigerwould]

Garner in the centre’s ?


Thanks JT, Kyle Lovett revisited.

Think you’ll find Garner came to West’s as a centre

way better than Lovett , don’t think he would be as good as Kurt Capewell

 

[Viking Warrior]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

 

[Tigerwould]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney

Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

 

[balmain boy]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

He's not on 900k. That just journalistic crap.

 

[Tigerwould]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

He's not on 900k. That just journalistic crap.

Yep you’re right. Got those $ from media reports. I just looked at Zero tackle they have him down as $700K.

 

[Newtown]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

He's not on 900k. That just journalistic crap.


Yep you’re right. Got those $ from media reports. I just looked at Zero tackle they have him down as $700K.

Then how much would WT have to throw in to secure Hodgson? Surely $200K seems a fair deal.

 

[Tigerwould]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

He's not on 900k. That just journalistic crap.


Yep you’re right. Got those $ from media reports. I just looked at Zero tackle they have him down as $700K.

Then how much would WT have to throw in to secure Hodgson? Surely $200K seems a fair deal.

Who knows, just had a look at the Raiders forum they say he is on $850. Is his player manger Moses? If that’s the case all sorts of shenanigans would be going on.

 

[WT2K]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

He's not on 900k. That just journalistic crap.


Yep you’re right. Got those $ from media reports. I just looked at Zero tackle they have him down as $700K.

Then how much would WT have to throw in to secure Hodgson? Surely $200K seems a fair deal.


Who knows, just had a look at the Raiders forum they say he is on $850. Is his player manger Moses? If that’s the case all sorts of shenanigans would be going on.

Yea, he's with that Management company

 

[Tigerwould]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

He's not on 900k. That just journalistic crap.


Yep you’re right. Got those $ from media reports. I just looked at Zero tackle they have him down as $700K.

Then how much would WT have to throw in to secure Hodgson? Surely $200K seems a fair deal.


Who knows, just had a look at the Raiders forum they say he is on $850. Is his player manger Moses? If that’s the case all sorts of shenanigans would be going on.

Yea, he's with that Management company

Well it would be hard to get a straight answer out of him. No wonder this is going on as long as it has.

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

It does matter what he’s on in Canberra we just need to put a value on him and offer that much. We don’t need to clean up their cap mess

 

[Geo]

It does matter what he’s on in Canberra we just need to put a value on him and offer that much. We don’t need to clean up their cap mess

They have.. but it appears Canberra won’t stump up the difference which is the sticking point..

Now the choice seems to be either increase our offer or move on..

 

[yeahcaz]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

Lol how ? Mahoney is arguably a top 3 hooker in the comp and if you don’t think top 3, he’s definitely top 5 and he’s 23. Sign him for 2023 and you’d have him in the prime of his career, around our young and improving forward pack. He’d have already played for Queensland if parra weren’t so stupid. 600k is a bargain and id honestly offer 700 off the bat

 

[Viking Warrior]

It does matter what he’s on in Canberra we just need to put a value on him and offer that much. We don’t need to clean up their cap mess

They have.. but it appears Canberra won’t stump up the difference which is the sticking point..

Now the choice seems to be either increase our offer or move on..

If we moved on who would you like to see the club target?

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

It does matter what he’s on in Canberra we just need to put a value on him and offer that much. We don’t need to clean up their cap mess

They have.. but it appears Canberra won’t stump up the difference which is the sticking point..

Now the choice seems to be either increase our offer or move on..

So move on. If we’ve valued him at a price put that should be it…

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

It does matter what he’s on in Canberra we just need to put a value on him and offer that much. We don’t need to clean up their cap mess

They have.. but it appears Canberra won’t stump up the difference which is the sticking point..

Now the choice seems to be either increase our offer or move on..

If we moved on who would you like to see the club target?

Api

 

[Ultimate Warrior]

So who's the back up if we miss out on Hodgson? Wouldn't mind blowing the dogs outta the water and Signing Mahoney


Personally I don’t think it’s worth throwing big $ at Mahoney.
The dogs have offered him $600K . Hodgson is supposedly on $900K and we offering $500K , with Canberra paying him $400K not to be there. If Canberra put in $400k then great. If no, then have Liddle/Simpkin.

Lol how ? Mahoney is arguably a top 3 hooker in the comp and if you don’t think top 3, he’s definitely top 5 and he’s 23. Sign him for 2023 and you’d have him in the prime of his career, around our young and improving forward pack. He’d have already played for Queensland if parra weren’t so stupid. 600k is a bargain and id honestly offer 700 off the bat

Mahoney is a fraud. Leave it

 

[jadtiger]

It does matter what he’s on in Canberra we just need to put a value on him and offer that much. We don’t need to clean up their cap mess

They have.. but it appears Canberra won’t stump up the difference which is the sticking point..

Now the choice seems to be either increase our offer or move on..

If it was my decision i would move on which i am sure would not be a popular decision on here.

 

[tiger_one]

Foran - against.

hahaha I seen what you did there ....... and I'm all 4it.