Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

tunks said:
Re Tristan Reilly.
List of guys who couldn't make waratahs;
Ben Kennedy
Tyson Frizell
Luke Keary
JWH
Not to mention Dave Furner's rugby career didn't go past u21 aus team.

Let's give the new kid a chance.
Click to expand...
Rugby is way more about who you know , and what school you went to than league .
It’s the biggest reason the Wallabies are a second tier nation now .
They will only poach league talent when it’s undeniable , yet if the choice is player x has 75% skill of player Y , but X went to joeys , and Y went to Granville high school . Then Y will never get the spot .
It wasn’t as pronounced when that sport went professional in 96 because professionalism hadn’t caused the divide in skill yet . And 99 and even 03 was still much of the same . But eventually elitism took over , and now that sport is barely even financial anymore .
 
I swear Sheens has been good for one out of left field signing every year he's been with us and they rarely ever work out. Like when we signed that fastest dude in rugby some years back and he maybe played 1 or 2 first grade games for us. Or some random unit from an Island nation who gets hyped and then does nothing in reserves.

I mean I don't hate taking these chances, but why not just sign good NRL players or youngsters. Koroisau and Papali'i are the types we need to be signing if we want to move the club forward and attract others. There's a less than 1% chance this Reilly bloke ends up being an above-average first grader. If we're Melbourne/Penrith this makes sense to round out a roster, for us just feels pointless.
 
Lukic said:
I swear Sheens has been good for one out of left field signing every year he's been with us and they rarely ever work out. Like when we signed that fastest dude in rugby some years back and he maybe played 1 or 2 first grade games for us. Or some random unit from an Island nation who gets hyped and then does nothing in reserves.

I mean I don't hate taking these chances, but why not just sign good NRL players or youngsters. Koroisau and Papali'i are the types we need to be signing if we want to move the club forward and attract others. There's a less than 1% chance this Reilly bloke ends up being an above-average first grader. If we're Melbourne/Penrith this makes sense to round out a roster, for us just feels pointless.
Click to expand...
Sheens was reported to have been interested in Miller ex rugby, 27 years old and now at the Sharks doing really well at fullback and 5/8. He played rugby 7s for Australia, so has Reilly. Sheens obviously has an eye for talent. Tuiaki ring a bell?
 
Lukic said:
I swear Sheens has been good for one out of left field signing every year he's been with us and they rarely ever work out. Like when we signed that fastest dude in rugby some years back and he maybe played 1 or 2 first grade games for us. Or some random unit from an Island nation who gets hyped and then does nothing in reserves.

I mean I don't hate taking these chances, but why not just sign good NRL players or youngsters. Koroisau and Papali'i are the types we need to be signing if we want to move the club forward and attract others. There's a less than 1% chance this Reilly bloke ends up being an above-average first grader. If we're Melbourne/Penrith this makes sense to round out a roster, for us just feels pointless.
Click to expand...
WHAT a sad life you have. You would know nothing about this rugby player yet you claim he will be a dud. Actually we have signed Koroisau and Papali'i. We signed an unknown school boy footballer a few years ago. No doubt you would have moaned about this signing as well. If you don't know who this person was, his name was Marshall. Get a grip and see how things work out instead of crapping on the club every chance you get.
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
Sheens was reported to have been interested in Miller ex rugby, 27 years old and now at the Sharks doing really well at fullback and 5/8. He played rugby 7s for Australia, so has Reilly. Sheens obviously has an eye for talent. Tuiaki ring a bell?
Click to expand...

Wish I could hang my hat hat on a lucky decision I made 20 years ago...
Ryan O'Hara, Danny Galea, Sam Harris, Jamahl Lolesi ring a bell?
For every feather in Sheens cap from back in the day, There's plenty of negatives.

ps: They Played Tuiaki at 2nd row for about 2 Years before they worked out he was a winger.
 
colinbh said:
WHAT a sad life you have. You would know nothing about this rugby player yet you claim he will be a dud. Actually we have signed Koroisau and Papali'i. We signed an unknown school boy footballer a few years ago. No doubt you would have moaned about this signing as well. If you don't know who this person was, his name was Marshall. Get a grip and see how things work out instead of crapping on the club every chance you get.
Click to expand...

I don't know anything about him either, But there aren't many rugby OB's that make good in League.
Centre is the hardest position to defend in League - It's wear all the hard decisions are made...
In union - they get a fairly easy run in comparison.

Worst case scenario, He has a bit of toe and size...
Might make a good winger....
 
batboy said:
Wish I could hang my hat hat on a lucky decision I made 20 years ago...
Ryan O'Hara, Danny Galea, Sam Harris, Jamahl Lolesi ring a bell?
For every feather in Sheens cap from back in the day, There's plenty of negatives.

ps: They Played Tuiaki at 2nd row for about 2 Years before they worked out he was a winger.
Click to expand...
Marshall, Ayshford, Moltzen, Fifita, Heighinton, Lui, Daley, Stuart (ex rugby), Clyde Wiki, the Walters bros. The list continues .................................
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 413 (members: 26, guests: 387)
Back
Top