Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Tiger_Yoshi]

One glance at the Parramatta forum would confirm this.

Ron Massey Cup level.

Only the WT would trade an up and coming player for a has been..

 

[diedpretty]

should have clarified sorry
- laurie approached penrith as tigers and superleague was the only other teams interested
- waqa blake was offered at this stage deal wont happen for a player trade, may happen for a $$$ fee though before aug 7, jake unlikely to be at the club next year

I hope by only considering a fee for Simpkin that the club has some genuine signings and need the openings in the top 30. Otherwise it doesn't make sense.

 

[Tom Shines]

Only the WT would trade an up and coming player for a has been..

He is the sort of player that Wests Tigers sign..

1. Below Average
2. Way past his peak

 

[TYGA]

Better not entertaining a swap for Simpkin. Small fee and create a spot for a kid in the top 30. Eels have high end talent limited backup.

 

[gregjm87]

Fox reporting Sanders to Raiders
Also Asiata looking to return to Aust, we could do worse?

 

[barnzee]

Look on the brightside.
Soon you'll get to move over to the Parra forum.
I hear the I.Q's much higher over there.

Must be school holidays

 

[tony soprano]

Better not entertaining a swap for Simpkin. Small fee and create a spot for a kid in the top 30. Eels have high end talent limited backup.

Fainu early would be good

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

Good ol' InsideManNRL on Twitter saying he's hearing Fainu brothers to Bulldogs. The disclaimer is he gets as many wrong as right.

 

[Todd Packer]

Must be school holidays

So far you've called me young and thin.
Thank you. Nobody has been that kind in their description of me for a very long time.

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

just to echo what someone else has said
- morris has been identified as a potential assistant
- holbrook more likely to replace dean young in NQ
- dogs arent in the race for fainu’s, commited to burton at 6 and sexton at 7 for next year, saving all of their money for haas

- simpkin to parra could happen, early word was waqa blake potentially swapped

- laurie begged to go back to penrith, tigers offered a 1 year deal, panthers 1 year plus team option

- noffa is being heavily shopped, club has said no guarantee of first grade next year

- blore shopping is now off table

Following on from @kade7 mail ...

Historical media reports indicate Ben Hornby & John Morris are off contract after this season at the Rabbitohs, Steve Georgallis is in the 3rd year of a 3-year deal at the Cowboys, while Josh Hannay still has another year on his deal at the Sharks.

So if Holbrook is out of the equation, we may stand a chance of landing one of Hornby or Morris or the very experienced Georgallis. We would have to entice with a much superior $$$ package and probably advise they would be main Assistant Coach.

 

[Spartan117]

MORE WTs Recruitment Incompetence

EELS LOSE YOUNG GUN HALFBACK

The Raiders have reportedly poached one of the most in-demand halfbacks from the Eels, with Ethan Sanders signing a contract with the Canberra club.

According to the SMH, the young gun will join Ricky Stuart’s Raiders from 2025, putting pen to paper on a two-year deal.

Sanders starred for NSW in the under 19s Origin and was awarded Player of the Match honours in Parramatta’s SG Ball grand final victory.

He remain contracted with the Eels until the end of the 2024 season, but Parramatta powerbrokers reportedly may allow him to depart early.

Sanders would have faced stiff competition for first grade minutes, with both Mitchell Moses and Dylan Brown signing long-term contracts.

 

[crazycat]

you don’t think Naden would be a better option?

I do

Sadly Laurie has lost all interest. You can see it in the way he plays now.
Naden may similarly be wanting to leave. Which is actually quite sad because Naden can play, can tackle better then almost everyone below 6 and really is what we need long term.

Our team management hasn't worked with Laurie or Naden.

 

[Curly_Tiger]

Why would we let Maumalo go and then replace him with Blake?

Again, should have kept Ken until the end of the year.

What happened to Kenny, has he played a game on the Goldie?

 

[Spartan117]

So much money in the Cap, A good forward pack and the Benji factor should have been enough to convince this guy if was open to leaving the Eels.

How does this club constantly fail???

 

[Needaname]

MORE WTs Recruitment Incompetence

EELS LOSE YOUNG GUN HALFBACK

The Raiders have reportedly poached one of the most in-demand halfbacks from the Eels, with Ethan Sanders signing a contract with the Canberra club.

According to the SMH, the young gun will join Ricky Stuart’s Raiders from 2025, putting pen to paper on a two-year deal.

Sanders starred for NSW in the under 19s Origin and was awarded Player of the Match honours in Parramatta’s SG Ball grand final victory.

He remain contracted with the Eels until the end of the 2024 season, but Parramatta powerbrokers reportedly may allow him to depart early.

Sanders would have faced stiff competition for first grade minutes, with both Mitchell Moses and Dylan Brown signing long-term contracts.

How can this deal actually be signed off?
Is it different rules for junior players contracted long term but not on top 30 contracts. If so god help us with our juniors.

 

[gregjm87]

So much money in the Cap, A good forward pack and the Benji factor should have been enough to convince this guy if was open to leaving the Eels.

How does this club constantly fail???

I think we need to stop considering "the Benji factor" as a positive. It's more likely a negative.

 

[Camel2281]

Asiata could be a good Lock for us

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Better not entertaining a swap for Simpkin. Small fee and create a spot for a kid in the top 30. Eels have high end talent limited backup.

I strongly support a small fee and the vacancy created in our Top 30 or one of our juniors. It is the only way we will keep them.

 

[thegbone]

Looks like Jakes dad been rubbishing the club on twitter, daresay hes out the door

 

[Tom Shines]

I do

Sadly Laurie has lost all interest. You can see it in the way he plays now.
Naden may similarly be wanting to leave. Which is actually quite sad because Naden can play, can tackle better then almost everyone below 6 and really is what we need long term.

Our team management hasn't worked with Laurie or Naden.

Now that the AJ wing experiment is hopefully over forever…

Naden is signed another two years, and I can’t see other teams being all that interested based on what he has shown here… so hope he is depth moving forward and not pencilled in next year as a statyer … he seems very ill disciplined in my opinion …

I’ve never thought Laurie was an NRL fullback… although I thought they may have given him a go at 6 before now… desperate times and all that …However .. I’m not going to be shedding any tears over him moving on… he won’t be seeing a lot of first grade at Penrith