Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[TurnStyle]

I only want our club to sign players who for one , want to be here with out a huge fight Over money .
I would like to see players stay or come to this club thinking we will be competitive and play for us for fair coin , I know it won’t happen as there are players that think they are worth much more than they are , EG
Dylan Brown , Newcastle 10 years 13 million , that is down and out crazy , Brown at present is worth no more than 750 , he was crap in Parra first game , and was bog average last season...

Dylan Brown doesn't think he is worth $13M for 10 years: he knows he is because that's what Newcastle is going to pay him.

 

[Spartan117]

Dylan Brown doesn't think he is worth $13M for 10 years: he knows he is because that's what Newcastle is going to pay him.

Couldn't happen to a nicer club, good luck Newcastle with 10 years of Salary cap issues

 

[Spartan117]

You’re setting yourself up for an almighty disappointment.

Im not one to give up to early on an outcome,

This isnt the Pascoe regime anymore

 

[JC99]

Gonna be the most Tigers thing ever when we lose both Galvin and Latu and end up with Sullivan as our 6

 

[Buttface]

I saw an article on Fox sports today where Isaac Moses said he will be taking Galvin to market on 1 November.

That being the case, Galvin may well sign elsewhere for 2027. If he does, I wouldn’t be letting him go for nothing, but I would prefer to swap him for a player we need for the 2026 season as opposed to making him play reserve grade out of spite.

I’d leave all options open, but it would need to be a good swap.

 

[Buttface]

moses is trying to beat up interest in galvin
if anyone wants to pay him anything close to a million dollars , be our guest

a very good crop of young halves are about to emerge and galvin will fall back to the field , trying to get his pay day before it happens

ethan sanders and strange

mitchell woods - love that gus made those comments about galvin to take the attention away from woods , who is a star

coby black

joey walsh

keagan russell smith

thomas duffy

zac herdegen -

onitoni large

throw in jonah pezet

plenty of options , the media just turning the screw as usual

It’s a shame we don’t have one of them on our team.

 

[TCL]

Lachie's rapid ascent is ill timed for our salary cap strategy. He will command too much money for us to even be the highest bidder.

So far I have not liked the look of how the gameplan looks with him at 6 anyway. They are weaponising his fitness by making him run himself stupid criss crossing across the field to create artificial overlaps and that has worked almost every time but he's busting a gut so hard to get there that by the time he gets there he isn't composed enough to calculate the correct decision. He has pulled the wrong reign on almost every possible try scoring opportunity created by that structure.

It appears to have been their entire attacking gameplan and it relies entirely on not only his fitness but him being an expert at instantly summarising the right play to make. His strength as a player is getting the ball early with time and space and threatening with his feet. He instinctively is a catch and run player which when put in a situation where most of the time the correct move is catch and pass he is missing the queue each time.

Benji and the team have worked against his natural instincts with this gameplan imo. I am worried if they don't have a plan b this year. Galvin is going to take ages to develop the ability to instantly catch and pass to the correct option. He's going to need to guess.

He is fit, but not fast. He doesn’t have footwork, he is not threatening with his feet. He has a fend which worked for him in the jnrs because he is tall and has reach. He can pass and put players into a hole. If the outside player knows how to spot and run at a hole.

 

[crazycat]

Dylan Brown doesn't think he is worth $13M for 10 years: he knows he is because that's what Newcastle is going to pay him.

Yep that's the market value right there.

Ash Taylor was worth 1m because he got 1m.

Ofcourse that's not the true player value.

Penrith, Easts and Storm get players to stay for unders and perform. I am completely lost as to why they stay at Easts.

 

[Telltails]

Not sure how a bottom club can build a decent roster to get off the bottom while ever the current system allows managers to offer any of their decent players up for sale while still contracted forcing ridiculous contract stipulations to have any hope of retaining. It has to effect the team, the player and leaves a club treading water trying to keep players happy without knowing what their true intentions are - "I've left it in the hands of my manager"
You can lay crap on the club for not being able to get off the bottom but it is becoming more apparent that unless things change we will remain a transition club for old talent, new talent, and those who don't give a crap - that pays well for the visit.

 

[bptiger 0]

I feel everything Richie mentioned re Moses and Luia combo is perfectly plausible.
But Anasta countered with ‘didn’t Luai leave Penrith and his partnership with Nathan to be the main man’?
I guess it’s an option if he feels it isn’t working at the Tigers but I doubt that’s what his about.
If the Eels are serious though, they would try and sign Luai before Galvin.

I just don’t get this so called rush for players to join the slimmmy eels , if anything BROWN leaving should be ringing bells he could have squeezed a bit more money out of them if he wanted to stay , BUT what the hell do they have that everyone once to go there , they push Galvin out and he wants to go back the kid needs to see a doctor or his parents need mental help

 

[WswWt]

Not sure how a bottom club can build a decent roster to get off the bottom while ever the current system allows managers to offer any of their decent players up for sale while still contracted forcing ridiculous contract stipulations to have any hope of retaining. It has to effect the team, the player and leaves a club treading water trying to keep players happy without knowing what their true intentions are - "I've left it in the hands of my manager"
You can lay crap on the club for not being able to get off the bottom but it is becoming more apparent that unless things change we will remain a transition club for old talent, new talent, and those who don't give a crap - that pays well for the visit.

The NRL won’t fix anything. It’s there for all to see and they still won’t do anything.
It makes them money that’s why, the more Fox make on click bait stories, the more the NRL can ask for at the next TV contract.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Not sure how a bottom club can build a decent roster to get off the bottom while ever the current system allows managers to offer any of their decent players up for sale while still contracted forcing ridiculous contract stipulations to have any hope of retaining. It has to effect the team, the player and leaves a club treading water trying to keep players happy without knowing what their true intentions are - "I've left it in the hands of my manager"
You can lay crap on the club for not being able to get off the bottom but it is becoming more apparent that unless things change we will remain a transition club for old talent, new talent, and those who don't give a crap - that pays well for the visit.

We have Galvin for two years on a modest contract and all supporters should be comfortable with that outcome. Richardson has already enforced the club's boundary by advising Galvin will see out his contract.

 

[Spartan117]

Gonna be the most Tigers thing ever when we lose both Galvin and Latu and end up with Sullivan as our 6

That's our trauma talking.

This time it will be different.

 

[Tiger001]

Lachie's rapid ascent is ill timed for our salary cap strategy. He will command too much money for us to even be the highest bidder.

So far I have not liked the look of how the gameplan looks with him at 6 anyway. They are weaponising his fitness by making him run himself stupid criss crossing across the field to create artificial overlaps and that has worked almost every time but he's busting a gut so hard to get there that by the time he gets there he isn't composed enough to calculate the correct decision. He has pulled the wrong reign on almost every possible try scoring opportunity created by that structure.

It appears to have been their entire attacking gameplan and it relies entirely on not only his fitness but him being an expert at instantly summarising the right play to make. His strength as a player is getting the ball early with time and space and threatening with his feet. He instinctively is a catch and run player which when put in a situation where most of the time the correct move is catch and pass he is missing the queue each time.

Benji and the team have worked against his natural instincts with this gameplan imo. I am worried if they don't have a plan b this year. Galvin is going to take ages to develop the ability to instantly catch and pass to the correct option. He's going to need to guess.

We got enough contracts wrapping up at the end of this year to cover Galvin

The only real risk is the paper bags and sombrero 🤠

 

[Telltails]

We have Galvin for two years on a modest contract and all supporters should be comfortable with that outcome. Richardson has already enforced the club's boundary by advising Galvin will see out his contract.

Why would anyone be comfortable with knowing that a key player we have the provisions to keep and are trying to build a squad around after the the first game of the season, is being offered up by his manager while the media is discussing his likely destination?
That is not the formula for effectively building a squad to get off the bottom of the ladder regardless of whether he sees out his contract or not. All it does is place doubt about everything the club/ coach are trying to sell.

 

[Tiger001]

Newcastle as stupid and they will suffer.

We just need to book on guard from poachers.

Protect our best youngsters

This is the worst kind of Kick the Can down the Road

 

[PabloX]

Idk about this lock business. I’m yet to hear one commentator suggest such a move. The only place I have heard he’s destined for the forwards is this forum. But everyone seems to be reading writing on the all for us signing May, yet there’s writing on the wall for Galvin leaving too

- Asks for a release twice last year
- Spits the dummy in the dressing room after the game
- Won’t commit to the club, uses the old “Leaving it up to my manager”
- Management notifies other clubs of their intentions to take him to the market

If you were looking for indications that a player and his management wanted out of a club the first chance they got, you couldn’t find any better examples of the above. The question will be what will do with him in 26.

Swap him for a gun back rower with the club he signs for

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Why would anyone be comfortable with knowing that a key player we have the provisions to keep and are trying to build a squad around after the the first game of the season, is being offered up by his manager while the media is discussing his likely destination?
That is not the formula for effectively building a squad to get off the bottom of the ladder regardless of whether he sees out his contract or not. All it does is place doubt about everything the club/ coach are trying to sell.

The manager can "offer him up" but he is not going anywhere. Richardson has enforced boundaries. 2 years is a long time. We have him on a modest contract. The next 2 years are probably going to be his best as a 6. Fainu imo is a better prospect at 6 or 7 so while you may consider him a "key", we have other keys including young Mason. Our pathways is strong so if he does go, we have options.

 

[Lestronge]

Yep that's the market value right there.

Ash Taylor was worth 1m because he got 1m.

Ofcourse that's not the true player value.

Penrith, Easts and Storm get players to stay for unders and perform. I am completely lost as to why they stay at Easts.

I think any player who has Moses as their manager should be considered off limits , to the point that our players should be warned about him , and our refusal to deal with him .
He’s just bad news . At the moment his whole and sole focus is getting as many players to the sea eagles as he can to help support seibold . Also his nephew and his success would be also a priority .
The family chose Moses and his firm , there’s not much more you can do , but make a competitive offer , understand whether or not it has a chance of success ( a real chance , not a stringing along to screw everyone over bar the team who signed him ) success .
I personally think we should ascertain Galvins real intentions , and adjust accordingly ie. prioritise Latu if it comes to that .
Of all the players Moses has steered away from us , really only Tedesco had immediate success , and it’s taken his nephew till he’s 29 to break into the origin team , so 9 years. With just as much failure at his club as he would have had here .
He ruined Woods career, even Marty Taupau was on a huge trajectory at our club , and whilst he had a decent career at manly , he was on a rocket to the moon when he was playing for us .
He almost torched the career of Seibold as well by backdoor negotiating him to the broncos .
He convinces his players to chase the money at all costs , and if love to know his true strike rate with advancing their careers . Not just here , but other clubs as well .

 

[PabloX]

So the Roosters want him, but we don’t ?
Surely we could use releasing Klemmer as leverage to sign Molo if we wanted him ?
Bringing in Molo and Taylan May would make us much stronger and increase our depth substantially.

The Roosters didn't want May, but we did...make it make sense.

We need centres and backrowers