Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Iron Fist said:
Kid is 17. Let him be a kid and come through properly. Or do you want another Galvin scenario?

He’s on a rugby scholarship which would be rescinded if he’s not available to play rugby for the school.

No one can predict a players NRL or sporting future, but graduating from a GPS school and looked after as an ‘old boy’ is the best thing for a boy right now.
Click to expand...
It’s another Galvin scenario I want to avoid.
I don’t even want to hear his name for a couple more years.
 
BUGSY MALONE said:
The way I see it after all of my initial disappointment has now settled, is this:
1.Lachlan Galvin is contracted to the Wests Tigers until the end of 2026
2. Lachlan Galvin is without doubt a top 17 First Grade player
3. I want the Wests Tigers to play finals in 2025
4. To achieve the above Lachlan Galvin MUST be selected to play First Grade (next week).
All the comments about him being part of the 2024 Wooden Spoon side does not wash, as in 2025 he can now play alongside Luai, May, Bird, Hunt, Turuva etc. who were not playing with the Tiges in 2024. Benji has to override the players from next week and select Lachlan Galvin in 1st grade. I am concerned about this Mondays game against the Eels and if we lose, sadly Isaac Moses will be laughing his head off.
Click to expand...
Aren’t you the bloke who wants to wrecking ball our club?
Been enjoying the wins have ya? 😎
 
Tito Santana said:
I think everyone can understand him wanting to see what he can get on the market however giving your reason as being youre have no faith in the coach is disgraceful.

Hold him to ransom if he wants an early release.

Dogs - get Burton. Can come play with his ex Penrith mates.
Parra - they have no one.
Manly - Olakautu or id do a deal for Paseka AND Bullemor.
Roosters - Wong or Chrichton.
Click to expand...
Starting to think Tito has split personalities.


Addition- I'd contemplate Kikau from the Dogs.
 
jadtiger said:
I completely disagree with ever selecting him again in first grade.I want players who are proud to play for the club each week and play as a team.Galvin is NOT a team player despite his talent.
Click to expand...
Whilst I don't want to show him the door I think as long suffering supporters we deserve to have our best 17 players selected each week. Use him whilst we have him under contract so we can finally make the finals. A complete waste if we make our point and have him playing at Lidcombe Oval every 2nd week.
 
Batmans Parents said:
Spare us the empty platitudes. You can say he needs to be selected but you can’t specifically say why.

What has he done this year to warrant automatic selection? His kicking game has been very poor, his decision making in attack has been questionable at best, his defence has been average and now his teammates (and probably the coaching staff) despise him. Not doubting the kid is talented but he isn’t showing it this year outside of the Dolphins game.

Your vision is not based on the reality of how he has played so far this season nor the wider reality of his relationship with the team and coaching staff which is entirely on him and his management.
Click to expand...
I clearly stated why he needs to play 1st grade.
 
The Chad said:
Starting to think Tito has split personalities.


Addition- I'd contemplate Kikau from the Dogs.
Click to expand...
If Galvin was to decide to go to the Bulldogs, there is no chance Gus would offer any of his contracted players as a swap deal, he would play hard ball and stick with what he already has until 2027.
Where the Eels and possible the Sea Eagles would be much more desperate to get their hands on Galvin much sooner.
 
Last edited:
How would people feel if Galvin just came out and said "I've always wanted to play for Parra."? Because I think that's a part of this. He grew up following them, dreamt of representing them, got shafted by them but still wants to go back. Plus having both Isaac and Mitch in his ear, Brown leaving, it all falls into place for 2026. I just hope we make him honour his contract all of next year and make them wait as we had to with Luai.

In May news, Wests Tigers have told Taylan that he has a contract next year if he undergoes rehab. He is not looking at other club offers and is willing to do what is needed to play with his brother. Tyrone has also reached out to the club for a minimal-dollar deal. They are desperate to play together in 2026. Watch this space.
 
Vicious said:
If Galvin was to decide to go to the Bulldogs, there is no chance Gus would offer any of his contracted players as a swap deal, he would play hard ball and stick with what he already has until 2027.
Where the Eels and possible the Sea Eagles would be much more resort get their hands on Galvin much sooner.
Click to expand...
manly will need someone to replace DCE
if they can sign galvin or fogarty they would sign galvin as they have brooks already contracted

no idea who parramatta could possibly offer us, Lomax ? Hopgood maybe ?
 
BUGSY MALONE said:
I clearly stated why he needs to play 1st grade.
Click to expand...

No you didn’t. You said he’s contracted until 2026, a top 17 player and needs to play in order for us to reach the finals. That’s not “why” he needs to play. What has he done to warrant automatic selection based on his on field play?

I told you exactly what he’s been doing this year in terms of his on field play. You made a bunch of generic statements with nothing to back them up and are now running from that. So either present something beyond empty statements or go away and let the adults discuss.
 
at present AD offers similar to galvin in the 6 / 7 role however AD probably defends slightly better and is committed to the club and goal kicks.
A centre pairing right now of naden and starford is probably as goodna pairing as we can come up with at present
we don't need galvin at present to win games of football he was terrible against Newcastle
 
BAGNF05 said:
Kikau absolutely fills a massive hole in our team. Sam Fainu has been ordinary/ injured.
Click to expand...

I think Fainu hasn’t been used well.
Until last game Galvin and Luai cramped his side and never used him, when Galvin moved more right edge and Luai stayed left Fainu had his best game of the year. Galvin also picks run v pass to Fainu. It’s congested & disjointed when Galvin moved across.

Leave Luai to the left, let Api own the middle and let the halfback own the right with Bula roving. This should use our attacking strengths better and allow for structure to function.
 
BAGNF05 said:
In all our games we’ve struggled in the forwards for large patches. Without May we’d be cooked.
Click to expand...
Several things...

Firstly, we HAVE May. So what's your point?

Secondly, Pole is averaging 146m a game himself and big minutes.

Thirdly, I said 'out of the backfield', referring to out first 2/3 tackles, taken by our outside backs, who are proving very effective.

And finally, I'd argue that your entire premise that 'In all our games we’ve struggled in the forwards for large patches' isn't based in reality at all. And if it is, then why not suggest a forward...?
 
Kelce68 said:
Several things...

Firstly, we HAVE May. So what's your point?

Secondly, Pole is averaging 146m a game himself and big minutes.

Thirdly, I said 'out of the backfield', referring to out first 2/3 tackles, taken by our outside backs, who are proving very effective.

And finally, I'd argue that your entire premise that 'In all our games we’ve struggled in the forwards for large patches' isn't based in reality at all. And if it is, then why not suggest a forward...?
Click to expand...
It’s called a forward pack.

May is leading us well.

Pole has improved but I’d argue still has a way to go in terms of consistency.

Then it falls away.

I was talking about go forward and wingers play a role in that. Turuva first class. Skelton is now looking lame.

Any club administrator with a brain would sign To’o.

We also need forwards and there’s no rule that says you can’t have both.
 
I have a Galvin theory and it’s the only one I can make fit to make sense of this situation. He will be at the Eels. He and his family are life long Parra fans. So much so he left Wests juniors to go to Parra. They didn’t rate him so he want back to West. Now Parra see he can play they want him. He can’t just come out and say it’s always been my dream to play for Parra and I only want to go there, otherwise they low ball him on dollars, so his grub of manager manufactures a story to get him the dollars at Parra and an early release. I can’t make anything else make sense.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 1,135 (members: 18, guests: 1,117)
Back
Top