Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

BEN Barba has continued his fantastic form for St Helens, helping the Super League club to a 36-18 win over Castleford in the sixth round of the Challenge Cup with a hat-trick of tries.

The former Canterbury and Cronulla fullback scored three tries — to take his season’s tally to 15 — and created two others as Saints helped erase the memory of their humiliating 53-10 defeat at Castleford in last year’s corresponding tie.

Barba has been in sparkling form this season as ongoing speculation links the star fullback to a possible NRL return.

His impact in the Super League has been enormous.

St Helens are a shadow of the side that struggled under Keiron Cunningham and, although most of the credit for the transformation should go to his successor Justin Holbrook on the anniversary of his appointment, the Barba effect cannot be overstated.

His electric pace, dazzling footwork and eye for an opening proved has proved to be a lethal cocktail for Super League defences this year and Castleford certainly had no answer to his array of brilliant skills.

The Tigers did not perform that badly and only two long-range tries, both against the run of play, separated the teams at half-time — but they have still to recapture their sparkle of 2017.

The Saints fans taunted the home side by chanting “one-season wonders” and Daryl Powell’s men have certainly been hit hard by the absence of an injured Luke Gale, the reigning Man of Steel, and are still sorely missing last year’s runner-up Zak Hardaker.

If Hardaker and Gale were the stars of 2017, then the Saints duo of Barba and Danny Richardson have stepped very nicely into their shoes.
 
Holmes after a dusty start, has scored a 90m try of a kick return beating about 4 defenders.
Layed on another, should have been 2 only Feke dropped the ball over the line, according to video ref
 
@ said:
Holmes after a dusty start, has scored a 90m try of a kick return beating about 4 defenders.
Layed on another, should have been 2 only Feke dropped the ball over the line, according to video ref

In fairness to the video ref he was probably stuck with that call due to the on field no try call. Had the ref called try on field he probably would have got the benefit of the doubt.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
https://twitter.com/NRLFANTV_/status/995562715027464192

Is Curtis still trolling reporters?

The lurker said we are after him too for this year. It only takes one to start the rumour and the rest follow.
I hope its true though.

We were supposedly getting Curtis Rona last year but that never happened.
 
Come on. Just one please! Rona, Holmes, Folau, Barba- can at least one of these be true!! This thread is like Jarrad Hayne - starts so promising but delivers precious little!😜
 
I do like the idea of Curtis Rona though .. a big tall strong fast centre .. something we don't have. He scored for the NSW Waratahs against NZ Crusaders yesterday .. but unfortunately for the Waratahs they blew a 29-0 lead, and lost 32-29 .. wow !!

I think the rumour will come through this time .. :stuck_out_tongue:
 
I think he would come onto Nofa's wing as much as I hate to say it…

1\. Corey Thompson
2\. Curtis Rona
3\. Mahe Fonua
4\. Esan Marsters
5\. Malakai Watene Zelezniak
 
I don't see any promising rugby players changing in the next 18 months.

There is a world cup next year and there are lots of opportunities to make the Wallabies side.
 
Rona is a solid player, not a world beater. Been out of the NRL for nearly two seasons, is he better than what we have…not sure on that one
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Thanks GEO. A simple yes or no would nice.

Nothing official yet mate

Just remember ladies and gents , Meaney is just potential at this stage

And we have learnt the hard way the last 5 years about potential = real ability at NRL level

Happy Tiger, Potential is word alot of people use a fair to describe very good players but some players never live up to the hype, and we have had our fair share of these players over the years. But it also depends on the type player, if he has the hunger to put in or do the extra work. Some the best young players are the ones that don't stand out all the time.

Totally agree , the amount of blokes from my era who you thought were going to be superstars and didn't , yet blokes who were the grinders and just kept working at it

I've probably said this a million times but Willie Carne was the perfect example

Pretty sure he didn't even make 1st 15 at IGS , wouldn't have even been in the Top 10 quickest guys in my grade

4 years later playing SOO for Qld and a real flyer
 
The thing about potential is that it means nothing if your recruitment team doesnt know what they are doing.

If you trust the guys whose job it is to identify future NRL talent that is all that matters.

At the moment and for the first time in many years i think we have a coach and a recruitment team that actually know what they are doing.

If they choose a Meaney then ill take it he has the goods.
 
@ said:
Rona is a solid player, not a world beater. Been out of the NRL for nearly two seasons, is he better than what we have…not sure on that one

41 tries in 57 games not a world beater? He’s an absolute country mile better than who we have there now.
 
@ said:
@ said:
Rona is a solid player, not a world beater. Been out of the NRL for nearly two seasons, is he better than what we have…not sure on that one

41 tries in 57 games not a world beater? He’s an absolute country mile better than who we have there now.

Nearly two years out of the game and yes he was good at the dogs in a very good side. He is probably better than what we have, but I would be using that money to buy a standout no1 or backrower. Anyway I am sure Cleary knows a lot more than me
 
Happy to sign Rona and offer Luke Garner from ISP a contract to round off our squad for 2018.

I like Kevin but ESP is probably where his future is.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top